Game Ranked All of Us Are Dead Mafia

[Aurelian]

This has happened to me. It cancels out a bunch

Seems like more than 3 quotes on mobile only works on the default OLF (Dark) skin.

 

[Aurelian]

...But the scum read in question was accurate, so why do you feel assured? You said knowing this could have saved you grief last game? How?

Help me out, Sky.

Whats with both you and Dofla choosing to avoid my questions and respond to other shit

Dofla sus
Sky Sus

Magic's case kinda shite. Didn't like the follow up with saying flower is not fluffing enough or whatever.
Don't see Magic/Sky as scum/scum because Sky has attached to him like a leech in a very open manner

im down to yeet gad/sky

ultra flower watson seem town

nibel lean town. he can make shit up without caring so not going to underestimate him. he hasn't done any solving when talking to me/flower earlier

Brief skim but I fail to see where Flower is getting equity between Sky and Dofla from. I mean, I have the first 6 pages to read and context to fill in, but that lack of sound explanation is just a red flag. Wolf Sky is not going to run at Ultra.

Also find it strange that Flower is going in on this and not from my early POV trying to find town.

Then why not hard push Ultra?

Because again, I am the only one who would do so, and it would be a waste of time

Literally my only motive to not vote Ultra if I were scum would be if (1) Ultra is scum with me AND (2) Nibel is town

Lynching scum Ultra is possible D1. Idk why you would chicken out.

Those reasons in questions being?

Your early D1, trying to lead people astray into random lynches. There's not a town motive to do that

Yeah, Sky is just scum here. Since when are certain players above getting lynched D1. This just looks like AtE and I hate it.

Distancing with your partner before your flip, good positioning.

Let's go over the logic one more time

> I make a post about a thing I read Gad scum for probably being NAI
> Ultra: "Gad was scum that game. Why aren't you voting Gad?"
> me: "I said it's NAI for me"
> Ultra: "Why aren't you voting Gad though?"
> me: "Why do you want me to vote Gad off nothing? That doesn't feel towny and tracks with you trying to shepherd other players into random votes earlier on"
> Ultra: votes me

Town Ultra is NOT this boneheaded

Mmm yeah this is like talking to a brick wall.

You never responded to when I called you out for your fake catch up either.



Sky or Dofla are both good choices

what im wondering is if youre considering if this at all on brand for her as town.


historically that isn't true at all sky. you are literally who we used as the reference for survivor meta-style that is used by town players as you do shit on essentially a whim at times while ignoring your own actual reads/thoughts. ironically it is most similar to tpein that will do shit just for the sake of it if it moves the game forward(in his warped perception).

the famous example being when in marvel mafia when you had a town read on curry and a scum read on me and then you voted curry with me, which was baffling. there are other things too.

somewhat relatively confident aurelian is town. could change but i liked his push on nibel in terms of what it means towards his alignment.

also lethal can be scum, haven't shit talked any of my posts yet. either that or i've magically became a good player!

@Gadministraitor

i read nibel as town as he didn't seem as hesitant this game being involved and was more fluffy and care free earlier on. last game it seemed like with every post he was trying his best to make himself look town whereas this game it doesn't read the same at all.

similarly with your content it feels a lot more focused on actually doing something rather than entirely fluffing and acting lost while struggling making reads(which would be more of the case in a return game where you draw scum vs your return game as town).

Vote Lynch Sky

What dispelled this fear in the hour you were away

That it still couldn't explain the wagon on me + you were still voting on me.

Really kind of emotes I hate

i havent liked ekko's play all game fwiw. it feels heavily lacking and streamlined.

You have nothing better to say? Why do you really wonder why I vote you if you vote me?

Kekko, wanna wagon Ultra? His take on you kinda weak sauce.

They‘re probably bussing each other tbh.

i dont think dofla's the way but i wont do his defense for them

I mean, you wanted reasons and I gave them. I’m not trying to defend them as brilliant.

Basically where I’m at is: when I skimmed the first 9 pages or so (whenever I made my first post), I felt like I could trust Ultra the most. I felt Ekko and Aurelian were pretty townie too. Flower felt different but I literally stated a lil sus like it was a footnote for me and not a major player in my thoughts. I don’t know Nibel. I think at that point those players and Dofla were the major voices. I have no “man I think this is scum reads.” The only thing I’d bet on right now is Ultra, Ekko, Aurelian being town in that order.

