His tussles with me were -
Money Heist - He was Scum, I was Town
DBZ - He was Town, I was Scum
Elden Ring - He was Scum, I was Town
You're conflating Poyser with me here too, but if you think he's attacking you with a poor angle then it should be fairly straightforward for you to dismantle it, especially as you have no reason to assume he is genuine while doing so here.
My irritation comes from this - I asked him what he finds suspect about my opening, he no sold the question, just asks a different one, and he has the reputation where he's just kind of taken in good faith to lead a charge even when the charge is shit.