• We're looking for artists. Direct message Dr. Watson for more info!

Game Ranked Hades Mafia - Game Thread

Reader mode
RDK said:
Think you have tmi and only started to divert from that when I mentioned it. Very transparent
Click to expand...

Nah.
I have been focusing on the ekko wagon all game.
Literally.
You trying to shade me by saying there is no scum in those 4 I want to lynch in is silly.
Would mean the 4 scums are all the outside voters which include you, evans, tweet and aurelian.

Like I said
Scum would want to look good by lynching a scum d1.
Simple.
It wasn't just magic there.
 
T-Pein™ said:
Nah.
I have been focusing on the ekko wagon all game.
Literally.
You trying to shade me by saying there is no scum in those 4 I want to lynch in is silly.
Would mean the 4 scums are all the outside voters which include you, evans, tweet and aurelian.

Like I said
Scum would want to look good by lynching a scum d1.
Simple.
It wasn't just magic there.
Click to expand...
You didn't even consider the other 4 until I said you had tmi

Wack
 
Ratchet said:
Possible yes but doesn't make much sense it makes for RDK to claim Xadlin's role now. Especially because he can quite easily get Evans over here.
Click to expand...

Wut?
He is trying to live.
Anyway,
He isn't playing very indie
Was pretending to be town and still doing it rn.
 
I think I can buy that he's Indie from play. He has been very tame. If he is, I think he's probably hostile and lying about being a Survivor. Reading the wiki, Demeter becomes very cold and bitter once Persephone dies, creating "the endless winter".

The problem is if we lynch him and he is indie, with Fang claiming hated (@Aurelian did you mention how long it's for?) we could be looking at effective LyLo tomorrow. If I'm going for Mafia then I'd pick Evans over him.

The problem with that is he is probably an arsonist who has had at least 1 cycle to douse. He could then probably get two more deaths by which point it's basically LyLo anyway (might even be game over). I suppose we could have @Ultra jail him tonight but that has us relying on roles working all correctly which isn't something I'm eager to do.
 
Considering Evans claim some more. As claimed it's quite powerful - it's basically a stronger motivator because not only does it refill a shot, it negates the "Burst" restriction some other roles have had (Burst = non-consecutive). Given that we already have a refiller flipped in Hime it's not great. My biggest issue is Alco's non-usage Night 1. We had just had a scum flip and because his role is a double-edged sword he neglects to use it at all... I think he could have safely used it on someone like Poyser or Ultra there factoring in the risk associated. I'm going to go look for his reads.
 
Ratchet said:
Considering Evans claim some more. As claimed it's quite powerful - it's basically a stronger motivator because not only does it refill a shot, it negates the "Burst" restriction some other roles have had (Burst = non-consecutive). Given that we already have a refiller flipped in Hime it's not great. My biggest issue is Alco's non-usage Night 1. We had just had a scum flip and because his role is a double-edged sword he neglects to use it at all... I think he could have safely used it on someone like Poyser or Ultra there factoring in the risk associated. I'm going to go look for his reads.
Click to expand...
I interpreted Evans claim as being able to give everyone a free shot at night, not just one person.

Hence the name "party time"
 
Can't say I buy the two survivors shtick tho, especially since Himes flip said somebody is hunting for her. That doesn't sound non-hostile to me at all.

I also know that Gram likes to have some sort of indy killing role in the game to counteract strong bussing plays from scum, and it also used to be that he hates survivors. I can't buy two survivors in the same Gram game tbh.
 
Ratchet said:
I think I can buy that he's Indie from play. He has been very tame. If he is, I think he's probably hostile and lying about being a Survivor. Reading the wiki, Demeter becomes very cold and bitter once Persephone dies, creating "the endless winter".

The problem is if we lynch him and he is indie, with Fang claiming hated (@Aurelian did you mention how long it's for?) we could be looking at effective LyLo tomorrow. If I'm going for Mafia then I'd pick Evans over him.

