Game Ranked Hades Mafia - Game Thread

[The Orca]

> dofla melkor ratchet ultra magic cp lethal tpein luka
>pretty sure aurelian is town now. hes done the town tell the melkor thing is just shit content by him which is normal next
Sheeping this since it was when they were close to death.
> magic whats ur read of me?
Melkor more spew town

Most of this is just confirming what i've already thought. I genuinly think Alco is always scum here.

Can you multi quote and comment below the post? These are hard to follow

 

[Luka]

Can you multi quote and comment below the post? These are hard to follow

That's kind of a pain so I didn't want to. If I do it in the future sure.

 

[Alco]

what did you mean it was pretty in character for him?

the way he engaged you and literally spelled out his suspicion is the way I would always see Poyser doing it. So I didn't think he was faking it at all (which is what was implied by Gad (I think))

 

[Magic]

I think you're arguing in circles here - you suggested a long back and forth makes him more readable, ergo the point of the long back and forth was to get a better read of him. You're objecting to the latter statement while admitting the former.

making someone more readable doesnt mean it makes you easier to read them.

getting into an argument with someone that will shoot nonsense back at you will not make them easier to read for you, but it can for others as he's getting more involved. he has a town tell that he didnt demonstrate yet for me, but i dont really want to go for aurelian any time soon because if he is scum it will become more apparent as the game goes on anyway and the same thing is true if he's town.

 

[Hans Tweetenberg]

No, I believe that I both preformed a kill and protected myself. Outing more requires me to out my full role.

You performed a kill and protected yourself?

 

[Luka]

You performed a kill and protected yourself?

Mmhm.

 

[Ultra]

Spoiler

I think this Luka character is town.
Already dreading the potential for 2K posts by them, though.

Not very convinced by Watson's start here.


Seems a bit excessive as an answer to very minor shade.

vote Dr. Watson

why's that?

They said: "I don't love Watsons opening, kind of feels like they're not really analyzing the gamestate" -> Looks like a bit of shade going your way.
To which you then had that elaborate answer.

Looks like I'm vibing with Magic. Scum, beware

What didn't you like about it?

I like Tweet's efforts here.

I'd agree with Poyser that Dofla's wagon is not doing a lot for me. There's next to nothing in their posts.

I do however find it a bit odd that quite a few people are feeling uneasy about Watson/Retro yet no-one is willing to join me on that wagon :hogansun

I know last game I disliked his entrance and I don't get the same vibes here. His usual MO is looking for as much town reads as possible early on and seems like he's doing that here, though the Retro read is a bit generous imo. But nothing that's rubbing me the wrong way, honestly.

Should be noted I was wrong on Magic last game, however lol

just gave 'm and you probably won't like it :slip

I wanna give some town points to Aurelian for going to bat for Retro somewhat. Don't think someone would stick their neck out like that if scum tbh.

LFG

the one where he says i'm "Active lurking" or something like that? Yeah, very weak.

I'll agree the Orca read is quite random. Calling it a push when you hadn't even entered the thread yet

It's just that Magic just making random stuff up is not something he usually even does as scum though? Or am I too generous now?

Apologies, ladies and gents, I had an urgency last night. Back right now, here we go!

Did Ekko self-vote as a way of defending himself? Very bush league imo

@Gadministraitor can you tell me in your own words what about Poyser's suspicion of Magic is fake to you?

I think it's completely in character for Poyser, myself, but thanks for clarifying.

Yeah not really feeling Alco off yesterday, assuming Watson is town (which I'm not quite there yet)

Specifically because it seems like he is engaging with certain content selectively and not in proportion to what's actually abuzz in the thread, he makes a single post about Ekko self voting and that's the entire extent of his commentary while he was getting gangbanged by half the thread. Big MEH

Town Alco usually just picks a winning horse and throws his vote behind them. He gives a nod to...Magic, Poyser kinda but doesn't hold the rope. Seems a little more than just being inactive on his end.

