• We're looking for artists. Direct message Dr. Watson for more info!

Final Fantasy XIV Mafia - Game Thread

Status
Not open for further replies.
Reader mode
Xadlin said:
my thoughts:

Town:
Melkor
Gram
Magic
lethal
Hans

Pro town:
Ekko
psychic
Craig
Ekko
Black dragon
Sworder

Indie:
T-pein- hes to good of a heel for me to put in either category.
Evan- his hateboner for t-pein makes him neg in my book

leaning Scum:
natalija- asked for a catchup and posted more then me
odd- odd made some town claims on day 1 so I think thats sus

[vote Lynch odd]
I dont get the whole Aurelian thing that happened for lik 5 -10 pages
Click to expand...
Err

How do you suddenly have 10 or so town reads? Feel free to elaborate on as many as you like
 
kinda wanna lynch someone from the pool that had raem in their scum reads as there's a lot of overlap there.

as in people that had both aurelian and raem(not tweet as he was the first one to do it and the post he quoted i saw where he was coming from, but i feel people piggy backed it).

tpein/lethal off the top of my head had raem as scum.
 
Grammaton said:
Getting yourself modkilled cause you can’t handle someone asking another player if they’d be up for voting you isn’t playing properly, it’s pathetic. Stop defending the indefensible
Click to expand...
it is what it is. again i dont mind playing with raem for the most part and i think he still plays himself into a town read. he has a weird way of playing but he is often trying to solve.

i do think he needs to look past thinking we're bullying/teaming up/etc on people as that's often not it lol, but he also hasn't seen us argue i guess(well he saw poyser and i argue).
 
Grammaton said:
See we’re at the point where internally I’m giving tpein credit for at least looking like he’s playing the game properly

How fucking pants on head is that

If for some reason I didn’t want to lynch Aurelian today (and I do) I would wagon odd next fwiw
Click to expand...
lethal is the next best bet before odd.

in any world. i just dont really wanna lynch the guy again on day 1 as i feel bad, but his tone is off, his reads looked like they were sheeped from cp tbh, and his final 3 scum reads didn't really resonate with me.
 
On topic of CP I'm a bit divided. On one hand I liked Ekkos points against him, but then there's also the fact that he went back and set the timeline straight on that Gram/Fang argument. Why would he ever do that as scum when the whole thread is having a field day with a wrong timeline? Also his "case" against Pein is decent and the fact that it gets zero traction is interesting in and of itself.
 
Hans Tweetenberg said:
On topic of CP I'm a bit divided. On one hand I liked Ekkos points against him, but then there's also the fact that he went back and set the timeline straight on that Gram/Fang argument. Why would he ever do that as scum when the whole thread is having a field day with a wrong timeline? Also his "case" against Pein is decent and the fact that it gets zero traction is interesting in and of itself.
Click to expand...

1) timeline fixing is something someone might have realized on their own when reviewing anyway. it also didn't really change a lot.

2) his case against tpein is good but as i mentioned my case against lethal in mhw was also good and used the previous game as a reference point. if cp saw him doing the exact same thing it's very good for him as scum to use that as a credible case because he's already used it before.

that said i can also see tpein as scummy for it because, with the assumption raem is town, because it is the exact same play and raem is likely to flip town.
 
Reader mode
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top