• We're looking for artists. Direct message Dr. Watson for more info!

Game Ranked Hades Mafia - Game Thread

Reader mode
Magic said:
this is your multiquote

paragraphs 1, 2, and 4 are all against alco and essentially shading him. you did this and yet he's not in your top scum reads or secondary ones. why? what is the purpose. where are these thoughts leading to cause it's explicit shade but there's no follow up with suspicion.

paragraph 3 is ORCA voting LUKA. luka is not in your top 5 scum, but orca is in your top 3 and yet you want to follow one of your top 3 scum onto someone that isn't in your scum reads?

paragraph 5 was directed at me when i was giving town credit to alco. again you didn't have alco as scum and you had me as scum so like what the fuck. why bother arguing against alco here rather than trying to call me out for pocketing so it actually aligns with who you have as scum.

your posts don't correlate with your reads.
Click to expand...
I fail to see how these go against my reads. Calling Alco scummy is not the same as calling him the scummiest read I have. I pointed out something he did, not establish a position for him on my read list.

Paragraph 3 is me saying I'm down to get Orca, not Luka. Luka's one of my top town reads

Yeah, again, I find Alco scummy. I CAN see you guys be town, but it's just not a full on read, just a sus. Does that make sense or nah, maple buddy?
 
Magic said:
i did, it wasn't in fact as outright shading as i initially thought:



it was more commentary and fence sitting than any read at all tbf, which i still dont find exactly great.

also was null on retro.

and part of his dofla scum read was sparing with ekko...who he had a weird feeling on, which doesn't really translate to something that's consistent.
Click to expand...

Right you said he went from scum reading him to saying he was null

The post you just pulled up was obviously what you were referencing because he reads him null and you capped his progression there

So you lied
 
Dr. Watson said:
Yes but I'm trying to understand this from Luka's POV because I can rule out the other scenario(s)

The guy claimed VT so from Lu's POV:
-He thought it was a bluff
-He had felt Scumfla would target him due to him being consistently on his ass so he self-protected in order to survive during night

So I suppose he just thought wrongly
Click to expand...
I don't much care about what Luka is cooking tbh, they're all over the place with their role talk
 
Ultra said:
Right you said he went from scum reading him to saying he was null

The post you just pulled up was obviously what you were referencing because he reads him null and you capped his progression there

So you lied
Click to expand...

:biden

i pulled up that post immediately after what i said. it wasn't as bad as i thought but i didn't like his play around the slot regardless. trying to say i lied is a whack stretch.

Magic said:
this was 4 hours left until eod.

you also called him out as scummy earlier then left him as null despite explaining why you felt he was shady.
Click to expand...

Magic said:
^this.

also you had dofla as scum, not null.
Click to expand...
 
I think that's sloppy work from you Magic, you tried to paint a narrative that Nibel had done some sort of 180, don't see how you got that at all from his posts.

Yeah you can say they still don't hold up on your own, but you're now admitting to me your lead direction today was based off a very scuffed read. He also immediately recanted his Watson read after she claimed - you omitted this as well
 
Ultra said:
I think that's sloppy work from you Magic, you tried to paint a narrative that Nibel had done some sort of 180, don't see how you got that at all from his posts.

Yeah you can say they still don't hold up on your own, but you're now admitting to me your lead direction today was based off a very scuffed read. He also immediately recanted his Watson read after she claimed - you omitted this as well
Click to expand...
my recollection of his play around ekko was avoidance on the wagon and opting for dofla over him.

i looked up the posts after and while it still wasn't that it wasn't suddenly "well i feel much better about this guy cause he just said he had strange feelings instead of scummy".
 
RDK said:
I can give you three and those are Tweet, Magic and Luka

I do think Poyser feels towny too.

I've liked Magic today and think he's on the right track with all of his reads / i agree with them all so that one has flipped for me.

Luka I've never played with before but play feels like town at ease in the thread and theyre clearly not really worried about holding anything back from playstyle and claim.

I was on the fence with Retro and did scum read her last phase but would probably lean town there too just due to poor longevity of claim if scum - seems unlikely. Also don't think she'd be cheap enough to use that AtE yesterday unless she's town - that's a bit of a nuance read tho
Click to expand...

I almost fell asleep reading this post. Think it reeks of selective reading as well - he's missing some additions I think he would probably have at this point, and if they were omitted I expect him to have a spicier reason for it
 
Magic said:
my recollection of his play around ekko was avoidance on the wagon and opting for dofla over him.

i looked up the posts after and while it still wasn't that it wasn't suddenly "well i feel much better about this guy cause he just said he had strange feelings instead of scummy".
Click to expand...

Did Nibel avoid his partners wagons in the Baki game?
 
Ultra said:
I almost fell asleep reading this post. Think it reeks of selective reading as well - he's missing some additions I think he would probably have at this point, and if they were omitted I expect him to have a spicier reason for it
Click to expand...
Who specifically?
 
Ultra said:
Did Nibel avoid his partners wagons in the Baki game?
Click to expand...
as far as i remember i told nibel to buss me for credit.

after looking it up he avoided bachi and wanted to divert the wagon to sky and said as much in the scum qt.

he also voted frinckles after town reading frinkles and i told him not to vote frinkles to save bachi.

Nibel | 花城 said:
There are a lot people voting Ekko I think, maybe too much, who among these people do not have an other scum read?
Click to expand...
he also had this when i looked at his posts and just didn't include cause i didn't want to, which also wasn't great.
 
Ultra said:
I think that's sloppy work from you Magic, you tried to paint a narrative that Nibel had done some sort of 180, don't see how you got that at all from his posts.

Yeah you can say they still don't hold up on your own, but you're now admitting to me your lead direction today was based off a very scuffed read. He also immediately recanted his Watson read after she claimed - you omitted this as well
Click to expand...
His doffla read implied he thought ekko was scum tbf
 
And I know he outright said he was null but that's part of the problem. It didn't track in a way that made sense
 
RDK said:
Who specifically?
Click to expand...

Aurelian, Ratchet, myself

Think it's easier to reconcile you taking Magic's carpet ride here than him cowardly killing CP and then making such a blatant mistake in casing a suspect.

You can easily talk me out of it though since Nibel is kinda scummy but he's also a notorious deer in the headlights
 
Ultra said:
Aurelian, Ratchet, myself

Think it's easier to reconcile you taking Magic's carpet ride here than him cowardly killing CP and then making such a blatant mistake in casing a suspect.

You can easily talk me out of it though since Nibel is kinda scummy but he's also a notorious deer in the headlights
Click to expand...
m8 this isn't the gotcha you think it is, i provided the post directly after the accusation. it didn't say what i thought it said but it didn't really change my view on the play.
 
Reader mode
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top