 

[Ratchet]

making someone more readable doesnt mean it makes you easier to read them.

getting into an argument with someone that will shoot nonsense back at you will not make them easier to read for you, but it can for others as he's getting more involved. he has a town tell that he didnt demonstrate yet for me, but i dont really want to go for aurelian any time soon because if he is scum it will become more apparent as the game goes on anyway and the same thing is true if he's town.

So in plain terms, you say you has a back and forth of text walls with Fang not so you can read him better, but for the sake of everyone else?

To which I say, given that he was generally town read at that point, why did you think that was a good use of your time?

 

[Luka]

Yeah not really feeling Alco off yesterday, assuming Watson is town (which I'm not quite there yet)

Specifically because it seems like he is engaging with certain content selectively and not in proportion to what's actually abuzz in the thread, he makes a single post about Ekko self voting and that's the entire extent of his commentary while he was getting gangbanged by half the thread. Big MEH

Town Alco usually just picks a winning horse and throws his vote behind them. He gives a nod to...Magic, Poyser kinda but doesn't hold the rope. Seems a little more than just being inactive on his end.

Ultra why cant you always be this cute

 

[Magic]

So in plain terms, you say you has a back and forth of text walls with Fang not so you can read him better, but for the sake of everyone else?

To which I say, given that he was generally town read at that point, why did you think that was a good use of your time?

I'd love to see all the town reads aurelian had prior to our argument. I truly would.

 

[Ultra]

I did not outright vig them. If I did, I would've said I did. I also do not know for a fact that I preformed the kill, I just have it as a large possibility.

Seems like bullshit but you're probably not scum so w/e, but does what you claimed bear any relevance to Alco or no?

Do you think he's SK who shot you?

 

[Luka]

Town
Nibel
Hans
Dr. Watson
Xadlin
Ratchet
Ultra
Magic
Aurelia
Voyer
The Orca
Polar Bear
Game
Lord Melkor
T-Pein
Alco
Scum

 

[Magic]

If you think it's so scummy you can push me ratchet.

 

[Luka]

Seems like bullshit but you're probably not scum so w/e, but does what you claimed bear any relevance to Alco or no?

Do you think he's SK who shot you?

No I just think they're evil.

 

[Magic]

If you think it's so scummy you can push me ratchet. I insist.

 

[Luka]

Town
Nibel
Hans
Dr. Watson
Xadlin
Ratchet
Ultra
Magic
Aurelia
Voyer
The Orca
Polar Bear
Game
Lord Melkor
T-Pein
Alco
Scum

Im confident on the top 6 town. Aurelia lowered since I hated there EOD yesterday. T-Pein lowered so I can say I went 2/2 D2.

 

[Alco]

Yeah not really feeling Alco off yesterday, assuming Watson is town (which I'm not quite there yet)

Specifically because it seems like he is engaging with certain content selectively and not in proportion to what's actually abuzz in the thread, he makes a single post about Ekko self voting and that's the entire extent of his commentary while he was getting gangbanged by half the thread. Big MEH

Town Alco usually just picks a winning horse and throws his vote behind them. He gives a nod to...Magic, Poyser kinda but doesn't hold the rope. Seems a little more than just being inactive on his end.

The bolded thing in the second paragraph is fair, tbh.

 

[Ratchet]

Seems like bullshit but you're probably not scum so w/e, but does what you claimed bear any relevance to Alco or no?

Do you think he's SK who shot you?

Why couldn't he be Mafia shooting him? Not trying to "gotcha" you here, just not seeing why you have him as SK.

 

[Luka]

The bolded thing in the second paragraph is fair, tbh.

Are you planning to do anything productive within the next year or no?

 

[Ratchet]

I'd love to see all the town reads aurelian had prior to our argument. I truly would.

Do you *really* believe the reads on Fang are a product of your interaction with him? Stop it.