Don't see how anyone got "yep, town" from this, as I'm sure at least one person did. It's helpful but noncommittal.


The answer was "You're not curious?" which doesn't feel like much of an answer. You had 10 minutes between Ultra quoting you and voting you, and you're acting like he was unreasonable.


"Hasn't interacted with anyone besides me"... off 3 posts, one of which was a vote, and one of which was a quote of Flower (not you).

More talk about Ultra, slight neg on Nibel which I won't give much thought because it's the natural way to think about Nibel in this game tbh. 100 post gap, then:



Both these posts may be stating the obvious but they're more productive than before the gap

Actually come to think of it Dofla's really doing a lot of stating the obvious in this readback, just got to the posts about Lethal not making sense

Helpful but weirdly low-judgement

Why did it take you so long to vote Nibel if the sus was there, is the question

Weirdly defensive of Ekko in Dofla's last few posts

Unvote
Vote Dofla

Too many odd things about this, would like to deal with them

vote lynch sky

very performative way to join a counter wagon. u magically sus dofla after a wagon on him is growing and whats worst it's being lead by a player u called obvious scum

on that note sky joined a wagon with you, who she called obvious scum, onto dofla

if dofla and sky both flip scum its shaping to be another stomp game

the CATALYST data would foken blow up

like chrismas came early

like this is my second game with GAD but it's clear a night and day difference from his last game where he struggled heavily with providing any meaningful content and here he actually seems to be hunting and reading multiple players(no offense gad).

anyone with experience with him should be able to evaluate him better. i dont think it's very hard unless youre just not reading his giant multi-quote posts.

this is the last thing you said after having him as null and i dont think i saw a real elaboration on either. definitely not on the slight town read.

the other read you had on him was a slight town read but only if sky flipped scum which is pretty meaningless as it's not a read on play.

Magic trending down, honestly.

Well no

It doesn't logically follow through that Flower reading Gad confidently as scum last game means that she'd be able to confidently read him as town if he is. You're basically saying her being uncertain is implicative, which is a big stretch.

Fwiw I think Gad is posting a lot of gibberish and you're overstating the polarity of his play a bit. I can see the gears turning a bit more from him but also he is drunk and 80% of his observations are not able to be grasped by the sober mind.

Unvote
Vote Flower

We're so back

Let‘s finish Sky. If she flips scum Magic goes next.

Vote Magic.

Gram not calling out his lack of logic is not a good look either.

Ultra and Whicker and perhaps Lethal

Vote Lynch Sky.

Gonna give my at-a-glance thoughts on a few low posters

Whicker's been sheepy and low content but his votes have been in the right place

My previous thoughts on Retro stand

T-Pein I cannot be fucked making sense of for obvious reasons, but here's something. He made one decent post here and then immediately went back on it by sussing in a direction he called "ez"

Lethal hasn't read

Gad I'd have to deep dive on

Nvm. Magic is probably Town. His posts remind me of Anon game overall.

Why is this Nibel wagon still a thing?

Unvote
Vote Dofla

Helping the "Dofla claim now" cause because it seems I'm literally alone on Flower now

Probably going to be off soon and after that and then sleep, I expect to be lynched by the time I'm back

Mainly because your response to ever being challenged feels unhelpful and untown

Basically the main highlights reel for me. I came away still not liking Nibel and his OMGUS pattern and not being constructive with his interactions with benefit of any serious pressure for over 24 hours. Looking at Magic and Ultra, both are pushing on Sky while Flower is sort of hovering around as they biet back into the whole Sky et Gad's entrance angle.

Anyway not surprised that Magic is starting to unfavorably look at Ekko due to more recent posts but the bigger issue I have is Sky moving onto Dofla despite both having Nibel in their POE and voting him; especially with the context of Flower and Ultra also both wanting and tying the two as scum/teamed. Sky has more or less had Ultra and Flower as her main scum reads and Nibel behind them while Gad was her last read as potential scum. Therefore the vote on Dofla feels pretty strange to me for someone to vote a player who shares strong perceptions with them:

- seeing Ultra as scummy
- looking at Nibel as a valid day 1 flip
- put in the crosshairs by Ultra and Flower and largely pressured by the same players mutually (Ultra, Magic, Ekko, etc)

If I'd be paranoid it's either townSky being opportunistic trying to save her own skin or scumSky taking whatever blatant escape route she can find.

