• We're looking for artists. Direct message Dr. Watson for more info!

Game Ranked All of Us Are Dead Mafia

Status
Not open for further replies.
Let's go over the logic one more time

> I make a post about a thing I read Gad scum for probably being NAI
> Ultra: "Gad was scum that game. Why aren't you voting Gad?"
> me: "I said it's NAI for me"
> Ultra: "Why aren't you voting Gad though?"
> me: "Why do you want me to vote Gad off nothing? That doesn't feel towny and tracks with you trying to shepherd other players into random votes earlier on"
> Ultra: votes me

Town Ultra is NOT this boneheaded

Mmm yeah this is like talking to a brick wall.

You never responded to when I called you out for your fake catch up either.

Honestly I don't know who to vote for. I would like to vote for Sky but I fear to be just b pocketted by the wagon on Sky.

Sky or Dofla are both good choices
 
Also I got Magic lynched, too. I'm not afraid of going after big shots when I think they're scum. Idk why anyone would. It's just a lame excuse.
Was that in a game where

(1) that big shot was on your wagon so they can just cry OMGUS
(2) two more of the top players were also on your wagon
(3) you were the top wagon, AND
(4) you had a history of being ML'd early and yet no one learning from that?
 
Regardless of whether her logic checks out she was very strongly deflective. Instead of explaining her perspective she immediately accused me of making something over nothing and nudged towards me being scum.
what im wondering is if youre considering if this at all on brand for her as town.

Everything I do as town makes sense. Just *some people* like to pretend it doesn't.
historically that isn't true at all sky. you are literally who we used as the reference for survivor meta-style that is used by town players as you do shit on essentially a whim at times while ignoring your own actual reads/thoughts. ironically it is most similar to tpein that will do shit just for the sake of it if it moves the game forward(in his warped perception).

the famous example being when in marvel mafia when you had a town read on curry and a scum read on me and then you voted curry with me, which was baffling. there are other things too.
 
historically that isn't true at all sky. you are literally who we used as the reference for survivor meta-style that is used by town players as you do shit on essentially a whim at times while ignoring your own actual reads/thoughts. ironically it is most similar to tpein that will do shit just for the sake of it if it moves the game forward(in his warped perception).

the famous example being when in marvel mafia when you had a town read on curry and a scum read on me and then you voted curry with me, which was baffling. there are other things too.
You're just acting like I'm exactly the same player as I was back in the WF days
 
what im wondering is if youre considering if this at all on brand for her as town.


historically that isn't true at all sky. you are literally who we used as the reference for survivor meta-style that is used by town players as you do shit on essentially a whim at times while ignoring your own actual reads/thoughts. ironically it is most similar to tpein that will do shit just for the sake of it if it moves the game forward(in his warped perception).

the famous example being when in marvel mafia when you had a town read on curry and a scum read on me and then you voted curry with me, which was baffling. there are other things too.

Well basically I was kind of shit testing her when I told her I would be perfectly fine if she flips town and she sort of failed. You'll notice she didn't start calling me obvious scum until I reminded her she was supposed to be scum reading me. I think town Sky would be more likely to call out my responses there and get peeved.

There was also a very protracted reaction to her wagon and then she immediately claimed. What timezone is sky in? Cuz if she wasn't asleep she was basically sitting there for half a day and then immediately turned up her palms in a way I can see her doing as frozen scum
 
Let's go over the logic one more time

> I make a post about a thing I read Gad scum for probably being NAI
> Ultra: "Gad was scum that game. Why aren't you voting Gad?"
> me: "I said it's NAI for me"
> Ultra: "Why aren't you voting Gad though?"
> me: "Why do you want me to vote Gad off nothing? That doesn't feel towny and tracks with you trying to shepherd other players into random votes earlier on"
> Ultra: votes me

Town Ultra is NOT this boneheaded

mate, i'll go real slow for you.

meta is defined as behaviour someone exhibits over the course of a previous game, typically multiple games. it includes behaviour, posting style, aggression, content, etc. we all agree there.

you noticed gad posting in a style that was similar to what he did the previous game and that you scum read him for.

he was scum in the previous game. the scum read was right in that game.

you noticed him displaying similar behaviour here. similar meta.

therefore you concluding the behaviour doesn't logically track because if you think he's playing like he did last game and you read him scum for doing so last game then you should read him as scum this game. instead you concluded it was NAI. it makes it look like a fake read, one that is derived from TMI as the only logical reason youd say it's NAI, town, or not-scum behaviour is if you are scum and know he's town.
 
why does watson seem town to you? what exactly did she do to lead you to thinking she was town?
she seemed comfy in thread + liked posts 178 and 183. gut says town

honestly town reading ppl for flimsy reasoning, specially those who will be LHF and taking them away from lynch pool has been working out great for me lately
 
Distancing with your partner before your flip, good positioning.
This is exactly the kind of shit I'm talking about with Gram btw. I try to provide something and you dismiss it because of your position on me
 
Well basically I was kind of shit testing her when I told her I would be perfectly fine if she flips town and she sort of failed. You'll notice she didn't start calling me obvious scum until I reminded her she was supposed to be scum reading me. I think town Sky would be more likely to call out my responses there and get peeved.

There was also a very protracted reaction to her wagon and then she immediately claimed. What timezone is sky in? Cuz if she wasn't asleep she was basically sitting there for half a day and then immediately turned up her palms in a way I can see her doing as frozen scum
Oh hey, talking on my behalf. Telling me what I meant by things. Very towny.
 
Not very confident, but Gram's probably Town.

But he hasn't been through all his Town tells on my secret Gram Town check list yet.
 
Partly boredom, partly to get something going. Also I thought it‘s funny if Magic comes into the game with a few votes on him.
in 2011/2012 i dealt with early pressure all the time in games, with big wagons stacking on me(when games were all 20+ players). happened again in a few times over the years during for differing amount of periods. might seem new to you, but hardly something i havent dealt with.
 
mate, i'll go real slow for you.

meta is defined as behaviour someone exhibits over the course of a previous game, typically multiple games. it includes behaviour, posting style, aggression, content, etc. we all agree there.

you noticed gad posting in a style that was similar to what he did the previous game and that you scum read him for.

he was scum in the previous game. the scum read was right in that game.

you noticed him displaying similar behaviour here. similar meta.

therefore you concluding the behaviour doesn't logically track because if you think he's playing like he did last game and you read him scum for doing so last game then you should read him as scum this game. instead you concluded it was NAI. it makes it look like a fake read, one that is derived from TMI as the only logical reason youd say it's NAI, town, or not-scum behaviour is if you are scum and know he's town.
Well maybe what makes sense to me makes sense for literally no one else. That's the only conclusion I can draw
 
I'll be honest I didn't fully read the endgame post of last game, didn't remember Gad as being scum.
 
And now instead of moving on, watch everyone characterise this as a climbdown to take the heat off me
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top