• We're looking for artists. Direct message Dr. Watson for more info!

Game Ranked Wrestling Wars Mafia

Status
Not open for further replies.
Reader mode
Ultra said:
Masons are alignment bound to town, feel free to ask the host to clarify, but you should have nothing to worry about. I'm surprised you don't know this.
Click to expand...
Fwiw masons aren't always confirmed town on our home planet. Town/mafia town/SK Mafia/SK have all been a thing
 
Ekkologix said:
was about to ask u this actually

now we'd like to mostly say the same about flowa. she claims this early and ends up 99% being town
Click to expand...

I prefer my rationale tho

there’s risk to faking miller, there’s no risk to claiming your role as a Mason (typically)

in the last game I made the (unchallenged, even by flower) observation she would try and confirm herself town as scum - if you’re saying she’s got no discipline as town either then how is it indicative of anything?
 
Ultra said:
What are your reads right now?
Click to expand...
Nothing solid, Flower. Lean town on Tiara, Lean town on you (just), conflicted on Ekko.

Other name that comea to kind off the top of my head is Big Man, didn't love his entrance but I have nothing solid to argue with it.
 
Tiara said:
You two are arguing and it's not apparent why you're arguing, what you think of each other and generally it just feels off. Could you clarify?

You, too, @Ekkologix .
Click to expand...
You may as well be saying nothing. Or is this another "it's not town v town but I won't say who the scum is"? Null, gun to head I may even go town due to how he has focused on such a ridiculous point.
 
Ratchet said:
You may as well be saying nothing. Or is this another "it's not town v town but I won't say who the scum is"? Null, gun to head I may even go town due to how he has focused on such a ridiculous point.
Click to expand...
Nah, just a question because it is just confusing.

But thank you for the answer.
 
Ultra said:
What other aspects of play are you considering here? It's the beginning of the game.

I'll give my interpretation here. Given Flower's sequence of actions:

- Agreeing with your accusation that she was nervous
- Saying she has something she wants to discuss but is waiting until everyone has arrived (which was unclear at first, but now checks out as waiting for her mason to get here)
- Couldn't abide by her own deadline and bursts forth with what's on her mind immediately and in public.

I think all of these fit the profile of her being townie. I think as scum, the default assumption is that she tries to sooth her masonry partner in private and keeps a lid on her role at least for now. For her to be scum here requires quite a bit of performance and self awareness.

You could argue she claimed just for the sake of credit but then she immediately discredits the reliability of her own claim with her questioning whether or not to say anything about her other mason.

So I think she's more likely to be town.
Click to expand...
wow I got like totally the opposite impression
 
Grammaton said:
I prefer my rationale tho

there’s risk to faking miller, there’s no risk to claiming your role as a Mason (typically)

in the last game I made the (unchallenged, even by flower) observation she would try and confirm herself town as scum - if you’re saying she’s got no discipline as town either then how is it indicative of anything?
Click to expand...
last game she didnt claim day 1. she hinted EoD 2 backtracked it day 3

its not a strong read on her obviously. just a place to start. if we observe her gameplay to be scummy we change it

I for one don't get why she wud be nervous about it but I guess being anonymous and in an alien chat might have freaked her out? idk
 
Ekkologix said:
last game she didnt claim day 1. she hinted EoD 2 backtracked it day 3

its not a strong read on her obviously. just a place to start. if we observe her gameplay to be scummy we change it

I for one don't get why she wud be nervous about it but I guess being anonymous and in an alien chat might have freaked her out? idk
Click to expand...

the fact you’re using ‘idk’ in your justification should be a clue that you’re building on sand
 
thoughts on lethal entrance wud be great too

expecting him to be more excited about a wresting game
 
Ratchet said:
Nothing solid, Flower. Lean town on Tiara, Lean town on you (just), conflicted on Ekko.

Other name that comea to kind off the top of my head is Big Man, didn't love his entrance but I have nothing solid to argue with it.
Click to expand...

I have one concern about your progression right now - earlier you seem to hold as a strong prior that masons in this game probably implied a scum pairing, and that's why you were scum leaning Flower.

The problem is that I would expect you, if you believed this sincerely, to want to get the other mason claim regardless of your read on Flower, because a 50/50 shot is a pretty good trade off. You have not done this.
 
Reader mode
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top