• We're looking for artists. Direct message Dr. Watson for more info!

Final Fantasy XIV Mafia - Game Thread

Status
Not open for further replies.
Reader mode
Magic said:
im working to cooperate as there's honestly nothing pointing to me being scum. i didnt want to cfd someone late in the phase. we worked on that aurelian wagon all phase, to not conclude it and let it fester and leave it for a down the line mislynch would not be optimal. you quit at the end of the phase. i finished the lynch as a result. psychic is saying i was town reading aurelian all phase when i literally didn't. i did strong town read raem and evans who both flipped town and i largely defended their play too. they would both be potential mislynch fodder. the play doesn't make sense as scum to hard town read them both for no reason that early on, but yet the scum motivation im being accused of is "well magic just faked and made up town reads because that's what he does as scum". not on all potential mislynch candidates off very little.

on top of that the majority of the game has suspected me, outside of nat for whatever reason. there is no teammate equity with me for most of the game. there's some shallow level thinking going on and it is what it is.

this phase ive tried working out where to go. i thought cp was a good direction. he's the cop. now im trying to figure out where he intends to go if im town but he seems completely clueless which has me a bit confused. was he always clueless? as he only decided to pursue me as scum once claiming cop giving him confidence to do.

does he think i pre-emptivly claimed roleblocker as a play of some sort? that limits the team's ability to use it in a beneficial manner for the team so no idea why i would do that nor why as scum id abstain from using the role. i wouldn't fake roleblocker as scum either as well that's stupid.

so tell me odo when i have this to work with what is the point of defending myself? there is a nothing case against me on basically having TMI because my town reads were right lol. i want to work with people on where to go in the case i flip town.

if i do flip town id suggest ignoring cp's info. in a case where there is no gf he'd be comfortable claiming cop. on top of that he only cleared someone already cleared(and based on his eod posts he was coming around to bpd being town). we're basically relying on the SK to cull some mafia for us if my lynch goes through so hopefully he does that.
Click to expand...
sense a bit of defeatist attitude but i dont hate this post
thoughts on this cp?
 
Magic said:
^as such.

im not trying to lynch you here, but i do want an explanation of how we got here.
Click to expand...
the way you went about the tweet claim and the fact you somehow never picked up on me being the cop felt like you wanted town to waste time on a bad direction and confirm my role
 
Magic said:
this is the hint, which is well before the vig stuff btw.
Click to expand...
it was more posts than that. BPD asked wasn't I scum reading him d1? I said yes but it's d2 now and not to worry about it. he asked me to clarify why I changed and I didn't give him answers. you definitely should've picked up on that. I don't do strong generous town reads with zero explanation as scum
 
Ekkologix said:
sense a bit of defeatist attitude but i dont hate this post
thoughts on this cp?
Click to expand...
how is defeatist when im continually playing.

my wagon is full of people that shift their votes with logic or reason outside of cp. im not going to convince psychic to move off of me she will just triple double im scum with scum motivations.

lethal just 180'd his read on me likely because i was strongly sussing him.

and honestly there isn't much of a case outside of that. youre sussing me for not using a negative utility role. okay what's the scum motivation to claim roleblocker ekko? why out a massively beneficial scum role that can limit town usage just to get a claim in early? now i cant claim scummy actions. it's a stupid argument.

cp voted me out of POE reasons that im not really following.

odo is sussing me for being right on town reads he doesn't understand.
 
CraigPelton said:
it was more posts than that. BPD asked wasn't I scum reading him d1? I said yes but it's d2 now and not to worry about it. he asked me to clarify why I changed and I didn't give him answers. you definitely should've picked up on that. I don't do strong generous town reads with zero explanation as scum
Click to expand...
cp in mhw i picked out who the cop was early day 2 with almost no hints by just POEing everyone else out of it.

if i was scum i have a reason to find the cop. as town im not looking for role hints. i can find you what im referencing if you want!
 
Magic said:
how is defeatist when im continually playing.

my wagon is full of people that shift their votes with logic or reason outside of cp. im not going to convince psychic to move off of me she will just triple double im scum with scum motivations.

lethal just 180'd his read on me likely because i was strongly sussing him.

and honestly there isn't much of a case outside of that. youre sussing me for not using a negative utility role. okay what's the scum motivation to claim roleblocker ekko? why out a massively beneficial scum role that can limit town usage just to get a claim in early? now i cant claim scummy actions. it's a stupid argument.

cp voted me out of POE reasons that im not really following.

odo is sussing me for being right on town reads he doesn't understand.
Click to expand...
scum motivation wud be to lynch tweet. we went over this

i can convince psychic to move

lethal/cp/BPD could be scum, none cares what they say

was there even a cop last game now that u mention it
 
CraigPelton said:
the way you went about the tweet claim and the fact you somehow never picked up on me being the cop felt like you wanted town to waste time on a bad direction and confirm my role
Click to expand...

how was the tweet claim scummy? i saw he blocked the person hinting at stump.

i am the roleblocker, meaning i assumed he'd be jailkeeper and that's a waste of a jailkeeper shot so i went after him. then he also claimed roleblocker.

just cause last game had 3 roleblockers, and again with specific theme related limitations, doesn't mean i assume that's just some common thing for ratchet.
 
Ekkologix said:
scum motivation wud be to lynch tweet. we went over this

i can convince psychic to move

lethal/cp/BPD could be scum, none cares what they say

was there even a cop last game now that u mention it
Click to expand...
bpd isn't scum due to multiple factors ekko, let it go.

he claimed vig.

he got blocked and outed the fact someone he tried shooting didnt die(town thought process).

then cp is also saying he copped him innocent.
 
Reader mode
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top