Game Ranked Tower of God Mafia Thread

[Lord Melkor]

Town reads so far:

Magic
Lindtaylor
Emil
Mango

Weaker perhaps: Luka, Watson, Kurosaki Ichigo

I do not have a lot of scum reads - it is a large game so I would be wary of coasting people like Cubey.

 

[Sharter Holmes]

Also add Ekko (Emil) to town.

Hello hello

What do you think of Ekko's post?

 

[Kurosaki Ichigo]

I dot not actually disagreed, but you had prior experience with scum Magic?

No
I use general behaviour and my own scumdar

 

[Sharter Holmes]

Jokes aside…I need context for this environment as I am new to it. Do lynches typically happen Day 1?



Is this community adverse to a NL D1?

Generally, yes. People here prefer lynches D1

 

[Sharter Holmes]

Gad is one that I feel like I should have a read on but don't, and I don't think engaging directly will help with that

I feel hurt

 

[Kurosaki Ichigo]

Oh, so you're a top...

Gross

 

[Sharter Holmes]

Do you have an early PB impression, since you voted him?

Retro voted PB?

More importantly, who's PB?

 

[Sharter Holmes]

:[

What? No defensive mechanism this time round Fangy?

 

[Sharter Holmes]

Aren't you an experience player? I recall playing with you on NF. Yet you say you have no idead what is going on but you have time to post this

Vote lynch Cubey

Idk if that post you quoted is enough justification to throw in this random af vote

 

[Sharter Holmes]

Does everyone die when I'm here?

Do I stink?

 

[Kurosaki Ichigo]

There is no content generated by talking to yourself about yourself

.

Because while useless it doesn't seem like something scum would do to open up with imo!

That's not enough to town read Luka.
On the other hand, the fact that he talked to himself is not, however, a reason to hang him

Unvote
@Flower

 

[Kurosaki Ichigo]

Does everyone die when I'm here?

Do I stink?

I don't think too many have woken up yet

If you are scum

 

[Lindltaylor]

same reasons magic provided


sup sup

flavor?

Lilial Zahard

I

I don't like this read list. It feels more like a list of players you can sheep high up and then you have convenience at the bottom

I actually like that read list lol. Especially the town part of it since his and mine have similar players as town.

Oh yeah, what Miller do?

@Flower This the role I was talking about the other day, probably got it all wrong


Just... yeah...

I scan guilty to investigations.

Would you be able to say more on Gram, Gad, Ruffles or just gut feelings?

Gram mainly off of tone in his interaction with Ichigo. Seemed townie to me.

Gad - just gut honestly. Can't point to a single interaction here. It's an overall town gut read.

Ruffles - Think he town slipped in his first post where he said "Oh FUG" and his replies to Magic and Mango seemed tonally fine to me. Plus - considering that he's kinda new to Mafia - his replies are generally what I associate with Newbie townies.

Hello hello

What do you think of Ekko's post?

Think they're fine tbh. Since you quoted a part of Ekko's post talking about Ratchet - I'll address that by saying I actually like that observation since it's something that caught my attention while catching up as well, and which I later asked Ratchet about to clarify what he meant.

Retro voted PB?

More importantly, who's PB?

Polar Bear - PB.

 

[Lord Melkor]

Retro voted PB?

More importantly, who's PB?

Polar Bear

 

[Grammaton]

Actually on reflection, I’ve seen Ichigo as scum and it looked nothing like this so probably not a good lead to pursue

Unvote

 

[Aurelian]

What? No defensive mechanism this time round Fangy?

 

[Lindltaylor]

.
That's not enough to town read Luka.
On the other hand, the fact that he talked to himself is not, however, a reason to hang him

Unvote
@Flower

Talking to themselves apart, what do you make of the rest of Luka's posts? His responses to Watson, Melkor and others?

 

[Grammaton]

Reloaded has 7 posts, and everything he said can be easily faked. Go into more detail with this read of yours.

The detail you need is in the post you quoted - he just got completely annihilated as scum in back to back games early, and his manner is nothing like those games

 

[Grammaton]

Magic very active and solving + Magic complaining about inactivity > Magic town.
It's an easy and simple read for me, and I'm willing to give him time instead of being paranoid
It's not about the post itself, but about who posted it and how.

what do you think about Magic?

Except this post was about mango, not magic

 

[Kurosaki Ichigo]

Gram mainly off of tone in his interaction with Ichigo. Seemed townie to me.

I think it's just his personality, it has nothing to do with the game or the alignment in my opinion

Actually on reflection, I’ve seen Ichigo as scum and it looked nothing like this so probably not a good lead to pursue

Unvote

The detail you need is in the post you quoted - he just got completely annihilated as scum in back to back games early, and his manner is nothing like those games

how much do you rely on meta in your reads?