• We're looking for artists. Direct message Dr. Watson for more info!

Game Ranked Hades Mafia - Game Thread

There's a handful of reasons, one which I already mentioned. Another part of it is, I almost never get shot even if the entire thread reads me town so who cares if my personal bodyguard dies. Who might be scum faking the entire role to begin with.

I'm calling cap anyway

I don't believe you hold Ekko and Retro in equal esteem as scum and favor going Retro

Literally doesn't make any sense. T-Pein unironically has a point
 
Admitting you didn't care who goes over but having consideration for claim always results in you defaulting to Ekko

The only reason you wouldn't is if you had another motive.
 
I'm calling cap anyway

I don't believe you hold Ekko and Retro in equal esteem as scum and favor going Retro

Literally doesn't make any sense. T-Pein unironically has a point
No he doesn't, I didn't "favor" Retro d1, I was fine with lynching both guys because their back and forth looked like a charade to me. I really only unvoted Ekko because I wanted Retros claim, and it happens that my vote stayed on her until EoD1. That isn't to say that I wanted to lynch her over Ekko.
 
u scum reading orca?
Less so after the night writeup. I also think as scum claiming results on me that support my claim doesn't really help his position. Going from Tweet's claim he should be confirmed if Tweet is town anyway. Not the direction I want to go today anyway.
 
@Ultra With all the claims on the table now, what's your preference?

I'm conscious of running the clock a bit here given the day length so I'd like us to start getting some sort of consensus going
 
No he doesn't, I didn't "favor" Retro d1, I was fine with lynching both guys because their back and forth looked like a charade to me. I really only unvoted Ekko because I wanted Retros claim, and it happens that my vote stayed on her until EoD1. That isn't to say that I wanted to lynch her over Ekko.

What do you mean in "happens" your vote stayed?

That makes it sound completely incidental. When actually you concluded you'd be fine with either after her claim too, and then stayed on her.
 
@Ultra With all the claims on the table now, what's your preference?

I'm conscious of running the clock a bit here given the day length so I'd like us to start getting some sort of consensus going

Haven't quite made my mind up yet but I do think RDK/Evans are good shouts. Kind of rethinking tweet here too because his early play around Ekko is in hindsight not really that gr8.

Between claimed and flipped roles I think there's slightly more vanillas than I'm used to from Gram games which is makes me think at least one is scum
 
What do you mean in "happens" your vote stayed?

That makes it sound completely incidental. When actually you concluded you'd be fine with either after her claim too, and then stayed on her.
Gotta be honest, I don't remember what I said or did d1 anymore to make my vote remain on Retro, if I had to guess then I didn't much care who of the two my vote was on at the end since I thought both were scum. And again the claim did zilch for me, even if it does namedrop my character.
 
vote lynch T-Pein

I think I've had just about enough of these WOAT reasons to vote people, on top of accusing people of things that oughta make them lock scum in his mind but him still voting completely different places
 
Something about Magic being favoured by Hermes and Hermes dying for Zeus kinda weird.

In constructing a dynamic surrounding roles that "favor" another you would figure Hermes in this case would be "favoring" Zeus if what Retro is saying was true, but it's actually Magic.

Something here stinks but not sure where the source is
 
Haven't quite made my mind up yet but I do think RDK/Evans are good shouts. Kind of rethinking tweet here too because his early play around Ekko is in hindsight not really that gr8.

Between claimed and flipped roles I think there's slightly more vanillas than I'm used to from Gram games which is makes me think at least one is scum
I'd favour flipping RDK over Evans but that's largely because I want Evans to have a chance to play. RDK has had that and hasn't really done much to get himself out of it.

I'm a bit surprised about the Zeus claim. From previous Gram games he typically gives more flavour characters than scum members, so even if it was Xadlin all along I would expect it to go unclaimed to get Retro flipped as a "layup" while scum claim one of the extras. Not really sure what to make of it - possible that they don't have that many to claim from unlike usual and so the janitor would be heavily required. Which then makes the decision not to use it Night 1 a bit perplexing.

I want to give CP's legacy a re-read - they *really* wanted him dead. From my recollection of it, that looks bad for Watson because I think he was the first to link Watson/Ekko.

Also with Tweet's claim I think Orca can be removed from PoE. Again Xadlin could be an observational role or whatever that wasn't claimed, the action block thing could not come from Mafia etc, but it's be weird to specifically block that type of action if town no longer have one.
 
Something about Magic being favoured by Hermes and Hermes dying for Zeus kinda weird.

In constructing a dynamic surrounding roles that "favor" another you would figure Hermes in this case would be "favoring" Zeus if what Retro is saying was true, but it's actually Magic.

Something here stinks but not sure where the source is
From flavour the God is what favours the champion - Zeus in this context would be the one giving a favour, not the one receiving one.
 
From flavour the God is what favours the champion - Zeus in this context would be the one giving a favour, not the one receiving one.
Actually I'm wrong on this - just checked the wiki and Achilles can bestow favour too. There does seem to be some difference but I haven't dived deep enough into the wiki for it.
 
Back
Top