Final Fantasy XIV Mafia - Game Thread

[Emil]

if ur solving the game with lazy lenses like tpein has u can take some of my day 1 posts as a defense of BPD, when in reality they were me pursuing a scum read of cp over a town side of null read in BPD

anyway its still bad even for lazy solving because he hasnt established yet why does he have BPD as scum or CP as town. @T-Pein™ pls go ahead

 

[Emil]

No I meant I was told as scum he gets better as the game progresses too. It isn't just one alignment.

hes a master at gaslighting and making you do mistakes then blaming u for them and making u feel bad for it as the game goes lol

 

[Hans Tweetenberg]

No I meant I was told as scum he gets better as the game progresses too. It isn't just one alignment.

Frankly I don't have any evidence that he gets better or worse during the course of any game as any alignment. He either wants to play or he doesn't.

 

[Hans Tweetenberg]

Magic
CraigPelton
TSworder
Black Pegged Dragon
Ekkologix
T-Pein™
Psychic
Xadlin
Grammaton
Natalija
Odd
Lethal

Imotbh

 

[Tempest]

Welp this Xadlin direction sure has killed the thread lol

 

[Grammaton]

Im working a theory that Magic and CP are partners - their interactions are rubbing me up the wrong way

Apes assemble!

 

[Emil]

this is the part where we use the reps i suppose

 

[Emil]

Magic
CraigPelton
TSworder
Black Pegged Dragon
Ekkologix
T-Pein™
Psychic
Xadlin
Grammaton
Natalija
Odd
Lethal

Imotbh

can u talk to me about the strong TR on tpein and soft TR on BPD?

also u were teammate with sworder last game, anything u notice from him thats stopping u from leaning him one way or another?

 

[Emil]

not sure why are we this divided? what exactly is the hold up?

@Black Pegged Dragon if u have something just claim it. u dont have to wait

cp undermining my scum read by saying i always do it is bad because im not the only one scum reading him this game. thats a pretty scummy response

 

[Hans Tweetenberg]

can u talk to me about the strong TR on tpein and soft TR on BPD?

also u were teammate with sworder last game, anything u notice from him thats stopping u from leaning him one way or another?

Strong Pein town read is a combination of his posts making sense to me and me also wanting to bring some positive reinforcement to his current playstyle. It's intentionally too generous, realistically he's light blue.

Soft town read on BPD is because I still think he's off on play but also the fact that the wagon I got going on him yesterday caught steam pretty quickly and since his counterwagon was town that oughta look good for him.

Gotta be honest I didn't notice much about Sworder last game except that he didn't post much. His first half of d1 posts looked good in that regard but he's dropped off a cliff since so that town lean I had on him has eroded back to null.

 

[Emil]

Strong Pein town read is a combination of his posts making sense to me and me also wanting to bring some positive reinforcement to his current playstyle. It's intentionally too generous, realistically he's light blue.

Soft town read on BPD is because I still think he's off on play but also the fact that the wagon I got going on him yesterday caught steam pretty quickly and since his counterwagon was town that oughta look good for him.

Gotta be honest I didn't notice much about Sworder last game except that he didn't post much. His first half of d1 posts looked good in that regard but he's dropped off a cliff since so that town lean I had on him has eroded back to null.

hm ok
lets see what bpd has i suppose thats a start

we have to so something. feel like we r slowly drifting to the abyss lol

i'll start by... going to sleep

 

[Hans Tweetenberg]

Seconding btw that BPD oughta come out with it already if he has info, this is moving at a snails pace as is, info is what would help us get those gears running again

 

[Grammaton]

I’m going to be let down by my unwillingness to do endless work here, but the distilled version of what’s bothering me is as follows:

- CP is very good as town at spotting ‘good guy’ reads (TMI town reads made by scum)
- Magic has made several reads that I think are just plain ass pulls (Raem and Nat specifically, but Evans felt generous at the time and Tpein is no different today than yesterday)
- CP himself wanted to lynch Nat yesterday, didnt get the lynch he wanted but hasnt come out with his chest puffed, and didnt even try to challenge Magic when he proactively said shes town and wont vote there at the start of this phase

Also, Lethal is probably with them

All of CPs efforts toward Lethal yesterday are in the frame of 'he could be aligned with Tpein', and theres a performative interaction here too:

Psychic also had raem as scum and had no reaction to his modkill and moved on like it was nothing. Just an absent of a reaction.

