For the record though, JIC I get quick hammered note for post game: Pretty much everything I have said has been what I actually thought, I haven't faked any posts to be towny so any wolf reads on me are genuinly just skill issues.
- Thread starter Lord Melkor
- Start date
@Ratchet
I don't think it's a stretch from Ultra. "I'm not sure Ratchet gives this much towns early" (Acceptable) "with no wolves" (Hence the TMI, I'm saying that you have no wolves in your reads) "as a wolf themselves"
Feels like a genuine observation as opposed to a wolf trying to frame what I'm doing, don't think it's really a stretch.
I don't quite find this answer satisfying, because I don't think your read on Luka is so firm to the point where you wouldn't consider a world where he's scum and CP could have swooped in and bussed there, or that it's impossible for CP to see an opportunity here
hime
Exceptional
- Pronouns
- She/Her
its simplistic thinking but sometimes the simplest answer is the right answer
i feel that here
But I think he's clearly spinning there, as written your post seems pretty clear to me. I actually don't like you defending it more than anything he's said about it because this should be something that you're all over. You gonna let him blatantly misrepresent you like that?
You're not seeing something that's fairly self evident?
His lack of consideration of a very obvious motive (you sneaking a scum buddy into townpile) means the read is fake
Doesn't have to imply all your town reads are clear, but it could
hime
Exceptional
- Pronouns
- She/Her
this is a very weirdly worded post and not something id expect town to make
I'm trying not to engage with the people wolf reading me as often, I tested it out in about 2 games (one town rand and one wolf rand) and it worked better for me than if I would have otherwise engaged with them I think. I also did explain myself in one of my posts if he's reading the thread, so if he see's that, and he should; and doesn't interact with it that suddenly becomes his issue and not mine.
I don't really care what you find satisfying lol, I don't townread you. While it's possible CP could have just gone for a bus, it would be somewhat out of character for him, and if he were to bus, he would probably start soft balling to lead Luka through the suspicion, like what he did with Watson. He he lays out his thoughts, in full, which I liked.
Not good.
I don't get this read? I see the TMI angle, but I don't see the angle you would make here based off of that post.
No because what he actually said was "I don't think Ratchet as scum reads a bunch of people town without making any scum reads". Nothing to do with sneaking a scum buddy in there, he's specifically talking about my approach and not the reads themselves. Which I think is fairly obvious?
This is his redacted position after I pointed out the flaw in his argument though, why are you assuming he intended for this to begin with?
hime
Exceptional
- Pronouns
- She/Her
town would never say that they dont think they r scum
they would know they r not scum
I mean, from any sensible persons perspective I can't see a world in which they think me and Dolfia are SvS. I would like to believe we are heavily unpaired at this point.
May I know what's stopping me from intending this from the get go?
Easy - historically he is later on buses, and he doesn't tend to open games by bussing because, by his own ethos, he prefers not to. And the times that he has tried to subvert this, he has been caught pretty easily through it. If I may point you back to my initial explanation, I think as scum he struggles with replicating a full thought process that's believable for him, which is both why I think him laying out his considerations like he did is good, and also why I would expect him as scum to play a bit more reactive than he has to this, that he may have time to see how the board plays out.
hime
Exceptional
- Pronouns
- She/Her
y cant he be town