• We're looking for artists. Direct message Dr. Watson for more info!

Ranked One Piece Thriller Bark Mafia

Reader mode
Magic said:
there is absolutely no reason for me to state this prior to him reacting. get over whatever has you all bent out of shape, this isn't productive.

And no I don't think you'd listen to any case or proposal I gave as I can't recall the last time you did. that is what it is, but you're hardly someone that has been easy to convince of shit. i even went through your case on him and told you why i disagreed with your points but alas that isn't enough!
Click to expand...

Bro I’ve listened to cases by ekko and tpein, you saying they’re more persuasive than you?
 
Rugrat said:
How calculated/pragmatic is TPein of a player as scum in terms of how he looks in the thread, Annie Wan?
Click to expand...

Magic said:

Final Fantasy XIV Mafia - Game Thread

Final Fantasy XIV Mafia Rules/Format -The game is Majority Lynch. That means 50% of votes are required to achieve a lynch, rounded up. Failing to reach majority by deadline will result in No Lynch. -Players may freely claim role and flavour. However, ensure to paraphrase the text itself -...
onelastforum.com onelastforum.com

town read you while you pushed raem and nat while agreeing their play wasn't "town-esque" and did other things. although to be fair i felt more certain raem was town in that game whereas with nat it was more of a vibe hunch.

i think gad could be scum in a similar fashion as to why i think polar could be scum. i dont really want to vote there, day 1, in a world they may just be town and playing in a way i think is good because if they are town then that seems like a good way to make them not play that way going forward. it's basically punishing them for playing in a way i feel is towny but scummy only to them as i expect more off the wall shit from them.

@Polar Bear speaking of which, what are your thoughts on orca?
Click to expand...

Magic said:
you responded to his post above by questioning him by stating it was you that stated it and (im presuming) since it was you he shouldn't trust that to be true since he doesn't trust you, except

he said this below(which was before you even questioned him above) stating that he doesn't think that's something someone would lie about because it can easily be disproven.

unless im wrong in any of this, this again just looks like tunneling.
Click to expand...

Magic said:
the lack of vote is a good question as he was sussing you and didn't vote anywhere else but then we'd have to see if this vote pattern is consistent with what he does as scum(and doesn't do it as town), which im sure you'll say youre too lazy to do.


why did you vote tpein over fuji here if you feel both were scummy?


why
Click to expand...

Magic said:
It isn't about if came under fire early. It depends on if he's had a scum read early and decided to actually vote it or not vote it like he's done here.

I've changed nothing. I'm addressing your suspicions/back and forth as requested.
Click to expand...

Magic said:
1. T-Pein™
2. Great Potato
3. Chairman Nibel
4. Gadministraitor
5. Flower
6. Polar Bear
7. Tempest
8. RDK
9. The Orca
10. Fujishiro
11. Aurelian
12. Luka
13. Grammaton
14. yohoho1996
15. HeWhoHasNoEqual
16. Rugrat
18. Hans Tweetenberg
19. Xadlin
20. Dr. Watson

nibel i kind of like too, but i dont really buy what he said about being tired of being indy and happy to be town again. the last few times he was town here he said he was sad he wasn't scum as that's what he really wants and he seems to be putting in a lot of effort right now(he also put in a lot of effort in that game he vigged me on day 1 before trailing off day 2 so it's hardly a slam dunk or the most scummy thing in the world but i dont really buy he would be happy to be town opposed to unhappy he's still not scum).

luka i vibed as town but idk how/why his scum reads on tpein/gram just disappeared after pairing them and look forward to hearing that interaction.

orca i dont think is overly sus thus far but he's also not agitated anyone yet and i think he's done that in every single one of his town games(whereas polar, as pointed out by fuji, hasn't). he seems very calm and straight forward. he does have cp as scum which i think cp has largely just ignored for whatever reason.

great potato/tweet might be generous town reads, but i haven't seen much scummy from them yet either and the case potato made looked like a town case.
Click to expand...

Magic’s entire progression on gad (he light tiwn reads him in the read list above)

Sorry I’m not seeing anything really approaching a reasoned endorsement for him being town, if I’m being generous, you at best give him an alibi for trusting some of my commentary despite distrusting me

Where’s the big town read and defence that you’re miffed nobody listened to, Magic???
 
Reader mode
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top