• We're looking for artists. Direct message Dr. Watson for more info!

Final Fantasy XIV Mafia - Game Thread

Status
Not open for further replies.
Reader mode
If I’m on the player list but not on your scum team you kill me N1 everytime, I can’t be reasoned with and I can’t be bargained with. If you are between me and a win you are in a bad position right off the bat
 
Odd said:
If I’m on the player list but not on your scum team you kill me N1 everytime, I can’t be reasoned with and I can’t be bargained with. If you are between me and a win you are in a bad position right off the bat
Click to expand...

odd your shtick is as stale as the buns on your patty
you need to get on the move, youre being a fatty
if youre town we need your claim
otherwise you risk town being slain



can you claim now pls.
 
Grammaton said:
Tpeins already showing me what’s up, but thx
Click to expand...

i dont see a world where you dont end up with the conclusion im scum as it makes more sense than cp being scum.

so ill ask you do the same as cp and do hypotheticals with me about where you'd go if i flip town/who you think the team is? do you so much in terms of teammate equity?
 
Magic said:
m8 youre always down there in the shitter.
just claim and show that youre a go getter.
Click to expand...
Maybe I just execute you, all it takes it for me to type 6 words and click post reply. Would that suffice for a claim then?
 
T-Pein™ said:
fully caught up.

town
tweet
CP
Aurelian
psychic

Town Null
Xadlin
Gramma
natalija
lord melkor
sworder

Scum
kekko
Magic
BPD
evans

Scum Null
Odd
Lethal

I think if Aurelian flips scum I switch most of my town and my scums.
lowkey.
Click to expand...
tpein is no dirty busser

if you guys agree with me that ekko is town then his entire scum list is town players. also he was too on the nose about aurelian frankly.
 
Magic said:
i dont see a world where you dont end up with the conclusion im scum as it makes more sense than cp being scum.

so ill ask you do the same as cp and do hypotheticals with me about where you'd go if i flip town/who you think the team is? do you so much in terms of teammate equity?
Click to expand...
I have a better proposition - you tell me why it’s not possible or likely for you to be teamed with any other player
 
Grammaton said:
I have a better proposition - you tell me why it’s not possible or likely for you to be teamed with any other player
Click to expand...

m8 im not stupid. the way your poe will fold out will have me as scum. i did my defense post again. i can quote it for you.

if you want anything else, the amount of people that sussed me this game combined with how viable my wagon was without any strong players pushing it ->unlikely im scum. with a team my wagon never gets his large because they likely would play around me. if i think im going to die yes id tell them to be the first ones onto me, but i didnt think i was going to die.

also as scum i have no real reason to hard town read you as early as i did and by continuing it.

there. now work with me before you inevitably decide im the best course of the lynch as there will be almost no margin for error afterwards.
 
Magic said:
m8 im not stupid. the way your poe will fold out will have me as scum. i did my defense post again. i can quote it for you.

if you want anything else, the amount of people that sussed me this game combined with how viable my wagon was without any strong players pushing it ->unlikely im scum. with a team my wagon never gets his large because they likely would play around me. if i think im going to die yes id tell them to be the first ones onto me, but i didnt think i was going to die.

also as scum i have no real reason to hard town read you as early as i did and by continuing it.

there. now work with me before you inevitably decide im the best course of the lynch as there will be almost no margin for error afterwards.
Click to expand...

So that’s a no then?
 
Magic said:
CraigPelton
TSworder
Black Pegged Dragon
Ekkologix
T-Pein™
Psychic
Xadlin
Grammaton
Hans Tweetenberg
Natalija
Odd
Lethal

Obviously least sure on nat/odd but the tracker results look good for odd.

nat still doesn't really vibe scummy to me. i could be wrong but if you guys decide to flip me here i'd prefer that not be the main direction. one of my town reads, at minimum, need to be off.

bpd isn't scum. ever.

i dont think ekko nor grammaton are scum here either at all. if odo is then props for the emotional manipulation. tweet's reaction to my claim, the way he went about his own claim all looked town as well as his early day 1 play. i will say i dont like how he went from aurelian to nat at the end of day 1 for almost no reason outside of cp asking for it but that was my biggest issue with his play.

im willing to trust ekko on psychic at least. also dont see the reason for her to ever move off of aurelian there as scum. she's tunneling me hard but that's not really AI.

the way xaldin claimed and presented his info looked town as well.

all in all, i think lethal/cp have to be scum here and tpein likely with them. tpein made all of his reads off of a bpd scum read and when he was no longer scum he just said he has to think of new reads basically. he was unable to present any new ones. the issue here is lethal and tpein argument doesn't look as s/s.

if im wrong on ekko this is basically all wrong as him being town is pretty foundational to this making any sense. cp did hint at his role but it honestly looked like he was hiding on it and from play itself he doesn't look great. i dont like his progressions, i dont like a lot of his reaosning, i do think he was trying to create a 2 for 1 with nat/aurelian last phase knowing if aurelian wasn't lynch nat would be. his reaction to not getting his lynch this game was opposite to that of mhw where he was much more mad and hungry to get tpein the second day phase whereas the hunger didn't exist at all this phase.

all this said it banks on him not being the cop which is not giving me the best feeling on it at all lol. i do need some level of confirmation ratchet doesn't have godfathers in his game sometimes(at least last game).
Click to expand...
in a world where cp isn't scum i think psychic is and probably with ekko.

again going through her actual reads it isn't great(as in a lot of it seems like they're after town players). she had sworder as town early on too. i dont like that early push on raem she had trying to work with tweet to get him lynched. again she was hyper confident on it and then when he was modkilled she just removed him from her scum reads.

but i find it hard to see ekko as scum right now, but that could be due to the lack of experience with him. his progressions seemed fine.
 
Something else magic did in MHW was encourage and discuss with ekko every dumb idea he had. Doing the same thing here with this speculation about me not being the cop
 
Reader mode
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top