• We're looking for artists. Direct message Dr. Watson for more info!

Ranked One Piece Thriller Bark Mafia

Reader mode
Grammaton said:
You serious with this?

Like I’m seriously asking you

He says it seems like a shit wagon to pursue day 1 (agree or disagree, you can at least rationalise it) - but then becomes today by saying he doesn’t want him to skirt

It COULD be a scum wagon but there’s no reason for you to oppose it based on your own takes on xadlin (ie you don’t have any)

As for the dead idiot, he provided a potential rationale for why he was doing the dumb shit he was doing - what’s the scum motivation for that in this scenario? There’s no danger anyone is going to actually lynch into a vig claim day 1, so unless your argument is that’s what he was going for, you have no point
Click to expand...
my point is that none of this is scumhunting on play and is actually scum hunting based on external factors allowing him to coast by while looking like he's actually hunting.
 
Magic said:
he's not really talking too much about involved players or ones contributing and has seemingly glossed over most of that, including people like you and myself. basically he's skirting by hunting on actual play and instead focusing on setup spec.
Click to expand...

I'm not sure why you've made the claim that I've glossed over talking about Grammaton when I gave a town read on them the last phase, which I know you must have seen going through my posts:

Great Potato said:
Anyways, I'm feeling pretty good about Grammaton reading through this Gad ordeal. The wagon and pressing on Gad who completely buckled under the pressure and dipped feels like a town who caught something and made an organic solve, and not a scum trying to force a wagon.
Click to expand...

I still stand by this. Gad made a fool of himself in the last phase. I'm not sure why you are expecting me to be focusing more energy on Grammaton because I hadn't gotten scum vibes for them.
 
Grammaton said:
Magic’s entire progression on gad (he light tiwn reads him in the read list above)

Sorry I’m not seeing anything really approaching a reasoned endorsement for him being town, if I’m being generous, you at best give him an alibi for trusting some of my commentary despite distrusting me

Where’s the big town read and defence that you’re miffed nobody listened to, Magic???
Click to expand...
I literally deconstructed your case against him and said your most valid point was the one about him not voting but that might also not be meaningful if it doesn't match up with past behaviour/meta.

Believe you're also missing a post in there where I said he's just town after I read back further.

Not sure what you want. I didn't want him to be the wagon or lynch at any point. That's largely my point and it's supported by, ya know, never going through and asking people to vote elsewhere.
 
Reader mode
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top