• We're looking for artists. Direct message Dr. Watson for more info!

Game Ranked OLF Christmas Mafia 2023 (Day 9)

What examples? When did you ever buddy so much with people as Town. You even said you agreed partly with Poyser, so what is he to you? Why are you not trying to make sense of Ultra vs Poyser this very moment? And no, you talking to me is not an excuse. You can focus on multiple things at once, you have that skill. You again, don't wanna pick sides and stay out of it.
You're not reading - your initial point, which you've tried to bait and switch out of, was that I usually disagree with Ultra, and that me agreeing with Ultra is scum indicative. I've given several recent town games where we've either both been town, or both pro-town, and done exactly that.

Now I don't care so much about the accuracy of the trend, I know it's not accurate, but I do care about how you got there. Because for this to be a legit thought process, you would have had to consider what I'm bringing up and had reason to dismiss it. You haven't provided a satisfactory one. Instead, you've postured and blustered, it's not going to fly Flower.

I will just add this - if this is out of spite for last game I strongly suggest you grow up and play sincerely, you're definitely coming into this with an agenda, I can't quite tell if it's a scum driven one or a spite driven one.
 
Says this mofo who just lynched TOWN AURELIAN

4ce.gif
whats that got to do with the price of fish?
 
You're not reading - your initial point, which you've tried to bait and switch out of, was that I usually disagree with Ultra, and that me agreeing with Ultra is scum indicative. I've given several recent town games where we've either both been town, or both pro-town, and done exactly that.

Now I don't care so much about the accuracy of the trend, I know it's not accurate, but I do care about how you got there. Because for this to be a legit thought process, you would have had to consider what I'm bringing up and had reason to dismiss it. You haven't provided a satisfactory one. Instead, you've postured and blustered, it's not going to fly Flower.

I will just add this - if this is out of spite for last game I strongly suggest you grow up and play sincerely, you're definitely coming into this with an agenda, I can't quite tell if it's a scum driven one or a spite driven one.
Imagine calling it spite when I read the first 50 pages and just didn't find anything in your play to Town read you for. Then saw CP's case and it made sense.

What have you done which should make anyone Town read you?
 
Imagine calling it spite when I read the first 50 pages and just didn't find anything in your play to Town read you for. Then saw CP's case and it made sense.

What have you done which should make anyone Town read you?
would you mind quoting that CP case real quick? I think I know which post you're talking about just would save the trouble of finding it again
 
flowers aggression looks forced

ratchet actually looks townier this game as someone whose been scum the past 2 games with him he never gets into long arguments day 1 and just cruises it until mid game

u can maybe make a case for his EoD being weak but his early day 1 was fine imo
 
flowers aggression looks forced

ratchet actually looks townier this game as someone whose been scum the past 2 games with him he never gets into long arguments day 1 and just cruises it until mid game

u can maybe make a case for his EoD being weak but his early day 1 was fine imo

Wtf based Ekko post?
 
Imagine calling it spite when I read the first 50 pages and just didn't find anything in your play to Town read you for. Then saw CP's case and it made sense.

What have you done which should make anyone Town read you?
But you didn't cite CP's position, originally you came up with an entirely unrelated reason and used that to justify your vote. See, I'm not going to let you do this - you're trying to wiggle out of defending your position by deflecting to things that are harder for me to defend myself against.

I'm not saying you need to town read me, nor am I saying that scum reading me is implicitly scummy. I'm asking you, specifically, about what you brought up - stick to the point. I will ask o Ce more - where is this coming from, and what are you using to dismiss the parts that go against your supposed theory.
 
Flower doesn't look very town is my honest impression surprisingly. I think she only looks town in relation to her aggression towards Ratchet. Something about that combination of factors makes me smell Kabuki theatre, Flower isn't a risk taker and always always goes for low hanging fruit first. Don't buy her explanation that she's had a coming to God moment.
 
As far as the whole "there has to be a T1 on scum team though", this implies you've done some process of elimination @Caldust, can you explain your considerations there
I’ve no experience with the bloke who got killed, but as far as I know he isn’t considered among the top echelon of players. Absent of a bodyguard or watcher; which may be on the same player, may not be used, may be a scum role etc, scum have free rein to kill who they want. Why would they kill a weaker player when they could kill a stronger one?

Ratchet staying alive as the lone top player for multiple phases was something people were ridiculed for. People are thus highly alert for the better regarded players staying alive in the later phases. As such, a scum with a top player would be more reluctant to kill the other top players early when they could perhaps be in the same position with “why are you alive spec?; this isn’t a nail in the coffin for Odo in particular as it’d be silly to just lynch or push the top players for this. I’m just strongly leaning towards a top player on the scum team and he would also fit that bill too.
 
luka likely scum playing the too scummy to be scum card and poyser falling right for it or is a teammate. sad!
 
  • You smart
Reactions: Ral
Back
Top