• We are currently rolling out incremental alterations to the forum. Don't freak! You aren't going crazy.

Final Fantasy XIV Mafia - Game Thread

Status
Not open for further replies.
Reader mode
Lord Melkor

Lord Melkor

Exceptional
Psychic said:
The first 2 pages is a bit tryharding imho.

Can the man post first before you decide this?

Suprised that LM's early reads are similar to mine. Slight town lean on Sworder and slight scum lean on Magic as well.

I have no idea what you mean by this. Can you elaborate?

Slight town lean on : Sworder, Ekko, LM
Slight scum read on : Raem, Magic

Regarding Aurelian vs Gramma. Null on both. Although logically, Gramma is making alot of sense and Aurelian is being defensive and not solving. he can be like that as town too, I think. Regardless, his slot needs to be resolved at this point. His flip would give me a better read on Gram.

Again, I am agreeing with LM here. I also can't read Gram.

I would like a Raem flip, just comes off as super scummy. He's not making alot of sense and does not seem to want to solve. Just getting bad vibes from him at this point.

You keep saying this as if you want us to notice how much similarly you acted as town last game.
Click to expand...

Our reads are indeed very aligned. I am not liking Raem as well.
 
TSworder

TSworder

Majin
Why the hell did Aurelian said his claim so quickly, it feels like he just entered the thread and claimed lol
Also it is kinda unfair to keep Grammaton in the nulls zone, I will give him a town lean, feels like he did way to much activity, - Im not confident on his Aurelian take tho, maybe he is on the money maybe not, idk
Raem has the same vibe like in mhm, maybe he is a little more defensive/ w this Aurelian talk, I still think that he went a little hard on T-vegan at the start but well nothing out the ordinary
Physic has some confidence in her initials reads, dont see nothing that astonished there
Idk what BPD is doing, how can you even read that slot? Aurelian tunneling every game?
Unvote
 
Lord Melkor

Lord Melkor

Exceptional
Ekkologix said:
fully caught up

town
gram - strongest town read. thoughts on aurelian and sworder matched mine as im catching up. update - i think the aurelian wagon wont go further tho as i feel like hes town. its getting a lil stale imo and i hope gram moves on. @Grammaton do u have any current sus reads aside from fang? what r ur updated thoughts on him now after his interactions with other players. do u think this is the same as evans who we caught on very early last game but he talked his way out of a wagon?


lean town
magic - i think he is playing protown now and helping move game forward. nothing outside of scum range after seeing monster hunter game but his play is inherently protown so if he is scum he is helping town rn and id imagine him to wanna go astray from this soon if scum. that wud be the point this read changes if it happens.
aurelian - i think i can decently read him after the last couple of games from the way he enters thread and holds conversations and believes what he is posting, even if i dont agree with some of it. he also did the town tell of his that i wont tell anyone ;)). i kind of hope gram moves elsewhere for a bit.


town side of null
sworder - early posts felt less calculated than last game where he opened with a read list and small fluff. dont have any reason solid to put him any higher tho
melkor - moving melkor down to here, tho still think his line of solving comes off as townie. i do kinda sense a bit of mailing in a scum read on magic. @Lord Melkor do u have any early PoE or town reads rn? i think ur posts to magic r kinda phoned in. i dont think as scum u wud make it that obvious tho so im leaning more townie on u, but i want to see more fire in ur reads if possible. what would help u read magic?
RAEM - dont agree with anything they said (like saying that forming town reads is scummy) but dont necessarily sense malice. the names he threw for scum reads seem more lazy than mafia (because it serves him no purpose to antagonize that many players at once). dont have stronger reason to move him higher. @RÆM pls give us reasons for ur reads por favor.


null
evans - if hes scum im gna need tpein to bury him here. update- moving him to null. if he continues tpein talk will move down to scum. there shud be plenty of content now for town evans to start cooking so im on the lookout for that
BLD - no update. i think fang comes better than BPD tbh, or rather, i dont feel like BPD scum reads fang really. aside from that dont have anything to read BPD from.
psychic - hi @Psychic :blobtrin. im afraid we might have lost you to the scum side this game :(( . can u help me read u town?
tweet - was looking a bit townie until that post where he retracts his town read of gram which looked very similar to how he retracted his town read off dofla last game. now sensing bit of scum tweet there. i think tweet wants to pursue RAEM now but idk the reasons behind it. @Hans Tweetenberg can u shed some light on ur PoE rn and reasons pls


scum side of null
cp - i think everything cp engaged with this game was easy and safe, and him going back to iso gram/aurelian to bring the timeline issue was mostly performative. i cant really tell rn who cp scum reads or where his direction is. i feel like he wants that aurelian mislynch badly but he wont really overextend for it. if it ever becomes an opportunity he will put his fangs on it instantly, no pun intended.


vote lynch cp
@CraigPelton id like a read list with reasons from you pls. ty ty ^^
Click to expand...

I mostly agree with your reads but they feel very safe. You have only one scum lean at this stage?

I am trying to solve Magic by establishing his motives. I was very impressed by his scum game during the Monster Hunter game and i am actually a bit surprised you think he will benefit town as scum.

Why do you not like Psychic?
 
Lord Melkor

Lord Melkor

Exceptional
Magic said:
I'm still likely going to want to lynch aurelian. I think the opposite of cp and the absolute lack of traction it's receiving feels more telling than people saying he's town.
Click to expand...

So you think Aurelian is not on his town meta here?

I do not like his early voyeur claim but he did the same as healer in the Monster Hunter game.
 
Grammaton

Grammaton

Consigliere
Moderator
That’s not to say Raem can’t possibly be town, he can, my point is that I have no real baseline to establish what looks town particular to him, and neither does magic?
 
Lord Melkor

Lord Melkor

Exceptional
Caught up and need to go back to work.

Psychic, Sworder, BLD remain town reads - they seem naturally giving their thoughts and relaxed. I would like to see more from BLD though.

Hans propably slight town lean. Ekko same.

@Evans needs to post more and give his thoughts if he wants to remain a town lean.

Unsure about Gramm and Aurelian, could still be town vs town. @Grammaton should do more outside this.

Still paranoid about Magic, i did not like how he got an early claim from Aurelian.

Ream and CP slight scum vibes, seem opportunistic.
 
Grammaton

Grammaton

Consigliere
Moderator
Lord Melkor said:
Caught up and need to go back to work.

Psychic, Sworder, BLD remain town reads - they seem naturally giving their thoughts and relaxed. I would like to see more from BLD though.

Hans propably slight town lean. Ekko same.

@Evans needs to post more and give his thoughts if he wants to remain a town lean.

Unsure about Gramm and Aurelian, could still be town vs town. @Grammaton should do more outside this.

Still paranoid about Magic, i did not like how he got an early claim from Aurelian.

Ream and CP slight scum vibes, seem opportunistic.
Click to expand...

I don’t get what you mean by ‘do more’

What exactly am I not doing?
 
Lord Melkor

Lord Melkor

Exceptional
Grammaton said:
No, he barely played the previous game, and as far as I know, MHW is the only game magic played with him (maybe fairy tail too, I didn’t check)
Click to expand...

Okay, if they played only one game it is kind of weird that Magic can be certain Raem is town so easily at this stage.
 
Reader mode
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top