• We're looking for artists. Direct message Dr. Watson for more info!

Game Ranked I Think You Should Leave - A Mafia Game by Sky

Status
Not open for further replies.
Reader mode
Dr. Watson said:
Flower you should have done a thought experiment and just rolled with the punches to see how many of us would tinfoil on you being vig, that would've been hella funny

But atleast I can analyze people being invested and comfortable trying to find the vig and it rules you out (maybe?) as a potential night target I suppose
Click to expand...
I don't want the Vig outing themselves. If I just roll with it they could think I'm scum pretending and CC.
 
Gadministraitor said:
Elaborate. I don't like that you're just kinda using a dead player's post as a spring board to bring nothing to the table.

You got reads on them? I town read at least two of them, and I don't know who Haza is. What are your thoughts on frinkles rn? I feel like you're tunneling Nibel (whose read I agree with you on) and Ultra heavily. I want to see other reads from you.

This reminded me why Ultra is town read for me. CP basically cleared him. I guess the CP lynch should clear boobies.

Now onto what I don't like about this post. Polar being all over the place is not scummy because it's different from another game? Maybe it's just me but that lack of care seems less town and more scum to me, regardless of how he played in any other game. I'm failing to see why anyone would clear him or his killer dolphin sibling.

Don't forget Lethal and Cubey

How is this a slip?

Go read up on CP's reads at least and get back to us on his reads. C'mon mate, it won't take long, I promise.

He's slippery. I feel like everytime he has some pressure on him, he disappears and then appears when there's a slight push on someone else to jump that wagon, or subtly add to that push. If this were anyone else but Nipples, that's obvscum move.

With nipples, I still read it as scum but idk man. I can't read him.

Sorry but this is a stretch. You should read other people before you head back to the nipple train, and I'm with you on that train. But I feel like you're ignoring a lot to focus on him.

Unsure, developing as I read but aside from Ultra moving to town on my reads, owing to his CP interactions, I'm still not sure. Hime's entering scumzone too

Also, I'm eating and I made this beautiful garlic and turmeric rice. Wanna try?

Who's buying into Hime's call to emotion? What's your read on Nipples?

You've been in a scum team and you know we've made plenty of mistakes together. I don't buy your post here. It's not like scum filters every post they make.

I'm assuming you mean the vitiligo panda and his sibling here?

What even is this? What are you trying to communicate here?

Nipple's play hasn't changed at all since the beginning. He's just as confusing now as he was before. What exactly did you like about him at the beginning? Several players even agreed that everything about him was super scummy there. I don't like this point here. It feels like you're trying to add more nuance to your reads than you actually have.

That being said, I'm now kinda unsure about Hime. Part of that is definitely how many people have changed their mind on her, but mostly cause I feel like the tunneling is because she cannot genuinely bring up reads on other people and that's really concerning. So that point, I see it gelling with my thought process.

Also, can you tell me why you think Flower's shift on Hime is that crazy?

Quoting cause it's last post I read. Gonna use you as a bookmark comrade, hope you don't mind.
Click to expand...
I do mind, please don't do that lol I like my notifications to be stuff that actually need me attention
 
Flower said:
I don't want the Vig outing themselves. If I just roll with it they could think I'm scum pretending and CC.
Click to expand...
I don't want them to out themselves either

Depending on who is vig they might have picked up on not being a good idea CCing in general but maybe my expectations and hopes are too high to avoid giving scum tactical advantage
 
Chuck said:
with how late D1 looked like, you could think you'll be lynched this DP

why abstaining? even if there's little chance of getting scum to kill themself, why not take it?
Click to expand...
combo of lack of confidence, didnt wanna mess things up (results), was only 2x, etc.
 
Gadministraitor said:
Nipple's play hasn't changed at all since the beginning. He's just as confusing now as he was before. What exactly did you like about him at the beginning? Several players even agreed that everything about him was super scummy there. I don't like this point here. It feels like you're trying to add more nuance to your reads than you actually have.

That being said, I'm now kinda unsure about Hime. Part of that is definitely how many people have changed their mind on her, but mostly cause I feel like the tunneling is because she cannot genuinely bring up reads on other people and that's really concerning. So that point, I see it gelling with my thought process.

Also, can you tell me why you think Flower's shift on Hime is that crazy?
Click to expand...
I went back and i think I mixed up his and hime's early posts. But nvm. I had him as town ever since i saw that 2vp, which is NAI, i know, but i simply assumed that's town and kept it like this.

Welp, Flower was defending her when she's pushed by Ultra and sounded as if hime was one of her strongest town reads. Then after a while I see Flower saying she wants hime lynched, followed by vote. Then when i asked she said she looked up hime's past scum games and she thinks there're similarities. So yeah, it's pretty unexpected change for me. That being said i had Flower as town. Looking at Watsons/Ultras reaction, i should be able to figure out her role too, so like, I'm not holding it against her or anything. I was just surprised
 
2x vote is unironically valid, you do kind of have to think outside the box when you have limited shots and determine whether the best course of action is to abstain or yolo it

The latter applies more to players who would be automatic night targets, otherwise it's kind of difficult and anxiety inducing trying to make sure the shots aren't misused or used on a poor read that gives less info
 
Reader mode
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top