• We're looking for artists. Direct message Dr. Watson for more info!

Game Ranked Grand Theft Auto Mafia

Status
Not open for further replies.
Reader mode
Actually think Polar's reaction to having to claim is more towny from him.


@Polar Bear help me read Orca. Why is he voting rdk without scum reading him and telling others to. And why is he comparing afk aurelian from this game to their scum win which was probably aurelians best scum game I've seen
 
Polar Bear said:
I called t-pein scum last game when he claimed bp. In fact I had all but 1 in there, but that's not a discussion for the now

Do you think scum would claim bp 2 games in a row?

I have him red bc of the claim though bc its something that is easily claimed by scum
Click to expand...
I think gad is lazy and they didn't really think of a fake.

So I could see it but its the appeasement of claiming that I think is scummy. You basically told achro to fuck off when it comes to your claim. I'd expect the same from town gad with some whining as well instead of just appeasing the crowd
 
Polar Bear said:
Sell me. I dont want receipts. I want you to sell me on what you see that makes him scum. I have him as a scum lean so im not opposed to it, but i want a case
Click to expand...

Sure

- Very few thoughts about the game and positions on players on catch up. Has shockingly few reads/genuine thoughts for having read the entire thread in one shot

- His main and initial push Watson premised that she was faking her post restriction and she was off meta. He clearly oversold this as she's IC and is mod confirmed town

- Secondary lynch preference was Aurelian who he said was frozen wolf. I think it's bad he avoided voting here specifically because town CP would be on scum Aurelian like a bitch. Either he's hedging because he knows Aurelian is actually town for some reason or he's distancing with a mate

Ekko has a pretty good summary of why his entrance is bad too:

Emil said:
its terrible. where do we start

says im chatting shite but then finds a made up meta reason to drop a town read anyway. its too cucked

after his catchup his only major sus is watson, and she basically no sold him. he got no diffed.

didnt give a position on an active player but magic. asks questions about my read of magic that he shud clearly know if hes remotely read the thread or my posts to accuse me of talking shite

seems to be very happy with his "town read" of magic hes using it a crutch to combat others with. like why u guys susing magic.. none rly cares. not everyone is susing magic, its mostly just ultra and i, and ive been seeing him more townie for the most part

when ultra asks him if he had anything else after the catchup just throws a "hey ultra thoughts on ekko following up your push on magic" just to add to the list of useless posts that can be answered by reading the thread and serve no purpose in helping him read either of us

basically cp either never really caught up and is just shit posting, or is scum pretending to be so. there is an clear struggle to get his head into the game here
Click to expand...
 
Ultra said:
Sure

- Very few thoughts about the game and positions on players on catch up. Has shockingly few reads/genuine thoughts for having read the entire thread in one shot

- His main and initial push Watson premised that she was faking her post restriction and she was off meta. He clearly oversold this as she's IC and is mod confirmed town

- Secondary lynch preference was Aurelian who he said was frozen wolf. I think it's bad he avoided voting here specifically because town CP would be on scum Aurelian like a bitch. Either he's hedging because he knows Aurelian is actually town for some reason or he's distancing with a mate

Ekko has a pretty good summary of why his entrance is bad too:
Click to expand...
Now the rest of this is a better case than an entrance that is nai
 
Polar Bear said:
@Ultra

So in the very last game (tower of god or whatever)

Tempest has had the same exact entrance as those 3 games you provided and he was town. You are full it if you think that is a scum tell

Post in thread 'Tower of God Mafia Thread' https://onelastforum.com/threads/tower-of-god-mafia-thread.4929/post-420698
Click to expand...

It may appear that way but I can see the nuances in his play better than you can. I can see through his soul. If you think it's NAI then I wouldn't be so consistent no? You'd have to assume I'm just extremely lucky.
 
I don't think cp reads the whole thread and is known to skip people's posts, ekko would be one of them

Flower said she was treating Watson like an ic which is where that comment came from.

Idk this is seems like an ego thing that I don't think is really going to work out. I don't see cp as that scummy(or towny mind you)
 
Ultra said:
It may appear that way but I can see the nuances in his play better than you can. I can see through his soul. If you think it's NAI then I wouldn't be so consistent no? You'd have to assume I'm just extremely lucky.
Click to expand...
I'm not saying the read is wrong.

Its not based on his entrance is all im saying.

If its the same entrance as scum and as town then its nai and saying otherwise is a lie.

Now the rest of your case is what I'm looking for
 
Magic said:
I don't think cp reads the whole thread and is known to skip people's posts, ekko would be one of them

Flower said she was treating Watson like an ic which is where that comment came from.

Idk this is seems like an ego thing that I don't think is really going to work out. I don't see cp as that scummy(or towny mind you)
Click to expand...

This the best defense you can come up with
 
Polar Bear said:
I'm not saying the read is wrong.

Its not based on his entrance is all im saying.

If its the same entrance as scum and as town then its nai and saying otherwise is a lie.

Now the rest of your case is what I'm looking for
Click to expand...

Just fyi when I say "entrance" I don't mean first post - I'm extending that to basically all his posts from when he first started playing. Maybe that's what we're disagreeing about. Basically his whole play so far is his entrance
 
Reader mode
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top