• We're looking for artists. Direct message Dr. Watson for more info!

Final Fantasy XIV Mafia - Game Thread

Status
Not open for further replies.
Reader mode
CraigPelton said:
did you ever answer my question about who the people hesitant to vote aurelian were that you thought could be scum? I also need to ask you who is defending aurelian that you think has scum equity with him or is potentially being scummy
Click to expand...

no it's more a vibe and the utter lack of votes. i'd have to go through. off the top of my head id likely revisit melkor and tpein.

also i did comment on the tpein thing you brought up. at least i think i did, i woke up twice at 6am to take spicy shits. was like a fever dream.
 
Magic said:
no it's more a vibe and the utter lack of votes. i'd have to go through. off the top of my head id likely revisit melkor and tpein.

also i did comment on the tpein thing you brought up. at least i think i did, i woke up twice at 6am to take spicy shits. was like a fever dream.
Click to expand...
well there's only 17 people in the game so I feel like there should be some names attached to these implications
 
CraigPelton said:
that doesn't contradict anything I said mate
Click to expand...

No?

Evans said:
T-Pein can still get in the bin. His entry to the thread calling me scum and his posts are dog shit

Aurelian can go in the bin too

CP is striking me as odd as he’s just circling around your interaction with Aurelian rather than pushing it as well. Seems to be trying to blend in on the wagon without committing to the push
Click to expand...
CraigPelton said:
Evans is hard to buy this game though. starts off with the I HATE T-PEIN LET'S KILL HIM shtick, then t-pein comes into the thread and plays exactly how he did when he was actually scum and suddenly Evans has nothing to say about him but shades me who is actually pointing this out. then when questioned about it he shades T-Pein but also continues to shade me. feels very off
Click to expand...

I literally commented on his play and then you post this
 
CraigPelton said:
well there's only 17 people in the game so I feel like there should be some names attached to these implications
Click to expand...

a lack of appetite for a wagon can be seen in a lack of votes being attracted to that wagon as well. almost no one wants to lynch aurelian from what ive seen except tweet, myself, odo, and you lean that way.
 
Grammaton said:
I mean I personally don’t mind someone trying to play devils advocate fwiw

Tbh the biggest thing that bothers me is Evans - I don’t really like his posts either but I’d find it hard to see fang and him aligned in some respects, given the post fang made to evans about tpein- I can’t see a S/S reason for it
Click to expand...
i think evans recent posts r townier than fang tbh, probably comf bias with me as evans brought the same thoughts i have on cp which makes me see him favorabily
 
sorry bpd too.

bpd game also seems highly mild from what i've seen. i should probably go look at the other game where odo caught aurelian in to cross compare his reaction to votes. tpein might have a valid point in regards to level of activity and defense aurelian is putting up being too high for him to be scum.
 
Magic said:
not that id ever want to play similar to my game last game, but if this is how you feel is the best way to read me why would you announce it in the thread opposed to waiting to see if i actually do this very thing?

aren't you worried i'd just adjust?
Click to expand...
its not in ur control to just adjust, unless u mean ur gna hard bus ur whole team stronger lol

gna depend on how well town does in finding ur other teammates. if we r doing well u will be forced in awkward position sooner or later
 
Grammaton said:
I’m a bit baffled about Magics conclusion that Raem is town
Click to expand...

why? did you read traitors mafia at the end of day 1 or even your game? he comes across like the mafia equivalent of a hippie. if you want i can pull out some quotes from your game to help you get the idea.

Lord Melkor said:
I mostly agree with your reads but they feel very safe. You have only one scum lean at this stage?

I am trying to solve Magic by establishing his motives. I was very impressed by his scum game during the Monster Hunter game and i am actually a bit surprised you think he will benefit town as scum.

Why do you not like Psychic?
Click to expand...
well this makes the attention youre giving me make a bit more sense.

ekko has a point in regards to me benefitting town as scum. it's something i noticed in the (long) past and someone else pointed out as well. if im alive i interact and bring forth reads out of people as it's what i do as town. if there's a dip in activity i generally bring activity and again it's through interactions and pulling people's thoughts out. basically that's my benefit as scum to town is that i play to still progress the game as it's my overall meta to do so.
 
also just wanted to help melkor ease paranoia now when there is no reason for it (at this stage atleast)
 
Magic said:
^this is the post he liked that im referring to.



the one above i made. i can maybe find the tweet post too that im talking about as well if it helps.
Click to expand...
aurelian liked similar posts from memory where i was telling tweet do not read aurelian from content but rather from tone and how much he believes himself

i feel like lynching fang here is more for policy than a solid scum read for me. if he turns out scum i wouldnt be surprised, but i dont strongly read him as such
 
Grammaton said:
That’s not to say Raem can’t possibly be town, he can, my point is that I have no real baseline to establish what looks town particular to him, and neither does magic?
Click to expand...
fairy tale, traitors, and monster hunt.

ive never seen his scum play, but i've definitely seen quite a bit of his town play and the way he thinks and approaches the game is unique.
 
Lord Melkor said:
Caught up and need to go back to work.

Psychic, Sworder, BLD remain town reads - they seem naturally giving their thoughts and relaxed. I would like to see more from BLD though.

Hans propably slight town lean. Ekko same.

@Evans needs to post more and give his thoughts if he wants to remain a town lean.

Unsure about Gramm and Aurelian, could still be town vs town. @Grammaton should do more outside this.

Still paranoid about Magic, i did not like how he got an early claim from Aurelian.

Ream and CP slight scum vibes, seem opportunistic.
Click to expand...

what is bpd's scum game like?

sworder does feel comfortable in the thread from the posts i saw so i agree with this.

xaldin too but it's mostly memes. memes that i like tho.

what are you paranoid about specifically? iirc you said ultra was the scum mvp and i was openly suspected most of the game so what exactly is your paranoia derived from?
 
Lethal said:
Page 1:

Not sure Magic playing a stats game is anything I'm going to like. Awkward entry post.
Ekko trolling. Ugh. Next player.
Evans' understandable Pein frustration, could just be to ease into the game. NAI though, everyone loathes Pein
Too much Pein discussion. Forgettable slot and player.



In what way did this seem 'forced?' Magic doesn't hint at wolf vibing Evans at all. Seems you are stretching just a little much here. Sworder jumps on immediately. Don't think 2 wolves go that ham so early on, so probs NAI


Someone lacks self-awareness
Click to expand...

did you mean those two, melkor and sworder, are unlikely to be aligned or that their votes are not alignment indicative. NAI not alignment indicative but it sounds like you meant to say they aren't aligned due to jumping on the wagon together so early on.
 
Lethal said:
Psychic liking posts but no comments. Hopefully she's posted soon?
Click to expand...

lethal why do you do this. it troubles my heart.

let's say youre reading back right now and liking posts but you weren't around. that would mean your likes showed up for others reading back but you also weren't commenting as you read back way after.

this feels like you know cp brought up the fact she was liking posts but not commenting but you didn't just states that's where youre getting the impression from. so instead it just sounds like a weird fucking comment because you have no time reference to know when she liked the posts.

this is entirely not alignment indicative. it just doesn't make SENSE AND TROUBLES MY HEART.
 
Reader mode
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top