• We're looking for artists. Direct message Dr. Watson for more info!

Final Fantasy XIV Mafia - Game Thread

Status
Not open for further replies.
Reader mode
Think I like Ekkos points about Nat best here

[Vote lynch Natalia]

I think I mighta been wrong on BPD, when I started wagoning him yesterday the wagon seemed to be building fairly quickly, that doesn't seem to me like a wagon on a scum player especially now that we know Fang was town.

Wouldn't mind Odd, Xadlin or Lethal today either
 
Black Pegged Dragon said:
Why do you think Gram has looked better this day?

I need Xadlin to claim here before I say anything more. Refusal to claim will just mean an insta lynch.
Click to expand...
He seems to be in a good mood, joking around, more relax.
CraigPelton said:
Voting with your scum read?? SUS!

@Psychic
Click to expand...
we still have alot of time, let's see how things develop.
Xadlin can swing either way. Needs to post more.
Basically Xadlin and BPD are both null to me at this point.
 
CraigPelton said:
3 - Magic
4 - CraigPelton
5 - TSworder
6 - Black Pegged Dragon
7 - Ekkologix
8 - T-Pein™
9 - Psychic
10 - Xadlin
11 - Grammaton
14 - Hans Tweetenberg
15 - Natalija
16 - Odd
17 - Lethal

I'm about here rn. Not sure T-Pein/Nat or Lethal/Xadlin would be aligned so this isn't really my final answer scum team of 4 or anything

I assume a 12/4/1 split with 17 players and 2 non-townie night kills

Town read I'm least sure on is probably Tweet. Maybe Ekko if T-Pein is town.
Click to expand...
whats the co-relation between town tpein and me being scum?

T-Pein™ said:
He literally started freaking out and pushed CP to try and lynch me out of nowhere when the BPD wagon started heating up.
And he moved me to scum for no reason at all.

:whathekong
Click to expand...
quotes for this happening? i didn't tell anyone to lynch u, not that i recall

anyway, why would that make me scummy?
 
Magic said:
He's like a Rollercoaster but overall it's better than his day 1 play in our game together. Someone said he does get better as the game goes along(as both alignments) so shouldn't underestimate him I suppose.
Click to expand...
I think that before this recent flurry of absolute trash tier games he's had, he's shown that he can play a halfway decent town game. There's always gonna be a certain amount of Pein gonna Pein to all of his games but he's not always been a pure liability. This game so far I can understand where many of this thoughts come from and that's usually a good sign.
 
@T-Pein™ this was my progression on u, nowhere did i say u r scum. i moved u down for reasons present clearly in my reads, if u read them

Ekkologix said:
ok caught up again

town
gram
melkor
lethal

lean town
evans
sworder
magic - btw how come u dont think xadlin's entrace is similar to fairy tail? @Magic

town side of null
rem - trending down. @RÆM pls give us ur reasoning for ur reads and how they progress now
fang - trending down as well. @Aurelian pls respond to my question above about ur current read of gram after knowing he voted u before BPD
t-pein

null - i dont have a strong reason to town read anyone here
psychic
BPD
odd
tweet
nat


lean scum
cp
xadlin - his opening is very similar to fairy tail as opposed to MHW. just a bit tame/less urgent but the essence of first post activity excuse into saying he will do his best then writing a summary is how he played there
Click to expand...

Ekkologix said:
off to sleep

where am at rn

town
evans - no update. tpein is making cp alot better but evans also wants tpein gone so neither of those make him look bad in retrospect


lean town
gram - gone a bit down since i think fang is MAYBE town and id love for gram to give us something else
magic - no update


town side of null
tweet - forgot why i had him as strong town. must be some posts mid day 1 i thought were towny / no agenda. someone cross check this with me lol. he seems to be coasting out the rest of the day playing on easy mode
aurelian - moving him and BPD here off of their interaction
BPD - same as aurelian
psychic - moving psychic here. i think recent posts look good. dont rly agree with the scum read of magic tho but it came from genuine thought process
sworder - no update. might start trending down if inactivity continues and i struggle to find other scum reads
lord melkor - no update. same as sworder
lethal - no update. the points magic brought are good. need to see more from lethal. my impressions on the read back initially was lethal felt towny but on a re-look its not as impressive as i initially thought. i hope i can see more consistency and interactions from lethal in real time.


