• We're looking for artists. Direct message Dr. Watson for more info!

Game Ranked Hades Mafia - Game Thread

Sometimes? Kinda defended Dofla when they were co scumming. Dunno about like that
i was more wondering if he was pre-emptively shutting down tweet having a reason to push nibel for inconsistent thoughts, but at the same time the interjection was weird.

that said i dont think that's sufficient to really drop what i felt was avoidant play around ekko's wagon.

ALTHOUGH now that i think about it im not sure why ekko himself didn't go after dofla and instead chose to go after watson despite there being more interest in the dofla wagon. unless he didn't want to potentially ruin that wagon if he flipped scum.
 
Just reading on Nibel now.

This isn't the best read list at all, lots of word salad here and saying stuff and then drawing the opposite conclusion to my expectation

I particularly don't like him using Dofla wanting to spare Ekko as a reason to scum read Dofla when he doesn't have Ekko as a scum read. But also why doesn't he have Ekko has a scum read based on what he says about him lol
 

Who are your top 6 town reads
 
Sorry, which post are you talking about in particular?
your latest big multiquote. you said there's additional reasons alco looks bad than just what was said and then you quoted me and argued against alco looking good from the posts that i quoted.

which would all be fine if you thought alco and i were teamed and i was trying to buy him credit or points or if you expanded on that at all, but you just left him out of your top 5 most likely to be scum so i dont understand why you'd argue against his town credit at all. if you dont think he's likely to be scum and you think i am then it'd make sense if you thought i was pocketing him and then you wouldn't bother arguing against him getting town credit.
 
ALTHOUGH now that i think about it im not sure why ekko himself didn't go after dofla and instead chose to go after watson despite there being more interest in the dofla wagon. unless he didn't want to potentially ruin that wagon if he flipped scum.

Uh, Didn't you imply Watson was scum?
 
Right, this post would make sense if I had one scenario and one scenario only. I don't. I'm looking at individuals for now, and I don't think I've stitched together enough from my reads to sus two people being scum. I have some doubts but I'll mention them tomorrow if you're still interested.

Simple answer is, arguing against your read doesn't have to have anything to do with my read on Alco. I could read him as town and still find your post sus.
 
this is your multiquote

paragraphs 1, 2, and 4 are all against alco and essentially shading him. you did this and yet he's not in your top scum reads or secondary ones. why? what is the purpose. where are these thoughts leading to cause it's explicit shade but there's no follow up with suspicion.

paragraph 3 is ORCA voting LUKA. luka is not in your top 5 scum, but orca is in your top 3 and yet you want to follow one of your top 3 scum onto someone that isn't in your scum reads?

paragraph 5 was directed at me when i was giving town credit to alco. again you didn't have alco as scum and you had me as scum so like what the fuck. why bother arguing against alco here rather than trying to call me out for pocketing so it actually aligns with who you have as scum.

your posts don't correlate with your reads.
 
Who are your top 6 town reads
I can give you three and those are Tweet, Magic and Luka

I do think Poyser feels towny too.

I've liked Magic today and think he's on the right track with all of his reads / i agree with them all so that one has flipped for me.

Luka I've never played with before but play feels like town at ease in the thread and theyre clearly not really worried about holding anything back from playstyle and claim.

I was on the fence with Retro and did scum read her last phase but would probably lean town there too just due to poor longevity of claim if scum - seems unlikely. Also don't think she'd be cheap enough to use that AtE yesterday unless she's town - that's a bit of a nuance read tho
 
Uh, Didn't you imply Watson was scum?
yes.

i mean if they are teamed why would he go after a teammate that hard instead of going for dofla when dofla was also viable. unless he gave up early and just thought he was done for or it was a bussing plan and if it was a bussing plan then that means watson and him were distancing.

basically what was the purpose of him avoiding dofla and going for watson. if it was self pres then why not go for dofla as well as watson instead of watson alone? that gives more credibility to it being a buss as he basically avoided dofla from what i remember.
 
gonna leave my vote on Nibel here

I do have a funeral tomorrow and likely won't be around all day just as an FYI

vote: Nibel
 
i explained this in my following post, but in the rest of your post you were shading alco too.

if you have me as scum and him as town then youd think it was a pocket. i just dont understand the time investment in shading alco if you dont even have him as scum.

or wanting to vote luca with orca, the former you dont have as scum and the latter that you do.
 
Magic can you pull up the post where he calls Ekko scummy
i did, it wasn't in fact as outright shading as i initially thought:


it was more commentary and fence sitting than any read at all tbf, which i still dont find exactly great.

also was null on retro.

and part of his dofla scum read was sparing with ekko...who he had a weird feeling on, which doesn't really translate to something that's consistent.