• We're looking for artists. Direct message Dr. Watson for more info!

Game Ranked Dune Mafia - town victory

Status
Not open for further replies.
This term is a joke
No it's true. Scum will either have to keep her alive for mislynch bait, and risk her catching then, or kill her and solve the PoE for us. She basically has what, one extra night as scum here? Of course your conclusion is scum will fall over themselves to give her that one night, because you're not actually interested in thinking, but for the room and all that.
 
You can gaslight and sus me for this all you want, i will get in the way of killing the claimed Watcher today, all step of the way.
In fact, if you were to wagon me and Watson, make us competing wagons and we are tied, i'd self vote to save her.

It's not gaslighting

I'm telling you that the logical outcome of your play, which is that you wanted to vote different people today who hasn't claimed yet, was almost always gonna lead to PR claims. Hence my confusion about your standpoint. This may be too nuanced for you.

You should consider listening to people who play here a bit more on what is likely to be expected here
 
No it's true. Scum will either have to keep her alive for mislynch bait, and risk her catching then, or kill her and solve the PoE for us. She basically has what, one extra night as scum here? Of course your conclusion is scum will fall over themselves to give her that one night, because you're not actually interested in thinking, but for the room and all that.

Ok, I'm sure we will come back and remember to lynch her when the game is already effectively over
 
It's not gaslighting

I'm telling you that the logical outcome of your play, which is that you wanted to vote different people today who hasn't claimed yet, was almost always gonna lead to PR claims. Hence my confusion about your standpoint. This may be too nuanced for you.

You should consider listening to people who play here a bit more on what is likely to be expected here
No.

My way has worked very fine.

The answer is no on Watson.

Period.
 
Ok, I'm sure we will come back and remember to lynch her when the game is already effectively over
You keep saying this but it isn't really true, I would go as far as to say that even surviving the night is pretty bad for her. So, your argument is the game will be over if we don't lynch her... exactly today?

It's not a very good argument. It's fallacious even, given that it appeals to fear.
 
Day 1 I wanted Aurelian, almost got it, then it evaporated and Ultra got his lynch. Mislynch. Okay so Day 2, and I've gone over Ultra enough today. He immediately saddles up to Poyser when Watson goes on the table, and then somehow fits them all into his scum team because he just says so. And while I don't really see them as teamed, I do have to say that Poyser watching this all go down, nodding his head and thinking "yup, that sure is Town Ultra" is pretty baffling to me.
 
Day 1 I wanted Aurelian, almost got it, then it evaporated and Ultra got his lynch. Mislynch. Okay so Day 2, and I've gone over Ultra enough today. He immediately saddles up to Poyser when Watson goes on the table, and then somehow fits them all into his scum team because he just says so. And while I don't really see them as teamed, I do have to say that Poyser watching this all go down, nodding his head and thinking "yup, that sure is Town Ultra" is pretty baffling to me.
Then what you wanna do?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top