Honestly likely want to lynch psychic at this point but want to see others weigh in. The content of her multi quotes were fine but the reads list is lacking compared to her recent town games. On top of thst I see heavy teammate equity with cp and I'm not feeling him either.

Nah we're not lynching Psychic you said yourself her play this game is nothing like her scum games

It also isn't like her town games. The read list she produced is also more similar to her scum games as it has two omgus in there but unlike her town games she isn't phrasing it in a way where she says scum is coming after me to lynch me.

nah I've caught her as indy she isn't any better at that than being mafia lol

looks the same to me

I don't think she's really been pressured enough to go into victim mode

eh maybe we just lynch t-pein here

seems like he's just in duck and cover mode while we push other people lol, hasn't done shit, wanted to lynch RAEM yesterday but didn't push it yet was adamantly against lynching Aurelian. I do think he's just scum again here

Calling me out for being odd is being dishonest when it is more likely that I'm going after her as a suspect. It's disingenuous.

She was sus on you early on in MHW mafia too

Magic hadn't even mentioned Psychic by this point in the game.


I actually think Psychic makes a good point here about Lethal. He's town leaning me out of hope? Since when is that a thing? He's usually careful around town reading my slot as most people are

I'm not seeing OMGUS here at all

Also I'm having a hard time seeing Aurelian as scum anymore tbh

BPD I'm kind of wavering on. Would rather just yeet T-Pein at this point

unvote
vote T-Pein

Your persistence in defending her and town reading her seems over the top relative to how far you tend to go for other town reads of yours. Why is psychic so special?

This reads as arranging the board, pure and simple.

Theres a lot more but CBA atm, if you want to look yourself, the two of them are maintaining a safe distance but theres no bite to anything they do with each other. CP was typing in caps DEMANDING we lynch Nat yesterday, and if anything theres now a higher chance hes right given the flips and kills - wheres the followup?

 

[Emil]

I am serious, he’s lost in the sauce. I’d say he has no idea what he’s going to do next

@CraigPelton accurate?

what sauce exactly are we right on that cp is lost in?

he town read aurelian and scum read now (tho dropped it today for ??? reasons)

please elaborate more

 

[Emil]

I’m going to be let down by my unwillingness to do endless work here, but the distilled version of what’s bothering me is as follows:

- CP is very good as town at spotting ‘good guy’ reads (TMI town reads made by scum)
- Magic has made several reads that I think are just plain ass pulls (Raem and Nat specifically, but Evans felt generous at the time and Tpein is no different today than yesterday)
- CP himself wanted to lynch Nat yesterday, didnt get the lynch he wanted but hasnt come out with his chest puffed, and didnt even try to challenge Magic when he proactively said shes town and wont vote there at the start of this phase

Also, Lethal is probably with them

All of CPs efforts toward Lethal yesterday are in the frame of 'he could be aligned with Tpein', and theres a performative interaction here too:

























This reads as arranging the board, pure and simple.

Theres a lot more but CBA atm, if you want to look yourself, the two of them are maintaining a safe distance but theres no bite to anything they do with each other. CP was typing in caps DEMANDING we lynch Nat yesterday, and if anything theres now a higher chance hes right given the flips and kills - wheres the followup?

you can probably fit BPD into that team and ship it

 

[Emil]

or xadlin or odd or honestly even nat... they likely knew she wasnt getting lynched

anyway lets start with cp. hes a center piece

goodnight

 

[Grammaton]

you can probably fit BPD into that team and ship it

Possibly, but I’m reading he’s suggesting info on xadlin

 

[Grammaton]

or xadlin or odd or honestly even nat... they likely knew she wasnt getting lynched

anyway lets start with cp. hes a center piece

goodnight

No, Nat was meant to be the dangling fruit today, why do you think magic made a big show of saying she WONT be the direction today, unprompted? The idea was for people to demand it, magic could spend the day shading teammates gently but with nothing that’s going to get them killed. For example he’s voting CP, any idea why? No, me neither

For the love of god don’t say it’s cause they could be teammates, that’s level 1 and you know it

 

[Natalija]

Holy shit, they got the nice roles

 

[Grammaton]

Holy shit, they got the nice roles

Time to start playing