Game Ranked Tower of God Mafia Thread

[Dr_Professor83]

Like?

The bus drive as an explanation (which I was wrong about while spit balling)

The Ichigo voting Melkor that Ratchet made looking bad for Ichigo (that he also realized was bad)

 

[Magic]

The backup vig is a funky claim, but I can kinda see it. I believe Polar and Fang's claims.

So you don't believe Ultra? Can you tell me why you believe those 3 claims over the others.

 

[Ratchet]

@Magic I take your point. I think there have been some angles today that have been weak. But you're asking me to believe that he, as scum, is basically throwing when he has no good reason to do so unless he wants out of the game quickly. Which isn't an assumption I'm going to be working towards. Like he has a tracker claim and then just burns it on fake info that gets caught out immediately. It's a lot easier for me to reconcile that he's town in comparison because at least the errors would be genuine.

 

[MangoSenpai]

How are you not agreeing with me when that's the premise of my argument?

He should have known aurelian is town and instead of looking at the proposed evidence he ignored it and called me scum while trying to force aurelian to claim. Aurelian was my wagon and he had me as scum and yet he jumped onto my wagon against him which town ultra wouldn't do as it's aligning himself with his scum read for no reason.

There was the melkor case which was bad and also wrong and it was brought up repeatedly that Melkor is a tough slot to solve and yet he pressed on.

I know I'm town and his continued shit with me also doesn't look right. He's also only not lying if a second redirection role is in play. He also continues to tell people he has info on me when it's been proven to him that he doesn't. Even his argument with tweet was about him bussing but turns out he's just an indy so that had no basis either and the scum read he accused tweet of bussing was gad who he seemingly has no interest in pushing as an alternative direction while having brought him up since day 1

No I mean in general, I've found myself on the other side of the argument in a lot of cases you've made - I do think Ultra as scum holds merit here - but I don't think it's the best play to gun for the claimed Tracker right now.

Anyway - I feel like I'm being split many ways so I feel almost directionless atp.

 

[Dr_Professor83]

If ratchet isn’t actually a town vig, there’s no trap

You realise this right?

I do. But I’m going with Magic’s view here. I think if Jag is town Ratchet is less likely to be town (and vice versa)

 

[Magic]

Why do you seemingly not care about gad anymore?

 

[Ultra]

The bus drive as an explanation (which I was wrong about while spit balling)

The Ichigo voting Melkor that Ratchet made looking bad for Ichigo (that he also realized was bad)

I've clocked a couple of different instances of Ichigo's claim not adding up with his progression so you're going to have to specify a bit more what you disagree with and why

 

[Ratchet]

As far as Jag goes, I would expect that to be the Cop alternative so it should be self-resolving.

 

[MangoSenpai]

I do. But I’m going with Magic’s view here. I think if Jag is town Ratchet is less likely to be town (and vice versa)

Why does Jag being town = Ratchet less likely to be?

Wouldn't a secondary vig be a trap for Gunsmith?

 

[Dr_Professor83]

I've clocked a couple of different instances of Ichigo's claim not adding up with his progression so you're going to have to specify a bit more what you disagree with and why

The one about Ratchet saying Ichigo voting Melkor D1 was bad

 

[Ultra]

Why do you seemingly not care about gad anymore?

I liked his play a bit more today

 

[Dr_Professor83]

Why does Jag being town = Ratchet less likely to be?

Wouldn't a secondary vig be a trap for Gunsmith?

Bc I don’t think we get the double layered trap wombo combo

This is like inception levels of trying to make town trip over themselves at that point

 

[Ultra]

The one about Ratchet saying Ichigo voting Melkor D1 was bad

Elaborate

 

[Dr_Professor83]

It’s a trap within a trap lol

 

[Magic]

Why does Jag being town = Ratchet less likely to be?

Wouldn't a secondary vig be a trap for Gunsmith?

The second vig is already a trap for town and so on top of that we had another trap for town with the vig roles? Again duplicate vigs always ends up with one lynched or them shooting one another.

 

[Grammaton]

I’m now curious about what mango tried to do to me, given that it wasn’t copping, watching or tracking?

 

[Magic]

I liked his play a bit more today

What about his play and starting when?

 

[Ultra]

So you don't believe Ultra? Can you tell me why you believe those 3 claims over the others.

The dude didn't say a word about me

 

[Dr_Professor83]

Well he actually voted Melkor instead of saying "hmm, hang on a minute..."

So if his contention is through his role, well that doesn't make sense as he didn't contend it Day 1.

Oh

Yeah that's a nail in the coffin isn't it

There ya go Ultra

 

[Sharter Holmes]

I mean, Tweet / You / Ratchet were all lynchable tohugh. A scum doesn't have to sacrifice his life, especially w/ a claimed vig esque role in Ratchet.

Were?