• We're looking for artists. Direct message Dr. Watson for more info!

Game Ranked Hades Mafia - Game Thread

so you went through it? rather than making a straight conclusion, expand as to why you have him as town from it.
If by went through it, you mean "skimmed the first few posts before my eyes glazed over" then sure, I went through it.

He's town because scum Fang doesn't go looking for a fight against town magic. I've been told that's the way to read Fang, by you I believe actually.
 
If by went through it, you mean "skimmed the first few posts before my eyes glazed over" then sure, I went through it.

He's town because scum Fang doesn't go looking for a fight against town magic. I've been told that's the way to read Fang, by you I believe actually.

that isn't how i read him, no.

also that's somewhat weak. i dont frankly care if you town read him, as i can see that pov, i just dont like the reasoning being so dismissive.
 
that isn't how i read him, no.

also that's somewhat weak. i dont frankly care if you town read him, as i can see that pov, i just dont like the reasoning being so dismissive.
I'll admit to being dismissive, but I tend to be when I'm scrolling through post after post of what amounts to e-dick measuring.

More to the point, if you don't tone read him, what on earth are you doing? Is a long back and forth with someone as obtuse and immune to reason as Fang going to help you in any way?
 
ok so going through both ultra and pelton seems to have a thing for polar, which i agree with since that polar bear seems a bit to energetic. i agree with the singing fish bass quote. no one that would align town is that hyper.

i think i lean ultra towards town. mostly cause they seem to call out bullshit on behavior like suspicious behavior like polar or Gad.
pelton im not sure. liek some others say, this game isnt big enough to have indies in it. migth be true. i think we were 30 last time i was indie. was it the monster hunter game? not sure.

Also im leaning more gad being scum then town actually. ill have to skim him through, but the consensus from both of ultra and CP's posts seem to follow this.

Also i think aurelian is town. based on their interaction with magic and going hard on ekko.

did i miss someone?
 
I don't think is very accurate to be honest Hime. Ekko has Scum can be as tenacious as anyone - there are plenty of reasons to scum read him but I don't think him refusing to claim (I've seen him do this as town) and not fighting to the end are relevant ones. I do like that you've given it, or appeared to at least, some extra thought by reconciling what he could be aiming for, but otherwise I get the impression you want to add a new reason for the sake of adding one rather than it being a pressing observation you felt you just share.
if ekko as scum will fight just as hard to the end, what do u believe his motivation for acting like this is?
also what games did ekko refuse to claim as town? i dont recall any tbh
 
I'll admit to being dismissive, but I tend to be when I'm scrolling through post after post of what amounts to e-dick measuring.

More to the point, if you don't tone read him, what on earth are you doing? Is a long back and forth with someone as obtuse and immune to reason as Fang going to help you in any way?
do you not think a long back and forth with aurelian makes him more readable?
 
Can we have
ok so going through both ultra and pelton seems to have a thing for polar, which i agree with since that polar bear seems a bit to energetic. i agree with the singing fish bass quote. no one that would align town is that hyper.

i think i lean ultra towards town. mostly cause they seem to call out bullshit on behavior like suspicious behavior like polar or Gad.
pelton im not sure. liek some others say, this game isnt big enough to have indies in it. migth be true. i think we were 30 last time i was indie. was it the monster hunter game? not sure.

Also im leaning more gad being scum then town actually. ill have to skim him through, but the consensus from both of ultra and CP's posts seem to follow this.

Also i think aurelian is town. based on their interaction with magic and going hard on ekko.

did i miss someone?
I've seen Polar Bear more energetic than this. I even find him less agressive than when he's scum.

