Sky
So unreliable.
I mean I could also offer an opinion why I think it's forced but I don't want to pre-empt the bird
- It's that time of the year again! Just kidding, we were late.
Click here to see the awards and nominate people for the rest of the categories.
- We're looking for artists. Direct message Dr. Watson for more info!
because i believe it comes down to wanting to take a leadership role rather than allowing posters he scum reads to slip through his grasp.
too lazy to go back and quote the past few games where he made it explicitly clear that he abhored that his reads on players weren't considered and he felt it was blindingly obvious they were scum. i noticed it's been a gradual change those games compared to this one so arguably that could be the one thing that might indicate he's scum. not sure if that makes a lick of sense, im tired
opposite play doesn't always mean scum - it could also be a differentiation in their usual town meta if that makes sense?
scum play for him would be a lack of solving ime. so generally speaking - separate from his own meta - i feel this is a town play. he's stepping up his game much like nibel
this is partially a vibe im getting, partially the consideration that he was serious when he stated he was going to tryhard. think he's kept his word
how familiar are you with tweet as scum? is there something off im missing?
Sky
So unreliable.
Simply because those are all first page fluff phase posts. That is the post of someone who's been told to analyse the game and panicked and did the first thing they saw. Like, so blatantly it's approaching too-bad-to-be-scum territory
no, i just wanted to try and see your logic behind it
fwiw this is a very town watson post
lethargy is my excuse
gimme time to review pls thank you
Im a bit unsure here. I just browsed through her last scum game
onelastforum.com
and there she seems to start off pretty fucking aggro actually, and it took me by surprise because i was kinda assuming she would start off meek lmao. I think she starts off fairly hot there, and she gets pretty aggressive when people give her shit as well so she doesnt really seem scared of taking on people being suspect of her when she's scum
but by the same token, the way she is solving and posting here doesnt seem anything like the way she was solving in her last town game either
onelastforum.com
whereby she was super care free and pretty direct with asking questions and engaging
so yeah idk i dont feel like i have anything on her any more but also doesnt feel right to me lmao
Game - Ranked - Better Call Saul Mafia Game Thread [Game End - Serial Killer Victory]
Welcome to Better Call Saul Mafia, a game based on Vince Gilligan's masterpiece show, Better Call Saul. Host: Kekko Reviewed by: @Rugrat Start: Sunday 11 AM CST. Countdown ========= Current Game State: Game End Living players [2/19]: 1. @Hans Tweetenberg - Mike Ehrmantraut - 2x Odd-Night...
onelastforum.com and there she seems to start off pretty fucking aggro actually, and it took me by surprise because i was kinda assuming she would start off meek lmao. I think she starts off fairly hot there, and she gets pretty aggressive when people give her shit as well so she doesnt really seem scared of taking on people being suspect of her when she's scum
but by the same token, the way she is solving and posting here doesnt seem anything like the way she was solving in her last town game either
Game - Ranked - Bleach Mafia (Prod Test Game)
Host: @Hobo Setup: Vanilla (12 Town vs 3 Mafia Goons) Rules: Experimental: This game will feature a prod system. If a player fails to post 15 times during a day phase (unless the day was shorter than 24h due to an early hammer) they will get 1 prod at the end of the respective day phase. A prod...
onelastforum.com whereby she was super care free and pretty direct with asking questions and engaging
so yeah idk i dont feel like i have anything on her any more but also doesnt feel right to me lmao
Hans Tweetenberg
Marvelous
We tell her we want her to give us something to work with, in response she goes back to the start of the game, picking out some more or less random posts and completely overanalyses the crap out of them. On top of that, as Poyser pointed out, the read on me she reached doesn't even make sense by her own metrics. Nothing about that post feels like natural solving, and everything about it looks like appeasement.
Hans Tweetenberg
Marvelous
Does that mean you think she's currently getting townier? Mind walking me through that?
She also seems way different than she did in the grand theft auto game where she was town
onelastforum.com
all the other games between those two, she was a rep in so not really a fair comparison lol
but the chink in that is, both of the games ive just posted she basically had a gimmick entry into the thread. GTA she had a PR and then Bleach she was basically starting a banter wagon on gad for no reason
but she was really proactive with engaging and asking questions and giving her opinions in both
Game - Ranked - Grand Theft Auto Mafia
Hello All, thanks for joining. A few pointers ahead of time: 1. Town win condition is not in the PMs but it is to eradicate all non-town 2. Don't cheat. This includes talking about the game in any way (PM, VM, IM, Rep, whatever) outside the thread and any other bullshit rule-bending idea you...
onelastforum.com all the other games between those two, she was a rep in so not really a fair comparison lol
but the chink in that is, both of the games ive just posted she basically had a gimmick entry into the thread. GTA she had a PR and then Bleach she was basically starting a banter wagon on gad for no reason
but she was really proactive with engaging and asking questions and giving her opinions in both
What do you think of her explanation post to that?
first, before i go back, what does not make sense with what i am saying?
these are one of the problems i have playing these games - if i cannot effectively get my points across, it's very difficult to play on the same wavelength and make a more concise point that is properly understood. throwing out "she makes no sense" gives me nothing to work off of here. i need more than that
these are one of the problems i have playing these games - if i cannot effectively get my points across, it's very difficult to play on the same wavelength and make a more concise point that is properly understood. throwing out "she makes no sense" gives me nothing to work off of here. i need more than that
Sky
So unreliable.
I'm not sure what this is meant to be asking? I've got no way of knowing with certainty how other people act
Nah her point on you is fairly easy to follow imo, people sometimes fall into a trap of plotting the behaviour/alignment relationship on a single axis, which only reliably works with totally nooby players, or with players with such distinctive styles that they struggle to replicate
She didnt pick the posts at random, she went to the start of the game did she not?
Hans Tweetenberg
Marvelous
Hmmm well I'm kinda torn here
On one hand we still have the contradiction that my play doesn't match the town meta you laid out for me
On the other hand I have noticed that you've been very understanding of my issues particularly during the last game so you making a feel-based read like this doesn't come across as fake or unnatural
The problem is that you arriving at the conclusion that I'm town can easily be explained away by ykno, you being scum and having all the answers
Mmmmmmmmmm to buy or not to buy
Hans Tweetenberg
Marvelous
Yeah she went to the start and picked a few posts from there
Are you working to the assumption that she wouldnt realise the optics of that?
Hans Tweetenberg
Marvelous
Could you explain the first paragraph in simpler terms please, I can't say I understand what you're trying to say