As for Flower I'd say I would agree with Whicker that she's operating a little way outside of her normal wheelhouse but the attempts to get Gram's attention and involvement are within her town self play. I'm still not 100% sold she is vouch safe town but I'm okay with not voting her today. Didn't like her having a problem with Nibel's wagon though and the AtE reactions to Magic because he logically called out her weird claim of saying she can perfectly read Gad then walking it back, reversing her town read on him to the point of wanting to vote him, etc...

Whicker seems fine.
RDK is okay.
Still think Ultra is operating in bad faith regarding Sky vs Gad entrance thing.
Nibel can still go today as my main preference.
Want to see more from Dofla.
Ekko is soft town but it'd more a vibe feeling.
Flower is still a null but lightly leaning town, tentatively with her
No idea about Retro.
Gad had defense from Magic but his earlier silly posts seem deliberate in awareness of how polar opposite they were in the last game. I don't buy the idea it wasn't intentional but either way I don't think he is teamed with Sky or Ultra.
Magic I do like a bit more bit wary and paranoid about being pocketed by him if he's scum again like in the last game.
Need more from Lethal. Nuff said.
Sky is trending down for me with the Dofla vote.
Gram null.

 

[Aurelian]

Think T-Pein is town but the little tiff Sky had with him was unique. Then again I have been consistently horrendous historically speaking when trying to read him.

 

[Sharter Holmes]

Basically the main highlights reel for me. I came away still not liking Nibel and his OMGUS pattern and not being constructive with his interactions with benefit of any serious pressure for over 24 hours. Looking at Magic and Ultra, both are pushing on Sky while Flower is sort of hovering around as they biet back into the whole Sky et Gad's entrance angle.

Anyway not surprised that Magic is starting to unfavorably look at Ekko due to more recent posts but the bigger issue I have is Sky moving onto Dofla despite both having Nibel in their POE and voting him; especially with the context of Flower and Ultra also both wanting and tying the two as scum/teamed. Sky has more or less had Ultra and Flower as her main scum reads and Nibel behind them while Gad was her last read as potential scum. Therefore the vote on Dofla feels pretty strange to me for someone to vote a player who shares strong perceptions with them:

- seeing Ultra as scummy
- looking at Nibel as a valid day 1 flip
- put in the crosshairs by Ultra and Flower and largely pressured by the same players mutually (Ultra, Magic, Ekko, etc)

If I'd be paranoid it's either townSky being opportunistic trying to save her own skin or scumSky taking whatever blatant escape route she can find.

As for Flower I'd say I would agree with Whicker that she's operating a little way outside of her normal wheelhouse but the attempts to get Gram's attention and involvement are within her town self play. I'm still not 100% sold she is vouch safe town but I'm okay with not voting her today. Didn't like her having a problem with Nibel's wagon though and the AtE reactions to Magic because he logically called out her weird claim of saying she can perfectly read Gad then walking it back, reversing her town read on him to the point of wanting to vote him, etc...

Whicker seems fine.
RDK is okay.
Still think Ultra is operating in bad faith regarding Sky vs Gad entrance thing.
Nibel can still go today as my main preference.
Want to see more from Dofla.
Ekko is soft town but it'd more a vibe feeling.
Flower is still a null but lightly leaning town, tentatively with her
No idea about Retro.
Gad had defense from Magic but his earlier silly posts seem deliberate in awareness of how polar opposite they were in the last game. I don't buy the idea it wasn't intentional but either way I don't think he is teamed with Sky or Ultra.
Magic I do like a bit more bit wary and paranoid about being pocketed by him if he's scum again like in the last game.
Need more from Lethal. Nuff said.
Sky is trending down for me with the Dofla vote.
Gram null.

So I'm going to talk about very little here cause most people can talk for themselves but...

I'm with you that Ultra going after Sky was kinda silly. Sky made an off the hip statement about my first posts. Felt like Ultra was reading too much into it. What annoys me tho is that Sky has also made posts on the defensive that feel scummy. I still think it's a silly angle but now I can't completely dismiss it either

As for me, sorry to break it to you but that's how my first posts always are. Scum or town, early on in the fluff scene, it's just more normal for me to joke around and see what happens. There's nothing solid I can post. I'm curious what you mean I was the polar opposite in the last game, cause... I mean, my start was the same? Fluff and long posts that were all over the place?

