Game Vampire The Masquerade: Bloodlines

[Ali]

I need you to read both of those posts you quoted slowly and carefully

Shit man I can barely see, I saw the not as nor

 

[Sharter Holmes]

Kek, it's fine

 

[Mr. Reloaded]

and In general, what's your scum list?

Cata and Gad and maybe Stargate.

 

[Mr. Reloaded]

vote Cataclysm

 

[Mr. Reloaded]

Cata and Gad and maybe Stargate.

If not Gad, I might have to revisit my Kiku read

 

[Lappland]

we still need ultra to claim today

 

[Stargate18]

Did Ali/Nutmeg claim or even hint Day 1?

I don't see why Star would avoid targeting them as their only named suspect, and why Nut was considered safe

Ali was voted pretty often D1, so I assumed that someone else would be aiming there. I decided it was better to try and RB someone I found suspicious rather than risk RBing someone who was already blocked.

 

[Stargate18]

@stargate you claim the rb on nutmeg right?

@Flower i hope you are smart enough to give out your gun out night 1 here

I did indeed, yes.

 

[Stargate18]

Finally caught up, apologies for liking and not posting, kinda a new bad habit.


Then how is he dead?


Stargate already claimed Rb, Cata calimed Rolecrusher ... who do you think is mafia?
also, @Stargate18 isn't it kinda weird you haven't sused cata for claiming a similar yet "somewhat more scummy" role as you? instead you RBed nutmeg N1 and me N2 ... why not thinking cata when he was already POE since D1?


He is 75/25 scum ... his scummniess comes from his somewhat questionable RB targets + His overall laziness and his instant claim after I claimed, he also seems to be tunneling which is not a towny feat.


See this looks bad, even I gave the possibility that Ultra or Lapp cases on each other might be right (even thought ultra can be scum since his predecessor LC gave me scummy vibes) but my guy stargate straight says it's bad to bad idea to fire at a mason when we can take out Relo, even tho the whole relo situation hasn't been resolved yet.


Yeah here are my thoughts so far

In the LAPP vs ULTRA situation, I go with Lapp, Every things lapp said checks out in some way, the possiblity of him scum coaching Nibel is honestly far-fetched and I wouldn't be mad losing to that sort of masterplan tbh hahaha .... as for ULTRA... his predecessor gave me scummy vibes due to laziness and inactivity (although LC said his inactivity is irrelevant) and Now ultra seems to be dead bent on proving his "sky's the limit" Lapp is scum theory, which doesn't ring well considering we have the entire Relo/Stargate/Cata situation still going on, I haven't played with ultra before, he might just be this hot-headed with his reads tho.

I somewhat believe York's (Goddessblade) claim.

Sigi is town since D1 incident with Yoho.

I can give Gad (Sharter) the benefit of the doubt, given that he does use his ability at some point.

Atso slot has been a hinderance to me but thanks to the mason claims I can finally put it to rest.

Reloaded is 75/25 scum ... I find his RB claim hard to believe, Knowing I was RBed myself and stargate admitting it, I will have to ISO his posts to see if he had any kind of interaction with SG ... I think RELO and SG are both scum.

SG is mentioned above.

The Cata situation is the one bugging me the most, If reloaded flips town then my POE is Cata for sure

Scum list
Reloaded
Stargate
Cata 50/50

This is a Fuji game, I'm not making any reads based off setup here. I can definitely see a situation where there are that many roleblocks in the game lol.

I will admit the Reloaded suggestion was just an example of someone widely scumread. In general, I just think that lynching masons is a bad idea, and lynching the active mason of the two, as Ultra has been consistently pushing even in the face of counterarguments, is fucking atrocious play.

 

[Ali]

we still need ultra to claim today

@Ultra claim please

 

[Ali]

So do you @Ratchet

 

[Ultra]

@Ultra claim please

Don't see the point in claiming a couple hours before day ends unless im gonna be lynched, I'll claim tomorrow probably

 

[Ultra]

This is a Fuji game, I'm not making any reads based off setup here. I can definitely see a situation where there are that many roleblocks in the game lol.

I will admit the Reloaded suggestion was just an example of someone widely scumread. In general, I just think that lynching masons is a bad idea, and lynching the active mason of the two, as Ultra has been consistently pushing even in the face of counterarguments, is fucking atrocious play.

Why aren't you voting?

 

[Ultra]

Why is your qualifier there that Lapp is being active if he's being scummy

He hasn't caught scum and looks to me to be pushing town for the most part, you guys will have to do better if cata flips scum

 

[Fujishiro]

VC 5 Of Day 3

Cataclysm: 4
Reloaded: 2


Ali: SG > Reloaded > Cataclysm
Cata: SG > Reloaded > unvote > Reloaded
Lappland: Reloaded
Reloaded: SG > Lappland > unvote > Cataclysm
Ratchet: Reloaded > unvote
Sharter: Reloaded > unvote > Cataclysm
Ultra: Lappland > Lappland> Cataclysm

With 12 players its 7 for majority​

 

[Ultra]

Ali
Mr. Reloaded
Sigismund
Ratchet
Sharter Holmes
Goddess

Stargate18
Atsumori
Lappland
Nutmeg
Cataclysm

Here's why I can't get over the mason thing

Top pile is my town reads, more or less everyone here looks good off Yoho, though there's some wiggle room here for bussing

You have bottom pile who either looked apprehensive about Yoho or didn't involve themselves, so if I clear Lap/Atsu, I'm left with Nut/Star/Cata. That feels a bit unlikely that they're all scum, I suppose you could replace one of these with someone in the top pile, but meh

Lapp himself has given Nut a hard pass as well for basically doing nothing which doesn't really suggest a Nut scum/Lapp town dynamic

 

[Ultra]

Really don't think this is the play here, honestly. It's a mason claim where at least one player has claimed that its a confirmed alignment, firing here feels like a very bad idea. (Masons are self-resolving anyway, since mafia will not want them to make it to F3 under any circumstances.)

If Reloaded is widely scumread, just take him out today so we don't waste time making a ton of hypotheticals about partners and have it all be worth fuck all if he flips town.

Why would you even make this post if he's town in your reads list, you have 0 conviction or what?

Readslist before I go sleep. See you all tomorrow.

Stargate18
Ratchet
Lappland
Cataclysm
Mr. Reloaded
Tinky winky

Lord Melkor
Sigismund
Atsumori
GoddessBlade
Nutmeg

Hayumi
Sharter Holmes
Ali

Struggling to find a post from you that isn't horrid

 

[Ultra]

Why is Nutmeg not in your bottom PoE if supposedly they were your roleblock choice as target as well, did you decide they were no longer as suspicious, any particular reason?

 

[Stargate18]

Why is Nutmeg not in your bottom PoE if supposedly they were your roleblock choice as target as well, did you decide they were no longer as suspicious, any particular reason?

Ali was voted pretty often D1, so I assumed that someone else would be aiming there. I decided it was better to try and RB someone I found suspicious rather than risk RBing someone who was already blocked.

 

[Stargate18]

Why would you even make this post if he's town in your reads list, you have 0 conviction or what?



Struggling to find a post from you that isn't horrid

I don't think Mr. "Let's kill the masons" has much room to talk about horrid posting.

You're just salty that Lappland pointed out how none of your posts today have made any sense.