• We're looking for artists. Direct message Dr. Watson for more info!

Game Ranked OLF Christmas Mafia 2023 (Day 9)

I think Governor is the foil to day shortener. Scum can shorten day to priories their choice of lynch and town can block the lynch altogether
 
No I mean, why does she say hes town because hes a tree stump? It doesnt make any sense

I dont really like that whole sequence tbh lol. Odo obv knew exactly what he was doing with his soft, which pretty clearly implied he was a PGO. It wards off people from visiting/killing him when in fact he should realistically be hoping to draw roles, not the opposite

Errrr

If I was a PGO I’d say no visitors

I specifically singled out protection

Bad bad bad
 
Ironically Poyser you're falling for the same trap you're trying to catch me in - you're responding in the negative without having given the point due consideration, you're just saying it's bad because that's the position you've opted to go for. I don't expect you'll be able to explain why it's bad, or why you're dismissing the meat of the post by only focusing on the very first part of it.
 
Go on, what's the pro town utility of the role?

Nah, he’s 100% correct about that lol
No, I dont mean governor is pro town. I mean the fact that that was his initial reaction just shown that he didn't at all think about the claim or the implications of it. If he did, the first thought would have been "eh well, I suppose it would be unlikely that mafia would have both a governor and a day shortener" but he didn't, he just said it was anti town and continued pushing her. To me it looks like an agenda

And like, his whole point on her is that she presented (in his POV) a garbage case on him, but like... That doesnt make her scum? Certainly not sure fire scum, dont consider her claim kind of scum in any case. Btw, his entire case on Evans is essentially the same thing. Feels like he is bringing absolutely nothing to the table this game
 
What's the rationale about claiming that as scum?
Denied - the act of claiming it isn't indicative of alignment, the fact you have to post it to the thread means you wouldn't be able to hide it. And moreover, you're not ever really even going to have the prove the role, because the very act of testing it out is anti town.
 
No, I dont mean governor is pro town. I mean the fact that that was his initial reaction just shown that he didn't at all think about the claim or the implications of it. If he did, the first thought would have been "eh well, I suppose it would be unlikely that mafia would have both a governor and a day shortener" but he didn't, he just said it was anti town and continued pushing her. To me it looks like an agenda

And like, his whole point on her is that she presented (in his POV) a garbage case on him, but like... That doesnt make her scum? Certainly not sure fire scum, dont consider her claim kind of scum in any case. Btw, his entire case on Evans is essentially the same thing. Feels like he is bringing absolutely nothing to the table this game
Uh oh! The point was about the role independent of itself - see my follow up responses for the consideration about how it jives with the day shortener. You're making it into something it's not.
 
No I mean, why does she say hes town because hes a tree stump? It doesnt make any sense

I dont really like that whole sequence tbh lol. Odo obv knew exactly what he was doing with his soft, which pretty clearly implied he was a PGO. It wards off people from visiting/killing him when in fact he should realistically be hoping to draw roles, not the opposite

Ekko could have written this post
 
Also my point on Flower's push Poyser wasn't that her case was garbage, but that it didn't track as a genuine piece of analysis. It's similar to Evans in that I argue he, too, came into the thread with an agenda and angle to push. That's the part that makes them scum, not the quality of the arguments themselves.
 
Back
Top