• We're looking for artists. Direct message Dr. Watson for more info!

Game Ranked All of Us Are Dead Mafia

Status
Not open for further replies.
how is that a solid foundation for a read? there's no reason for you to not trust anyone, from your town pov, due to a false guilty?
I thought I was scum to you and you don‘t consider a Town Flower world, why do you suddenly care?
 
But my question...

Why did I move from strong town to nothing while there are still others in your town read while you don't trust anyone? It's its player reads, I don't think I've changed anything on my end. What's your town read doing to get that read? I'm just curious.
Because you‘re not as open minded. Watson is purely on claim while Fang and Ekko displayed doubts which just sound genuine.
 
Because you‘re not as open minded. Watson is purely on claim while Fang and Ekko displayed doubts which just sound genuine.
Oh, I'm very open-minded. It's just that, this isn't a good excuse or reason to not vote you. I mean, you never gave me something worth considering more than the mech. And on that note, I'm so confused as to what Fang or Ekko gave that sound decent? Genuine, sure, that just means they're bad, but what about their reads made you go "Hmm, these people have a point"?
 
Oh, I'm very open-minded. It's just that, this isn't a good excuse or reason to not vote you. I mean, you never gave me something worth considering more than the mech. And on that note, I'm so confused as to what Fang or Ekko gave that sound decent? Genuine, sure, that just means they're bad, but what about their reads made you go "Hmm, these people have a point"?
Did I, at any point, ask you to not vote me? I‘m perfectly fine with getting flipped here. It‘s better now while we can still afford mislynches than coating Town the game in lylo.
 
Oh, I'm very open-minded. It's just that, this isn't a good excuse or reason to not vote you. I mean, you never gave me something worth considering more than the mech. And on that note, I'm so confused as to what Fang or Ekko gave that sound decent? Genuine, sure, that just means they're bad, but what about their reads made you go "Hmm, these people have a point"?
So far comes off like you don't like me or Ekko for not reading you as town!
 
Did I, at any point, ask you to not vote me? I‘m perfectly fine with getting flipped here. It‘s better now while we can still afford mislynches than coating Town the game in lylo.
You didn't answer my question btw.
So far comes off like you don't like me or Ekko for not reading you as town!
No, I don't like Ekko for legitimate reasons I've provided. You, I just think you're reading me wrong again
 
And why I don‘t trust anyone is stuff like this:

I mean, it was already minutes after I asked and the longer you wait as scum the more sus you look.

Sure but if you kept ducking you would have looked really bad lol

Like you can say you didn't have to claim but if you continued avoiding to claim it would look awful on you
Literally same thoughts, but the guy still doesn‘t realize I‘m Town.
 
scum and town can have similar thoughts, especially if the thing in question is abundantly clear, which in this case ducking would be.
At the same time, too. Just cut it out. I would be fine if you named the result as the reason, but saying it‘s read based is just cap.
 
At the same time, too. Just cut it out. I would be fine if you named the result as the reason, but saying it‘s read based is just cap.

mindmelding is not a good reason to town read someone, to me, in particular if it's an obvious thought. "i would have delayed claiming more as scum" is obviously not a strategy that would work.


why would you care if im saying it's read based if you're town lol.
 
Ofc. Who else but good players would do that?

Idk Flower, but you usually have better defenses than this. You're talking a lot about people acknowledging the possibility where you were framed but, that's not an actual defense of yourself.

Yeah, cause no one was voting for Ultra at that point. This isn't a catch.

See best buddy? The funny thing is, you've been calling my reads shit since before... lemme double check here.. oh yeah. Since before I had reads. In fact, I don't think I ever went past general susses more than twice. This is a push. It makes no sense. Just like it makes no sense who and why you town cleared "most other players". If anything, you're setting up a whole "Get Gad lynched and then try to pass it off as his shit reads". But, it's kinda ass cause it feels fluffy at the same time. You're not contributing. You haven't really contributed to the whole Flower thing either afaik. Which reminds me, Flower's interactions with you last phase which I mentioned as sounding weird? Yeah, this scum read on her isn't looking good for you either. You're a whole bag of pushes and nothing else at this point. Yeah. Ekko and Flower can go.

Thank you Maple buddy

I'd like to know as well

You think a lot but there has been no process explaining the thinking lol

Why is you always reading me wrong bruh?

This is useless. I mean, it seems like you're contributing but she actually posted about it. And further more, if Retro was lying, I'd say someone would have counter claimed her. It's just... I don't get why you made this post.

This isn't looking good Flower

But what's your indication that I'm scum?

😂

I'm with you on the Nibel thing. After Flower and Ekko.

Why? Why aren't you going for the actual mech read?
lets take a step back here, when is the first time i called ur reads shit?
 
mindmelding is not a good reason to town read someone, to me, in particular if it's an obvious thought. "i would have delayed claiming more as scum" is obviously not a strategy that would work.


why would you care if im saying it's read based if you're town lol.
I‘m literally the first who called it out. And mindmelds are more often than not with Town.
 
Give your reads on all living players so far then:
- me
- Ekko
- Flower
- Gram
- Watson
- Magic
- Nibel
- Dofla
- RDK
- T-Pein
- Lethal
- Whicker
Fine! Make me put in effort why dontcha?

You, I think you're town. I don't see you shrugging off questions. That's my general read. You're coming off as open. Stubborn, but open. I also don't think your read on me makes any sense. You'd need a reason to think I'm scum, lack of reason that I'm not scum isn't a valid thought process here.

Ekko: Tldr, he claims to have explained his reads but he never has. Prove me wrong if I'm wrong. He "town cleared most people because flimsy reasoning is good" and that's it. He hasn't modified or changed his stance. Not D1. Not D2. Again, he's pushing but not putting his money where his mouth is

Flower: I'll explain at the end but for now, pure mech read. She's asking for people to consider a world where she's being framed but there's been no explanations or counter claims regarding Retro's cop claim. See no reason to not vote her.

Gram - Null. But I'd wager slight town.

Watson - Until someone counter claims, she's town cop. If Flower's town, she's gonna be on fire tomorrow

Magic - Null. And before you say I should know him better and have a better read cause he was mafia with me last game, he was inactive there too.

Nibel - Been adding to his post count but not to this game's content. I'm not sure he's scum but I wouldn't mind seeing him go.

lolDofla - Honestly, I see his reasonings. They're not the best plays according to some y'all but... I'm lazy and I can get behind his thought process. Just like my dupe to act like me.

RDK - What am I supposed to read here? Both games with him were kinda where he didn't post too much. He doesn't seem to be the one to put up a whole different persona just to be scum so slight town/null

T-Pein - Was on some interesting wagons but never posting yesterday. I'd have to ISO to recheck which wagon I'm talking about but I'm hella sick so if anyone can ISO me for where I mentioned him, that'd be great. 🙃. Anyways, scummy

Please don't tell me you're expecting me to give you something on Lethal and Whicker...
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top