Game Ranked Better Call Saul Mafia Game Thread [Game End - Serial Killer Victory]

[.guillo]

Polar bear and orca

I have no idea what guillo is doing

That is cause you are frozen, with no original thoughts and in defensive mode.

How about we do this...

UNVOTE

I'm willing to let you breathe in exchange for you to read the thread and then give me a readlist structured like this:

Town

Not Sure

Scum

Along with the reasons of those placements. I wanna see where you are at.

 

[.guillo]

In the meantime I'm gonna place my vote here

VOTE to lynch: Chairman Nibel

​

 

[The Orca]

For sure, but firstm may I ask?
How long have you been playing Mafia? this is a genuine question.

You may, but I will answer later. Not needed to answer the question

 

[Cubey]

@.guillo alright

 

[.guillo]

You may, but I will answer later. Not needed to answer the question

I actually need it, please cooperate

 

[The Orca]

I actually need it, please cooperate

You do not. You and Flower have said the same thing, based on what is in the thread. You can answer with what is provided already in the thread

 

[Cubey]

Town

Polar bear (same sus list as me)
Orca (see polar bear)
Rdk (said he was joking but I think there was truth in his lynch votes)

Not sure

Ratchet (I might’ve accidentally gotten the doc to role reveal)
Dr. Watson (said she wanted to hear my side, never commented on it)

Anti-Town

Flower
.guillo
Hans tweetenberg

 

[.guillo]

You do not. You and Flower have said the same thing, based on what is in the thread. You can answer with what is provided already in the thread

Ok, I will answer, someone has to be the grown up here.

 

[The Orca]

Ok, I will answer, someone has to be the grown up here.

Not about being grown up. You said it was OMGUS, you should be able to explain how without further information provided

 

[.guillo]

Night 4 is a long time though, some games end earlier.

Would be rather bold claim as scum, since no one would wait 3 days without demaning full claim?

I like Melkor's progression here: First he thought just about the same thing Orca did, but then I can see him thinking about it and seeing that such claim is not exactly a move scum would do.

 

[Polar Bear]

This is what flower looks like as town

 

[Polar Bear]

 

[Cubey]

Lmao

 

[Polar Bear]

This game, she sounds more like this....

 

[Polar Bear]

 

[The Orca]

DotG:

 

[.guillo]

So who claimed and why already?

This is your first game relevant post.

Yes, that guy would maybe work as commuter, not sure why a doctor?

This is Melkor debating with Flower why Cubey's doctor claim does not make sense for Cubey's flavor claim.

Cubey is likely scum, but do we not want to use our time?

This is Melkor scum reding Cubey but also bringing up the fact that if we all pile of Cubey, and keep tunneling just Cubey, we kill the thread.

Vote lynch Orca

Then he goes and votes for his second suspect, you, Orca.

Absolute worst vote i have seen is Melkor. Ugly. Performance with no conviction behind it imo. I dont think he really wants to vote me. Probably a place holder for scum to move later or just an easy vote and dip lol

This is your overblown reaction to his vote, which is straight up OMGUS.

No, i voted you because I did not like your entrance.

And this is the reason for why he voted you, which i can see a concern for as your first game relevant post was about who claimed a role, which is a weird thing to ask if you are uninformed of what is going on. Hmmmmmm

 

[.guillo]

And thanks to this analysis, I see more reasons to scum read you, except, if Cubey is scum, would he be so clumsy as to associate you with his by pleading to you about me and my read on Polar Bear?

 

[The Orca]

This is your first game relevant post.

This is Melkor debating with Flower why Cubey's doctor claim does not make sense for Cubey's flavor claim.

This is Melkor scum reding Cubey but also bringing up the fact that if we all pile of Cubey, and keep tunneling just Cubey, we kill the thread.

Then he goes and votes for his second suspect, you, Orca.

This is your overblown reaction to his vote, which is straight up OMGUS.

And this is the reason for why he voted you, which i can see a concern for as your first game relevant post was about who claimed a role, which is a weird thing to ask if you are uninformed of what is going on. Hmmmmmm

Let me know when you want to explain how its OMGUS, you avoided the actual question at hand entirely again lmao

 

[.guillo]

Town

Polar bear (same sus list as me)
Orca (see polar bear)
Rdk (said he was joking but I think there was truth in his lynch votes)

Not sure

Ratchet (I might’ve accidentally gotten the doc to role reveal)
Dr. Watson (said she wanted to hear my side, never commented on it)

Anti-Town

Flower
.guillo
Hans tweetenberg

This readlist is disappointing. This is the kind of readlist I expect scum to make.

"I townread Polar Bear and Orca because they have the same reads as me"
and I scum read my two main pushers, which is quite the coincidence.

I wanna know though, why is Tweet in your scum pile as he has been defending you? Why is he any different than Polar and Orca?