What do you think of Watson and Dofla?
 
if ekko as scum will fight just as hard to the end, what do u believe his motivation for acting like this is?
also what games did ekko refuse to claim as town? i dont recall any tbh
Worstgen
I have more but I can't talk about them yet (ongoing).
 
do you not think a long back and forth with aurelian makes him more readable?
No, no I do not. I think the opposite actually - in long drawn out conversations you're going to beat him logically to which he will lie and misconstrue to save face - behaviour you'd attribute to scum.
 
i voted and left.

why do you think scum would coordinate anything in the first 15 posts tho.



is what i said. you did not actual respond to either question and instead said i was speaking for him when it's clearly questioning you on the relevance of what youre saying.


im not gaslighting you because you didnt wait for the answer as i already said. if you dont wait for an answer then your question has no purpose. it didn't matter what i said, the response was always going to be "youre spending too much on orca, why arent you focusing on players you struggle on reading more". that means youre question wasn't innocent.

at that point i had barely any posts and you asked me more questions on orca while saying my main thread play was around him. that's the issue. you didn't wait to see if that would continue being my focus but instead just attacked me for it while also ignoring that it was my focus in the first place because i was being asked about it by poyser.

1) i'm not feeling any heat, i literally told you i responded so you didn't feel like your effort was a waste(and to see if your defense is in typical nature of your back and forths with people when youre town).

2) you were literally one of the last people on ekko and ignored his slot most of the day when he was actually being sussed. you took an interest when he was almost hammered. he is still going to be lynched, which most everyone has made clear this is just for getting claims before a potential janitor muddies the water.

3) it's your demeanor and tone to accusations and your theory crafting. you even initially refused to vote ekko after he put you as a suspect on his list and said you wont go there.

im not strawmanning anything, i asked you what the agenda is as you said something is an agenda from his post but didnt specify what.

i was responding to mentions and quotes, as i keep responding to you, and quite literally after you can see me catching up in the thread.

the question that i viewed as with intent was the one about who i struggle to read. it quite literally looked like you asked with the intent of using it to sus me but forgot to wait for me to answer the question before using it to sus me.


???

this last bit is the most towny part of this response as it's legitimately ???

"you should town read me and since you haven't your stalling" as that only makes sense in your own head.
1. You voting and leaving was part of my suspicion on you and your play around Melkor.
2. Yes you are trying to gaslight me; you've spent this entire time trying to paint a picture that my distrust around your answers + responses when I questioned you as not being innocent i.e. agenda driven and the implications your making is basically I'm trying to set you up.
3. The amount of posts you had in relation to Orca being called out for voting Poyser who hadn't started to play yet was initiated by me with Ultra and others coming to add their own input on how it was bad on his part. You came in while that happened to defend it and say you read him as town for that, then it snowballed from there.
4. I don't care if you don't or do feel heat, it was relatively soon that the wagon on Ekko was materializing harder and you started double downing.
5. I didn't ignore Ekko or his play in fact the evidence is there with Ultra questioning me why I was suspicious around Ekko's play. The fact I've stressed repeatedly my willingness to hammer/lynch Ekko should be obvious I shifted my position from null on him to scum reading him with current developments from last night.
6. How is my demeanor and behavior any different from any other past game I've been town? Can you actually quantify your argument that this ONE game I'm playing differently then before?
7. Don't really recall this part well but I did say Ekko typically will happily lynch or mislynch someone whose identified in his eyes as an easy info flip and it's been often a thing he did on NG and WG then here.
8. I'm just gonna repeat what I said earlier cause we're going in circles but the reason had to do with how much you were defending your stance on Orca's push to wagon Poyser. Nothing else was involved in my question to relating Orca vs Craig.
9 and final part. I asked you why your struggling to make sense of how I am putting my lens on your play with Melkor and the defense of Orca. You think I'm sussing you cause I want a town read from you? You couldn't be more wrong.
 
can you give an unbiased read on dofla pls and ty cause this aint it
i am trying to...? lol
i dont really understand the case on him in general tbh so if someone has more to add on to after this

xadlin says he scum read him bc he said "blood and darkness"
i didnt realize that was a line from this game
i just remember around the time we started dating, dofla had a zagreus avy and status "Blood and Darkness" on discord for a few months

as for ratchet, i think he said dofla was underwhelming
like im confused lol, what was the expectation?
dofla is usually a low poster in general esp when hes working

ik a few other ppl say hes tunneling luka which makes no sense
but he feels too confident abt luka to the point it feels like he actually believes it?
 
Back
Top