My initial stance on Magic vs Ultra has been TvT. Only at the beginning of this phase did Ultra drop from my Town reads, but reconciling why he’d do any of this as scum has been the hardest for me since.
As for Magic as town.. well, it’s more of a gut feel than anything. I mean he’s peddled accusations that seem very similar to what I’ve seen from WEF game as mentioned before, and his progression here isn’t that surprising to me. I recall him quoting a post of Ultra’s earlier in the day and asking “would scum Ultra do this” meaning re-evaluation was already taking some form in his mind.