The problem with that is he is probably an arsonist who has had at least 1 cycle to douse. He could then probably get two more deaths by which point it's basically LyLo anyway (might even be game over). I suppose we could have @Ultra jail him tonight but that has us relying on roles working all correctly which isn't something I'm eager to do.
Click to expand...
This is weird.

If you think I'm hostile then wouldn't you want scum to have to deal with me. Why would you be asking ultra to protect me

Also arsonist spec is shite when there's no evidence of a firefighter or the like

I'm a Survivor. Flavor spec is also strictly advised against
 
Hans Tweetenberg said:
Can't say I buy the two survivors shtick tho, especially since Himes flip said somebody is hunting for her. That doesn't sound non-hostile to me at all.

I also know that Gram likes to have some sort of indy killing role in the game to counteract strong bussing plays from scum, and it also used to be that he hates survivors. I can't buy two survivors in the same Gram game tbh.
Click to expand...
You'll see when I flip. My wincon would have been far too easy if hime knew she could just hint her character to me.

I literally just had to visit her and we both won.

Said if I safely visit her I will return with her to Olympius victorious and the game will continue if possible
 
Ratchet said:
I think I can buy that he's Indie from play. He has been very tame. If he is, I think he's probably hostile and lying about being a Survivor. Reading the wiki, Demeter becomes very cold and bitter once Persephone dies, creating "the endless winter".

The problem is if we lynch him and he is indie, with Fang claiming hated (@Aurelian did you mention how long it's for?) we could be looking at effective LyLo tomorrow. If I'm going for Mafia then I'd pick Evans over him.

The problem with that is he is probably an arsonist who has had at least 1 cycle to douse. He could then probably get two more deaths by which point it's basically LyLo anyway (might even be game over). I suppose we could have @Ultra jail him tonight but that has us relying on roles working all correctly which isn't something I'm eager to do.
Click to expand...
As I told Ultra I have no idea if this status ailment is just for this day or permanent.
 
RDK said:
You'll see when I flip. My wincon would have been far too easy if hime knew she could just hint her character to me.

I literally just had to visit her and we both won.

Said if I safely visit her I will return with her to Olympius victorious and the game will continue if possible
Click to expand...
I guess her thing could have just said nothing but even still I think I'd have easily identified her
 
RDK said:
This is weird.

If you think I'm hostile then wouldn't you want scum to have to deal with me. Why would you be asking ultra to protect me

Also arsonist spec is shite when there's no evidence of a firefighter or the like

I'm a Survivor. Flavor spec is also strictly advised against
Click to expand...
I'm asking him to block you. Or rather, suggesting that he could. As I said in the post, if you *are* an arsonist your kills could take us to LyLo anyway and I assume you'd be igniting tonight regardless. Jailing you should avert that. Keyword being "should".

A Firefighter does not need to exist for an Arsonist to be present, and given you claim to have an alternate wincon I don't think it's required at all.
 
Ratchet said:
I'm asking him to block you. Or rather, suggesting that he could. As I said in the post, if you *are* an arsonist your kills could take us to LyLo anyway and I assume you'd be igniting tonight regardless. Jailing you should avert that. Keyword being "should".

A Firefighter does not need to exist for an Arsonist to be present, and given you claim to have an alternate wincon I don't think it's required at all.
Click to expand...
Being an arsonist that couldn't douse until at LEAST n3 would be such a hard wincon come on now
 
RDK said:
Being an arsonist that couldn't douse until at LEAST n3 would be such a hard wincon come on now
Click to expand...
Sure it would - but you have an alternate one so.

I know you're saying to ignore flavour here, and I take that point, but I find it very very hard to believe you'd be able to just find the existing survivor, and if you fail, you just become a survivor instead. Arsonist is the only explanation I have for the kills.
 
Ratchet said:
I find it very very hard to believe you'd be able to just find the existing survivor, and if you fail, you just become a survivor instead.
Click to expand...
Yes, which is exactly what makes it difficult and exactly why I decided to claim VT.
 
Reader mode
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top