Game Ranked Castlevania animated series Mafia - Game Thread

[Tempest]

,

He skipped answer questions here just as in a prior scum game

Did tweet ever explain his vote of ekko?

Ultra. He's not following through on getting claims. He's twisting peoples words and thoughts. But he's also making sense at times

which claims has he not followed through on? from what I recall he's pushed luka, ratchet, and emil. We have 2/3 of their claims.

 

[Emil]

@Ratchet may i ask why do u have polar as town btw

 

[Ratchet]

@Ratchet may i ask why do u have polar as town btw

Few reasons, none really great so it's on the weaker side. I liked his early play around Orca, even more so now that Orca has made himself obvious town, I also liked that he tagged Magic and Ultra early for their thoughts on one another, just felt like something he wouldn't go for as scum.

 

[Tempest]

Want to let Tweet play for a bit and frankly I have no doubt I won't get my lynch anyway so I'm playing to solve the game rather than get lynches. I haven't retracted any position on Tweet, I've simply moved my vote to who I think the worst voter on Tweet's wagon was, and see what that turns up.

@Emil This was after the unvote. He says he hasn't retracted his read, he just thinks he won't get his lynch (despite the fact he was getting plenty of support!)

Then this:

The Orca - Town
Polar Bear^ - Town
Emil^ - Town
Chairman Nibel^ - Town
Hans Tweetenberg - Could be Scum
Magic - Null
Ratchet - Town
Lethal^ - Town
Ultra - Could be Scum
hime - Could be Scum
One Last Username - Town
Luka - Town
Xadlin - Could be Scum
Tempest - Town
Psychic - Null
Jesse Pinkman - Null
Bachi - Town
DoflaMihawk - Town

^ Weaker sided reads. I could flip Ekko as he may just be TMI'ing me, but I'm not going to get there today.

Scum PoE so far is Tweet/Ultra/hime/Xadlin, and then Magic/Jesse/Psychic.

I don't think the scum team quite fits as a teams anyway. Ultra and Tweet being together doesn't really make sense to me. I could see hime being aligned with Ultra. Xadlin... I could see the attempt to spin me unvoting Tweet as scummy to deflect from him. Doesn't look great for Tempest either here though because he sees me support his wagon and then what, drops his suspicion? Like @Tempest do you think I'm scum with Xadlin then?

Given the above, Tweet could be the Town in there. At which point I'd probably bring Craig down a level into Null, or maybe into lean scum. I don't think the entire scum team would act in concert here though.

I have Dofla town because he won't be scum with Tweet. If Tweet is Town that read is retracted. If Tweet is scum, Ultra is probably Town, hime could be scum with him (Tweet). I think with all that considered I'm left with a primary PoE of

Xadlin/hime/Tweet
Ultra secondary
And then based on the flips of the above, room for Jesse/Polar/Ekko/Magic/Tempest.

He conditions "Tweet could be town" on a bunch of other things happening first, namely some combo of me, Xadlin, and Ultra flipping scum. It's nothing to do with tweet's actual play.

 

[Ratchet]

@Emil This was after the unvote. He says he hasn't retracted his read, he just thinks he won't get his lynch (despite the fact he was getting plenty of support!)

Then this:


He conditions "Tweet could be town" on a bunch of other things happening first, namely some combo of me, Xadlin, and Ultra flipping scum. It's nothing to do with tweet's actual play.

Is that not evidence of me backing away from the scum read tho?

 

[Tempest]

And again, tweet hadn't even claimed. So complaining about "I won't get my lynch" when you haven't even gotten your wagon target to claim comes off rather precious. Maybe his claim will bring him more suspicion? Or it'll be town clearing and you won't want to lynch him anyway and you can use that to help refine your solve? Why complain before any of this happens?

 

[Ultra]

@Ultra

Why so reluctant to claim flavor and character?

Stubborness, mostly. That information is really only beneficial to bad actors

 

[Tempest]

Is that not evidence of me backing away from the scum read tho?

no because you explicitly said you didn't retract it and you put him down as scum in your following reads list! what?!

 

[Magic]

y did i focus on the top 2 posters i scumread in a game that just started?
is that ur question?

this is funny
i love how ppl r acting like ive committed a cardinal sin by talking abt my top 2 scum reads
this is honestly even worse than what ratchet is crying abt considering id basically just started playing at the point of the quotes u quoted and im the one who started the wagon in the first place

Ya.

It's objectively worse to just focus on scum reads than trying to find town.

 

[Magic]

Who thinks ratchet/ultra are t/t?

 

[Emil]

Few reasons, none really great so it's on the weaker side. I liked his early play around Orca, even more so now that Orca has made himself obvious town, I also liked that he tagged Magic and Ultra early for their thoughts on one another, just felt like something he wouldn't go for as scum.

the magic ultra thing shudnt be a point if they r both scum with polar no? even if one of them is

as for the orca thing, i find polar overexplaining the town read of orca unnecessarily and leaning too much into it. think polar is legit frozen and using orca as a crux to argue against orca's voters

 

[Tempest]

Ya.

It's objectively worse to just focus on scum reads than trying to find town.

would love for you to catch up and weigh in on ratchet here btw

 

[Emil]

Who thinks ratchet/ultra are t/t?

i was but i expect them to find each other by now if that was the case

 

[Magic]

i was but i expect them to find each other by now if that was the case

Why?

Once they dig their heels in do you think they would relent?

 

[Ultra]

i was but i expect them to find each other by now if that was the case

suboptimal scumming, you gotta play both sides. Stop pussy wolfing

 

[Ratchet]

no because you explicitly said you didn't retract it and you put him down as scum in your following reads list! what?!

I refer you to my current list.

 

[Tempest]

I refer you to my current list.

already covered it, again you didn't reference his play

 

[Polar Bear]

which claims has he not followed through on? from what I recall he's pushed luka, ratchet, and emil. We have 2/3 of their claims.

He half assed ratchet and emil. Ratchet claimed without pressure imo and emil has virtually none

 

[Emil]

@Emil This was after the unvote. He says he hasn't retracted his read, he just thinks he won't get his lynch (despite the fact he was getting plenty of support!)

Then this:


He conditions "Tweet could be town" on a bunch of other things happening first, namely some combo of me, Xadlin, and Ultra flipping scum. It's nothing to do with tweet's actual play.

thats 3 points for Gryffindor

ratchet's team falling down

if u havent retracted any position from tweet u shud have continued with pushing him until claim / wait to see how xadlin/tweet interact when xadlin wakes up. i think moving from tweet there given ur position on him is scummy on a second look.

otherwise not sure why wud u say that. i thought tweet came off townier and if u had said this u going off of him wud have been alot better

i wud still prefer not to day 1 ratchet over xadlin, but i dont have him as townie as before. and i think xadlin is probably scum and ratchet can easily be bussing there to cement himself before pushing for tweet or w.e later

as for ultra, i feel like smth is still off. maybe this is a serial vs mafia scenario

 

[Ultra]

He half assed ratchet and emil. Ratchet claimed without pressure imo and emil has virtually none

You and Orca both have him as scum, why don't you vote him you lazy bums