Final Fantasy XIV Mafia - Game Thread

[T-Pein™]

Well colour me shocked

Did you even read the conversation?

Yes I did.
You can do the same thing to anyone.

 

[Grammaton]

@Ekkologix nope, I feel pretty certain Aurelian is scum and likely won’t be moving

Outside of that, strongest town reads are on tweet and Sworder as it stands

I don’t want to say any more just yet.

 

[Grammaton]

Yes I did.
You can do the same thing to anyone.

If you read it, I struggle to see how your takeaway is that I bullied him, unless you don’t think I should vote or ask questions?

 

[T-Pein™]

If you read it, I struggle to see how your takeaway is that I bullied him, unless you don’t think I should vote or ask questions?

You literally did it to me last game.
Why should I think you are right "this time" ?
He made like 5 fluff posts and you were alresdy death tunneling.

 

[Magic]

You literally did it to me last game.
Why should I think you are right "this time" ?
He made like 5 fluff posts and you were alresdy death tunneling.

Ngl cp might be right on this Vibing exactly like monster hunter.

 

[T-Pein™]

Ngl cp might be right on this Vibing exactly like monster hunter.

Cringe.

 

[TSworder]

If you're talking about MHW, town actually won that one

My bad, I thought about fairy tail when I wrote that comment, but yeah I played with Raem also in MHW

 

[Grammaton]

You literally did it to me last game.
Why should I think you are right "this time" ?
He made like 5 fluff posts and you were alresdy death tunneling.

Whether I’m right or wrong isn’t really central to what I’m asking you

This reads more as you making an excuse to disregard anything I say and take the opposite stance, regardless of what it actually is. Why do that?

 

[Grammaton]

Ngl cp might be right on this Vibing exactly like monster hunter.

There’s one key ingredient still missing tho

 

[Grammaton]

There’s something Aurelian did which I think you’re all disregarding:

I'm not unduly bothered by you advocating for my lynch, even as misguided as it is. I'm more annoyed you are intentionally misrepresenting my entire response to X, then having the absolute nerve to say I'm taking your words and misusing them when you started this with a strawman about me calling X scum when I said it could be scummy. I'm not going to be lynched today either way and I know what my slot is.

You need, and have failed several times now, to explain how my actions are "blatantly" scum.

This is a clear attempt to diffuse the wagon by hinting a big 3 role (cop, vig, watcher) - he leans into it again later with the ‘aw shucks, sure hope I don’t have to claim’ post

Then there’s the functionality of his role. He said that any scum role he sees will report back as a town adjacent equivalent - I think this is a very shaky claim as I find it likelier it’s an I’ll-conceived fake meant to remove the burden of ever giving incriminating results - I don’t see any reason ratchet gives such a pointless role

 

[Grammaton]

Nope

This game's version as Town Voyeur it won't tell me who used what on who they targeted but it will always be town flavored basically

Do you want me to copy paste what the host game me? And therefore get mod-killed because that's exactly what my role is:

- I can target a player and see who they targeted but it won't tell me what action they did
- all their actions will come back town flavored (killer as vig, role cop as cop, etc...)

For reference

The sum of this is that it’s delivered in such a way as to not incriminate scum actions - I feel the more natural thought process if you are town drawing such an abomination of a role is to question wtf you’re supposed to do with it, not proudly puff your chest out and declare it a town power role (that gives misleading results)

???

 

[T-Pein™]

Why do that?

Why do you mean why?
I have zero confidence in you.
If he flips scum then you get a T-Pein point.
Only way I vote aurelian is if he is -1 a minute before the deadline.

 

[Grammaton]

Why do you mean why?
I have zero confidence in you.
If he flips scum then you get a T-Pein point.
Only way I vote aurelian is if he is -1 a minute before the deadline.

So to clarify, whatever I say, you will just take the opposite position, regardless of what it actually is

You’re a sad sack of shit, you know that?

 

[T-Pein™]

So to clarify, whatever I say, you will just take the opposite position, regardless of what it actually is

You’re a sad sack of shit, you know that?

Prove yourself.
I ain't gonna mindlessly sheep you.
Specially not after you mislynched me last game...
I have my own reads.

 

[Grammaton]

Prove yourself.
I ain't gonna mindlessly sheep you.
Specially not after you mislynched me last game...
I have my own reads.

I’m not asking you to sheep me you fucking mong

 

[T-Pein™]

And yes I am not convinced Aurelian is scum anyways.

 

[Grammaton]

And yes I am not convinced Aurelian is scum anyways.

Well then fine, make your case as to why rather than just boiling it down to being a knob

How hard is it to just play properly

 

[T-Pein™]

I’m not asking you to sheep me you fucking mong

I am not going to go out of my way to derail your aurelian wagon.
I just don't wanna join it.

 

[T-Pein™]

Well then fine, make your case as to why rather than just boiling it down to being a knob

How hard is it to just play properly

I literally did.
I am saying Raem seems scummy to me....
He is my #1 sus.

 

[TSworder]

this entire argument seems predicated on a completely false timeline of events, from both sides lol

Good catch
My take here is that Grammaton voted Aurelian for reactions, and then when he was asked about it, he started talking about events that happened shortly after his initial vote. I don't think it's a big deal, but somehow both Aurelian and Grammaton started pointing at the same "reason“, aka the little conversation between Aurelian and BPD, and they both forgot about Gramm's vote and its order in this convo.
I'm at page 19 and have them at null so far.