Nah, his logic is fine, I don’t particularly agree with the conclusion but as far as I’m concerned, in a pure contest of rationality, you both got rings ran around you
- It's that time of the year again! Just kidding, we were late.
Click here to see the awards and nominate people for the rest of the categories.
- We're looking for artists. Direct message Dr. Watson for more info!
- Status
Nah, his logic is fine, I don’t particularly agree with the conclusion but as far as I’m concerned, in a pure contest of rationality, you both got rings ran around you
Can you describe what made you read Sky as town? Specifically. Your provided reason is "she doesn't always make sense as town", but I don't see why that observation couldn't have been made when you first voted her
i dont think anyone i said has been disproven. i said you had great confidence in reading gad and i proved it. ultra tried saying it wouldnt apply to you town reading him when it was clear from your day 2 posts last game that it would apply regardless of alignment(you find it easy to find him town).
your mentions of gad were a slight town read without elaboration and a null read, the former which i brought up myself.
that was another thought i had but i find your posts more scummy than his which is why i was talking about you and not him. like from my pov i wouldnt have him as more scummy. my thought is that if you are town, which you know if you are or not, then rather than pairing yourself with the idea "people that read me town are town and people that dont are scum" maybe consider deeper as that's self serving.
like im obviously not going to just sit here and pretend like he would never misread you, ever.
@DoflaMihawk who do u have scum rn aside from nibel?
No, it‘s not. Magic going for me instead of Ultra is not logical. It would require Ultra to be wrong about me as Town, which, let‘s face it, he just isn‘t. If you think it‘s not S/S and think Ultra is defending me you would draw the conclusion a scum Ultra is pocketing a Town Flower and, as Town, go after the likelier scum. Who is Ultra. Magic is trying to derail.
to be clear i do not town read sky.
i just refuse to bank the entirety of day 1 on the idea she has to be scum and in the scenario she isn't i want the game to have been explored elsewhere. i can definitely see a world in which she is town and in that case if we just straight lynch her what exactly do i get out of it?
inb4 because i said u wud be scum if u tunnel
least u came to ur senses. this playstyle is inspired by yours. maybe we can work together this game. first you must know that we follow my rules
if i help u see flower as town can u support us on gad/sky?
i suppose we can do dofla too for ultra
btw this isn't logic, this is bias.
"ultra wouldn't ever misread me so he should be scum reading ultra and not me".
that's from your own biased point of view of him never misreading you. that doesn't mean logically i should think the same way as thinking someone never misreads another player is illogical
ive been messing around alot with chatGPT recently, it gives based NAI responses
Excuses.
Where this falls apart is it requires the assumption you are town. His points on you are predicated on sky flipping town, so what’s wrong with directing the questions at you and seeing how you respond?
The whole neurotic ‘anyone sussing me is scum’ thing is just boring as fuck to deal with, please put it away
Ok great. Your proposed alternative is town, pick another one, like, I dunno the guy in the lead wagon currently emoting around his claim
Sky
So unreliable.
Your entire case is predicated on me being scum which isn't true lol
i just did that in the last game too. with town.
Ultra and Whicker and perhaps Lethal
I would just drop the subject on these particular grounds, it's noise generating. If he's scum you're giving him more license to tunnel you, it's not going anywhere either way
Please claim immediately
- Status