 

[Magic]

Vote sky

Before bed

 

[hime]

Day 1 Vote Count #6 (Up to Post #1,065)​

Votes:
Flower -> Magic > Ultra > Sky > Magic > Sky
Nibel -> Nibel > Unvote > Sky
Ekkologix -> Magic > Gadministraitor > Sky
Gadministraitor -> Magic > Ekkologix
DoflaMihawk -> Gadministraitor > Ultra > Nibel
Magic -> Ekkologix > Flower > Sky > Unvote > Sky
Ultra -> DoflaMihawk > Sky > DoflaMihawk
Aurelian -> Ultra > Unvote > Nibel
Sky -> Flower > Unvote > Nibel > Unvote > DoflaMihawk > Unvote > Flower > Unvote > DoflaMihawk
Whicker -> DoflaMihawk > Flower > DoflaMihawk
Grammaton -> Sky > Unvote > DoflaMihawk
T-Pein™ -> Nibel > Sky

Count:
DoflaMihawk = 4 (Ultra, Grammaton, Whicker, Sky)
Nibel = 2 (Aurelian, DoflaMihawk)
Sky = 5 (Nibel, Ekkologix, Flower, T-Pein™, Magic)
Ekkologix = 1 (Gadministrator)

Vote counts may or may not display the true nature of the votes.
Please let me know if you feel I have made any mistake.
I will not count unbolded votes.

A little under 8.5 hours left to discuss the lynch.
8 votes required if hammering.

Day 1 ends in - Countdown

​

Spoiler: Tags

1. @Grammaton
2. @Flower
3. @Lethal
4. @Sky
5. @DoflaMihawk
6. @Magic
7. @RDK
8. @Gadministraitor
9. @Ekkologix
10. @Ultra
11. @T-Pein™
12. @Nibel
13. @Whicker
14. @Aurelian
15. @Dr. Watson

 

[Flower]

We should probably hammer Sky. The wagons are a bit close.

 

[Ultra]

We should probably hammer Sky. The wagons are a bit close.

Can we uh, talk about how Dofla no sold the claim? Nobody seems to give a fuck.

 

[Ultra]

I'm fine lynching Sky but why is everyone being so soft on him it's weird.

 

[Grammaton]

I think I’d rather lynch dofla

I don’t think sky is town either but yeah, she will be forthcoming whereas he clearly won’t

 

[Atsumori]

I'm fine lynching Sky but why is everyone being so soft on him it's weird.

Seems like both Dofla and Sky want my ass dead today. I prefer to have Sky today.

 

[Grammaton]

Seems like both Dofla and Sky want my ass dead today. I prefer to have Sky today.

Could you elaborate as to why?

 

[Flower]

Can we uh, talk about how Dofla no sold the claim? Nobody seems to give a fuck.

There‘s not enough rope for two.

But I can switch if needed.

 

[Flower]

Whatever we decide on, the wagon should be hammered or at least have 2-3 votes difference to the second biggest wagon.

 

[Ultra]

There‘s not enough rope for two.

But I can switch if needed.

Feels like there wasn't very much collective pressure to get him to claim which is annoying. I don't wanna blind yeet him but gotta tighten that up.

Also do you have a 3rd slot for scum penciled in? I don't.

 

[Flower]

Feels like there wasn't very much collective pressure to get him to claim which is annoying. I don't wanna blind yeet him but gotta tighten that up.

Also do you have a 3rd slot for scum penciled in? I don't.

How many scums are we dealing with? 3?

 

[Flower]

@DoflaMihawk come here and claim.

 

[Ultra]

How many scums are we dealing with? 3?

Would assume the split is something like 3-1-11

 

[Flower]

The issue I have is Dofla basically hinted PR while Sky claimed Vanilla. If we go by the risk aspect Sky is the safer option today.

 

[Ultra]

The issue I have is Dofla basically hinted PR while Sky claimed Vanilla. If we go by the risk aspect Sky is the safer option today.

See, saying this enables him to do absolutely nothing though, good luck getting anything out of him. Oh well, better have a good explanation tomorrow, if he isn't domed