• We're looking for artists. Direct message Dr. Watson for more info!

Game Ranked Dune Mafia - town victory

Status
Not open for further replies.
So, the thing with Sparkles is that I have not yet seen Poyser read her wrong. So his read has a lot of value to me. And I think, as town or scum, he has an obligation to read her right. So my position woukd be that for Sparkles to be scum here, Poyser's chances of being scum go up drastically. And I guess this is a problem I have with you, because you aren't really treating Poyser like you think he's likely scum. So I have to ask, you think he would be confidently wrong on Sparkles as town?

I still think a lot about Poyser feels inorganic this game, but I'm having a bit of trouble parsing if I'm just being biased or not. I don't think he's definitively town and I don't really wanna stake anything in his judgement this game.

If he's town I would say...probably not wrong?
 
I still think a lot about Poyser feels inorganic this game, but I'm having a bit of trouble parsing if I'm just being biased or not. I don't think he's definitively town and I don't really wanna stake anything in his judgement this game.

If he's town I would say...probably not wrong?
That doesn't really answer my premise though. If Poyser is Town and Sparkles is scum, he would have to be confidently misreading her slot. Now it's not impossible, but I would say it's unlikely that he would get it so wrong. So let's take that aside.

If he's scum, he knows he needs to read her correctly. In which case, great she's town. The only other alternative is that they're both scum, but I can't understand his progression at all from that point. This is why I don't feel the Sparkles direction much. Because I can't justify it from how he's played around her.
 
Fuji why on Earth as Town does Aurelian, the most stubborn mother fucker in the game, claim at the behest of someone he scum reads. How are you reconciling this?
You didnt ask me but i can tell you.

They got 6 votes on and Arne said he was ok with hammering this once and for all. This would create a sense of urgency to claim immediately.

I have Aurelian in my maybe scum pile, but again, with how fast his wagon grew over Alco which dissipated really fast, i think that Alco is a likely hit, cause if he was town, with the amount of times his name has been thrown around, there would be more votes on him
 
5. OLU
6. Arnie Slot
7. RDK
8. Sharter Holmes
12. Alco

Down to lynch any of those @Ratchet I literally forgot AM existed, hes coasting which is a bad sign lol.
OLU - yup no complaints from me.
Arne Slot - No issue with CP at all, currently have him lean town. Wouldn't lynch today.
RDK - meh. Probably wouldn't lynch today.
Sharter Holmes - Yup, I'm coming around to it. Would support this.
Alco - Would be more of me deferring than anything else, I don't have any strong feeling on him. I town read you and Guillo and you both want him dead, so I'm at least open to it.
 
And take his mislynch to the grave? Did that ever happen before?
No, he would need someone else to ask him, or several other people. He would be difficult and as obnoxious as possible. He would not just claim for me first time of asking. At the very minimum, he would make me ask several times.
 
OLU - yup no complaints from me.
Arne Slot - No issue with CP at all, currently have him lean town. Wouldn't lynch today.
At the time I made the list both Arne and Sharter made some posts that made me pause and reconsider a bit.
RDK - meh. Probably wouldn't lynch today.
Alright.
Sharter Holmes - Yup, I'm coming around to it. Would support this.
What do you think of his latest posts about me btw.
Alco - Would be more of me deferring than anything else, I don't have any strong feeling on him. I town read you and Guillo and you both want him dead, so I'm at least open to it.
Alco is my weakest scum read I just feel like the way he mentioned me and my past games tunnel of him being similar to this and then not voting me but just going for Sparkles who was a consensus lynch a bit weird, if he feels like its such a homerun he should pursue it from a town POV idk though what do you think?
 
That doesn't really answer my premise though. If Poyser is Town and Sparkles is scum, he would have to be confidently misreading her slot. Now it's not impossible, but I would say it's unlikely that he would get it so wrong. So let's take that aside.

If he's scum, he knows he needs to read her correctly. In which case, great she's town. The only other alternative is that they're both scum, but I can't understand his progression at all from that point. This is why I don't feel the Sparkles direction much. Because I can't justify it from how he's played around her.

The fact that Poyser was hard scum reading her up until a couple hours ago, and also scum reading me all along complicates this a bit from both angles.
 
Alco is my weakest scum read I just feel like the way he mentioned me and my past games tunnel of him being similar to this and then not voting me but just going for Sparkles who was a consensus lynch a bit weird, if he feels like its such a homerun he should pursue it from a town POV idk though what do you think?
I think the point you and Guillo have made are fine. I don't know how much of it really applies to Alco because he's never been the easiest read, but at the very least I think it justifies some pressure. His reaction to that would probably be more telling.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top