null / need more pressure
tpein - moving tpein here. no idea what hes doing this game. i'll chalk it up to lazy town over scum maybe but hes making cp's game really easy. im falling to the trap of relying on people to solve PoE now which is not good
nat - no update. dont sense much agenda but also not much solving
odd - no update. dont sense much agenda but also not much solving


scum side of null
cp - while i think tpein makes him alot better, im leaning individually scum on cp for reasons ive outlined in thread. im not as confident on it as much anymore tho, but i am struggling with finding scum reads rn. its possible the wolves r hovering around nulls and my reads r wrong


lean scum
xadlin - similar thread entrance to fairy tail. dont sense as much degree of solving from him as seen in MHW. xadlin isnt getting nearly as much attention as he shud be. need pressure.



goodnight
Click to expand...

Ekkologix said:
ok im caught up. im here rn

town
evans
gram


lean town
sworder


town side of null
magic - goes a bit down. kind of not feeling him this EoD. i do value his points on lethal and psychic but i dont think they r slam dunk enough no
BPD - moving up to here from how he handled wagon on him
aurelian - purely off tone. i gave up on reading from content. a scum flip from him wont surprise me at all
psychic - her post b4 going off last night were good imo. i still have reservation about her saying "fang shud be resolved" and not looking much into him. if fang flips town it'll look bad for psychic imo
lethal - its the best day 1 ive seen from him in awhile so want him to stay for now. idk whats with his thoughts on me being scum for "sheeping evans" idea on cp tho. dont see the rationale much. i do also see magic's points and im also shocked to see lethal have that many town reads when he usually scum reads lots of players early on. also lethal generally struggles with tmi so thats a point against him. could move down if i dont find other scum. @Lethal pls give me ur reasons for all ur town reads por favor
melkor - no update. hope to see more tho like sworder to move him up
tweet - no update. still dont sense ill agenda so thats good
nat - nat seems uninformed solving at her own pace when interacting with lethal and magic, i think weak town lean for now

null
t-pein - i wanna say town but i dont undertsand the town read on cp at all. then scum reads me and magic for derailing from BPD but doesnt explain why he has BPD as scum to begin with
odd - no update


lean scum
xadlin - no update. still no response to the scum read on him. might be too AWOL for scum lol
cp - no update
Click to expand...
 
Hans Tweetenberg said:
Think I like Ekkos points about Nat best here

[Vote lynch Natalia]

I think I mighta been wrong on BPD, when I started wagoning him yesterday the wagon seemed to be building fairly quickly, that doesn't seem to me like a wagon on a scum player especially now that we know Fang was town.

Wouldn't mind Odd, Xadlin or Lethal today either
Click to expand...

Wagon was fake.
Magic literally abandoned when it was getting real.
 
T-Pein™ said:
Bs.
You kept saying "TP making CP look good now"
Then you pushed him to tunnel me instead of BPD who he was voting at the time.

:zilla1:
Click to expand...
where did i push him to tunnel u

i actually wanted YOU to help me bury him

u town reading him confused me big time
 
im about here now, will try to put a lid on the nulls and reduce them as much as i can in terms of decisiveness

town
tweet
magic
gram
sworder
psychic

can be any / need more data
tpein
odd
lethal

scum side / poe
cp
xadlin
BPD
nat
 
there is a possibility of BPD being mafia and xadlin being serial or something

BPD is mailing the fk out of every read he had this game

@Hans Tweetenberg ironically ive been starting to think i was wrong on him and moving him to scum side. surprised to see u start to move him to town side lol. whats the reason for ur change?
 
Hans Tweetenberg said:
I think that before this recent flurry of absolute trash tier games he's had, he's shown that he can play a halfway decent town game. There's always gonna be a certain amount of Pein gonna Pein to all of his games but he's not always been a pure liability. This game so far I can understand where many of this thoughts come from and that's usually a good sign.
Click to expand...
No I meant I was told as scum he gets better as the game progresses too. It isn't just one alignment.
 
Reader mode
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top