• We're looking for artists. Direct message Dr. Watson for more info!

Game Role Madness Supernatural Mafia

Reader mode
Pqwerty said:
also we seem to be assuming there's 3 active protection roles just fine. why do ppl not question town having a vig and 3 protective roles after one just flipped town?

my protection is passive and i assume it exists to stop vig from ending the game if they misfire.
Click to expand...
We have four protection roles.
 
Dr_Professor83 said:
I think you’re scum floundering right now instead of genuinely trying to solve.

All of your solving right now is defensive/omgus adjacent more than looking like you’re actually trying to take an open mind to approach the whole game and try to sort things out.
Click to expand...
Which is a completely different tone and vibe from pqwerty from the last two games.
 
The X said:
Which is a completely different tone and vibe from pqwerty from the last two games.
Click to expand...
I have a feeling town PQ would be handling this with a “wait wtf uh how does this all make sense” and then consider a ton of options while also considering why those options always may not make sense.

Here’s he’s starting with conclusions and then instead coming up reasons for why the stuff he usually questions is not a hold up.

It’s a completely reverse process. Last few games PQ was more of a lawyer/devils advocate wifom machine
 
I also hate that pqwerty is advocating for both Alexis and Ali to be left alone today. He still hasn't answered the question that if both are town, why did wolf let them get both their shots off D1? And if that's the case, why on earth would they allow both to get their shots off AGAIN with a smaller POE.
 
Dr_Professor83 said:
From my PoV one of you/X/Reloaded are scum.

You keep trying to separate from the protective roles bc it isn’t active but yours is stronger than Watson’s or mine due to being presumably infinite even if it’s passive.

I think you look way more like scum than X.

If you flip town I’ll be stuck with the task of figuring out if we really did have this much protection and it’s countered by scum with extra KP. I really don’t think X is scum rn though and I think it’s just going to be you. (I also don’t really love the idea of 4 town protects + scum extra KP Reloaded lol)
-

Sigi hasn’t claimed to be roleless, just that he hasn’t do anything so far. I’ve considered him being ninja but I think if he was that scum could kill someone other than Watson.

Why do you think Ali is town?
Click to expand...
i dont think Ali is 100% town here but i'm worried that bc of how good tracker is for town that if we mess up and kill town tracker then we'll be mechanically down a good role. hence why i suggested we let Ali get their 2nd shot off and then vote them out once they're out of uses if u don't like their results
 
Dr_Professor83 said:
I have a feeling town PQ would be handling this with a “wait wtf uh how does this all make sense” and then consider a ton of options while also considering why those options always may not make sense.

Here’s he’s starting with conclusions and then instead coming up reasons for why the stuff he usually questions is not a hold up.

It’s a completely reverse process. Last few games PQ was more of a lawyer/devils advocate wifom machine
Click to expand...
Yeah he also felt like a conspiracy theorist in those games. Like I said before, it feels more like he's subbed into a wolf slot and trying to do damage control rather than try to solve the game. I blame him zero for this, though. Rough position to be put into.
 
The X said:
I also hate that pqwerty is advocating for both Alexis and Ali to be left alone today. He still hasn't answered the question that if both are town, why did wolf let them get both their shots off D1? And if that's the case, why on earth would they allow both to get their shots off AGAIN with a smaller POE.
Click to expand...
He’s currently arguing for Sigi to be ninja or scum is in such a great spot that watcher/trackers hold no threat to them from what I understand.

But I don’t like either of those arguments when the liker conclusion is to at least strongly consider one is scum lol. (You can float the other theories out too as alternates sure but avoiding the most probably scenario is pretty wack)
 
The X said:
Yeah he also felt like a conspiracy theorist in those games. Like I said before, it feels more like he's subbed into a wolf slot and trying to do damage control rather than try to solve the game. I blame him zero for this, though. Rough position to be put into.
Click to expand...
The main way to sum it up is I think town PQ is very unsure of himself and will have second thoughts any time something remotely comes up to give him some, but here it’s not happening.
 
The X said:
I also hate that pqwerty is advocating for both Alexis and Ali to be left alone today. He still hasn't answered the question that if both are town, why did wolf let them get both their shots off D1? And if that's the case, why on earth would they allow both to get their shots off AGAIN with a smaller POE.
Click to expand...
ninjas man. or maybe they don't have a way to stop them idk

i just don't think this game is so cut and dry
 
I also think my limiting his main sus/arguments to me & you here (and Sigi to a lesser extent) he does well to avoid too much spew while trying to look like he’s solving.

Bc if he does go over me/you are never aligned with him anyway lol
 
Dr_Professor83 said:
There’s usually a ton of arguing for why he/town may be wrong and not for why he’s right
Click to expand...
well normally i dont sub into a role where i have to defend myself immediately

but anyway

let's say im 100% wrong here and that there's no scum between you and X and there's scum between Ali and Alexis.

Then town has 3 protective roles, a BP, 2 investigators, and scum has what, an NK? Like you're saying that scum killed to avoid being watched, so this seems to imply they don't have a good means to escape a watch. So like what scum team roles make your scenario balanced?
 
Pqwerty said:
well normally i dont sub into a role where i have to defend myself immediately

but anyway

let's say im 100% wrong here and that there's no scum between you and X and there's scum between Ali and Alexis.

Then town has 3 protective roles, a BP, 2 investigators, and scum has what, an NK? Like you're saying that scum killed to avoid being watched, so this seems to imply they don't have a good means to escape a watch. So like what scum team roles make your scenario balanced?
Click to expand...
oh and not to mention you believe Reloaded randomly claimed vig D1 when he can't even shoot til later on
 
Pqwerty said:
well normally i dont sub into a role where i have to defend myself immediately

but anyway

let's say im 100% wrong here and that there's no scum between you and X and there's scum between Ali and Alexis.

Then town has 3 protective roles, a BP, 2 investigators, and scum has what, an NK? Like you're saying that scum killed to avoid being watched, so this seems to imply they don't have a good means to escape a watch. So like what scum team roles make your scenario balanced?
Click to expand...
If you, me, & Dest are all town, then I think Reloaded pretty much has to be scum extra KP.

I don’t believe Ali/Alexis are both town (Ali much more likely to be scum). I believe scum probably have ways to deal with watcher. I believe they’d avoid killing him or blocking him bc doing so would make his counterpart look bad. (Bc people were already sussing there was scum between them)
 
I think if Ali & Alexis were both town scum would have gladly killed or blocked the other to make the other look worse and set up a mislynch
 
Reader mode
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top