• We're looking for artists. Direct message Dr. Watson for more info!

Game Ranked OLF Members Mafia

Status
Not open for further replies.
The first serious piles of votes:
Let's take a look on them.
Nibel - kinda reasonable because outside of the fluff his plays were kinda meh for now
Lord Melkor - I can totally see where this one is comming from, very unhinged entrance lol

Less serious piles:
Gramm - not versed in his meta, but I agree that if he were scum he would openly be running into some knives here with his play on Sky
Flower - had meh votes on her, mostly fluff votes, so was never a serious pile to begin with, but she played well enough with votes on here

all other piles were not of interest for me
Melkor is an interesting fella right now, not really fond of how he entered this game. Usually he also tends to have me in his early reads, but iirc we townstomped him in the Halloween game, he got shredded away by us.
 
I mean so far the only ones who've found it weird so far are me (and I have the weight of non-game-related history influencing that) and Melkor (who doesn't know him that well)
Yeah, but you agree that Melkor could be scum, no? Do you see him and Gram as partnered?
 
I also think that him taking a swing at Gram for his reasons stated is overall a pretty normal move from Melkor though
It's still a bizarre follow through to me even by LM standards. I think he's probably just lost in the confusion but most games he generally doesn't go at your neck out the gates at you.
 
What does he gain from that, tho? People who know him would just find it weird he's defending Sky of all people. It just draws unnecessary attention towards him and denies him a Sky mislynch which would not be hard for him to accomplish and not even make him look bad.

I actually do this as scum sometimes though.

Besides it is not like you are bound entire game by your early town reads.
 
The first serious piles of votes:
Let's take a look on them.
Nibel - kinda reasonable because outside of the fluff his plays were kinda meh for now
Lord Melkor - I can totally see where this one is comming from, very unhinged entrance lol

Less serious piles:
Gramm - not versed in his meta, but I agree that if he were scum he would openly be running into some knives here with his play on Sky
Flower - had meh votes on her, mostly fluff votes, so was never a serious pile to begin with, but she played well enough with votes on here

all other piles were not of interest for me
Melkor is an interesting fella right now, not really fond of how he entered this game. Usually he also tends to have me in his early reads, but iirc we townstomped him in the Halloween game, he got shredded away by us.
Y no read on me. I like the second most active poster in the thread after Flower.
 
And it's always hard to explain a change in reads which is also believable, Melkor. Scum profit more from staying consistently on a specific read.
 
Yeah, but you agree that Melkor could be scum, no? Do you see him and Gram as partnered?
If they were partnered Melkor would surely have come out with an actual reason to read him scum rather than making stuff up
 
I just hope this is not another DN scenario. But fine I drop it for now. Do you have a read list so far?
Town read on you, Sky (weaker, Ultra had a good point but it's more logical than it is necessarily scum indicative), I'd probably throw Fang in there too at a push.

Null lean scum on Rej. Don't want to elaborate more there for now.

Lean scum on Retro, as I said liked a couple of their posts so they're trending upwards. Still think their opening was awkward as hell.

No read on anyone else. Agree that Melkor's entrance is pretty terrible but I want to see what he does from here first before making my mind up there. Retro's post there felt a lot like last game with what she did with Ekko - her reasoning for suspecting him isn't actually a reason to suspect him.

The rest are small leanings that I don't want to put down yet.

Kweh
 
I've been in multiple distances in my time, and the thing that defines them is scum coordinating a little to make the distance look competent. That's not showing in Melkor's posts
 
In all seriousness tho, why would you bring non game related history into anything when I’ve given you absolutely nothing other than a completely clean slate lol
Because I'm a cynical bitch who bears grudges and tends to assume everyone else does the same

That's kinda it really
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top