Anyway I feel satisfied with my direction here knowing I can always blame Craig for not even considering Retro if he's scum
- Status
Tempest
Leprous Monarch
you can't, actually. you agreed with me that there's no way retro makes those night decisions.Anyway I feel satisfied with my direction here knowing I can always blame Craig for not even considering Retro if he's scum
Ugh what the fuck man, does scum you take her off the table like this
Tempest
Leprous Monarch
if I'm sure I can get the lynch I need, sure why not
Thing is CP I haven't actually misjudged retro, I told you what my considerations were, you're the one no-selling her based on NK theory alone, so to me it looks like you have your game plan in
If you think I should find your argument about Fuji NK compelling, you should almost certainly find my own argument compelling about why I would 100% kill you.
Because look at last lynch. That is a microcosm of what would be my scum end game, I go head to head with Ratchet and win because my thread play has been superior. I don't stack the deck against myself this way
Because look at last lynch. That is a microcosm of what would be my scum end game, I go head to head with Ratchet and win because my thread play has been superior. I don't stack the deck against myself this way
Doddsy
Mafia God
It was before.
I checked day 1 myself again after I sussed CP, he goes at Aurelian right away and is the first to call him out for his dodgy active posters post. I think putting it down to distancing doesn't quite fit.
If I lay out my thinking here.
CP has no reason to skip the kill, keep me alive, and to bus both of his team mates pretty hard. Going against him he has the fact he's alive pretty much. He did also push those day phases through pretty quick but I can't attribute that to him alone.
Ultra has been pretty scummy for most of the game. However, I don't think this situation is ideal for him either. I've advocated for his lynch previous, and he's essentially put himself up against CP in a one on one, as he's ignoring what I think might be the easier option on retro.
Retro the points given against are the kill choices largely being made while absent. But retro has also been shading me pretty constantly, saying that I'm good at blending in, which does somewhat account for me still being alive over lethal. That said retro hasn't really pushed in my direction at all so not sure on that
Tempest
Leprous Monarch
eh poyser tunneled you all game and had just flipped town. I don't think you necessarily win that battle. I lynched ratchet first because I had less reason to town read him, but the idea was always that we could lynch you both before losing
I don't actually think Retro has been absent for these recent NK's, if that's what you're saying is clearing her (I don't like this angleshooting but if you're going to use it I should address it)
Yeah, I considered that, but that's probably not ideal - you should really play kingmaker here as the confirmed townie
Doddsy
Mafia God
I thought that was what was said as to why retro wasn't being considered?
Wdym I don't necessarily win that battle - I just beat ratchet the other day. Whatever you can say, he would be 10x easier of a win condition than you are
Tempest
Leprous Monarch
that reason is secondary to the no-kill night which ultra and I agreed was too tactical to be her. also the NK choices themselves. why not kill the people who look the most town? that's the level 1 scum play. instead the scum kills appear overly clever and machiavellian. fits me, I'll admit. my hunch is it fits ultra too.
She wasn't absent, but there was a NK where no kill was made intentionally, and CP seems to think this means it's a calculated play by an experienced player
Doddsy
Mafia God
Yeah but if I die in absolved of the blame
Tempest
Leprous Monarch
according to ultra she's a mafia newb
- Status