Final Fantasy XIV Mafia - Game Thread

[Arne Slot]

I'm down to lynch her though not really sure where else to go rn tbh

 

[Arne Slot]

Btw @Grammaton if you could give my posts this phase a closer look I've been hinting at something kind of blatantly

 

[Grammaton]

I'm still down to lynch her but if she's not going to claim it'd be a voteto lynch. Why would I start there at the beginning of the phase?

I’m struggling to buy this as your logic - I don’t think you would cater to that kind of silliness, and even if for arguments sake you would, it would still be worth it to see how other players play around it

I don’t think you approach hunting through the prism of the claim being the important thing - the claim is really just an emergency parachute that will stop you pushing certain lynches through.

This doesn’t seem real to me.

 

[Arne Slot]

I’m struggling to buy this as your logic - I don’t think you would cater to that kind of silliness, and even if for arguments sake you would, it would still be worth it to see how other players play around it

I don’t think you approach hunting through the prism of the claim being the important thing - the claim is really just an emergency parachute that will stop you pushing certain lynches through.

This doesn’t seem real to me.

1) I'm not gonna lynch someone at the start of a new phase

2) BPD, who I trust, hinted info on someone in my POE

 

[EkkoLoJinx]

Nat doesn't claim we learned that last game didn't we

I like to use the whole phase and Bpd was hitting info

well this is bullshit because these r all ur posts before BPD came out with the result today and none of them says we shud pursue nat to continue yesterday, nor atleast establish why u think she is town to let her go scot-free. this transition is more scum aligned than town

Cool so it's basically a 13 player game now where Mafia have a big advantage

Sounds like a job for the reigning town MVP

You don't wanna just lynch magic?

Why wouldn't he?

Is this kill spec useful?

@Grammaton just take the L on being wrong on aurelian and try to redeem yourself this phase. This moping around is weak af

All right time to analyze the wagons d1

What do you make of Magic d1 feels like he made a lot of noise but didn't really divert from the Aurelian lynch. Do you think he's right about Psychic being scum, or me?

Both sus of Magic early...both dead now...the busywork comment stands out to me because idk what the point of trying to figure out if T-Pein would suggest killing Evans in a scum qt is when we don't even know if Evans was the mafia kill. And a lot of what Magic did d1 felt like pushing papers around without really trying to lead anything. He did try to sus Psychic but all his reasons were trash, and even when I pointed out and admitted Psychic wasnt playing to her scum meta he kept sussing her. I like the fact that she didn't come in voting Magic tho as I feel if Magic was town and she was scum that that might be the angle they try and play today

I have no opinion on ODD

Lethal's play looks very fearful and shallow in substance since he's mainly just parroted me/you/gram and gave us all town reads. I am leaning scum on him but want to re-read the game. Will probably skip the Gram/Aurelian stuff tho

if by u you mean he. I wanted the Nat cfd but there was like a minute left and we couldn't get her even 1 away from hammer

bring it

what?

magic asks a lot of questions literally every game

early shout for lethal being the sk

nah it just tracks with the fact he's not as much of a hidden coward as he is as scum but also wants to be on the BIG BOYS's safe side and is throwing reads around rather mechanically to that effect

xadlin comes in and has nothing to say about the Aurelianfest that had dominated much of the thread by this point

ye I agree with this

so xadlin says this later on, I guess realizing it's odd that he hadn't said anything about aurelian yet.

I called out Xadlin in real time I guess and he pretty much just repeated himself

I'm still not a huge fan of this point from tweet as it's kind of an irrelevant point but he's using it to seem like he's considering me from multiple angles

I'm all right with tweet overall btw even if I didn't like that one post I think he's more likely town than not here

I feel like turning on a dime seemingly inexplicably is well baked into my meta at this point lol

dime his name is BPD, I will be vindicated on that one, he's town

ekko is doing that thing where he makes assbackwards conclusions with confidence so I think he's probably town

that's the vibe I got from you after re-reading your d1 posts. if you're scum I will be shook

Lethal's read on psychic didn't evolve at all as she came into the game and started playing, bad sign

I think I'm all right with magic for now tbh, generally agreeing with his town reads and after re-reading my posts d1 I can see why I look bad here even with the aurelian town flip

my only motivation for voting magic rn would be if he flipped scum I would get to point out that psychic caught him for the rest of his life

who's they?

are you actually town reading nat? from what I've seen on a reread your main contention is odo's reason for suspecting her isn't valid

so I assume he's also a town lean for you right? lol

(jk I know you voted him)

 

[Grammaton]

1) I'm not gonna lynch someone at the start of a new phase

2) BPD, who I trust, hinted info on someone in my POE

You don’t have to lynch them tho

You’re just voting to apply heat / you then respond to what happens after that

As for the other thing, I see

 

[Natalija]

1) I'm not gonna lynch someone at the start of a new phase

2) BPD, who I trust, hinted info on someone in my POE

Are you up to speed? He shot Xadlin and we assume Hans roleblocked BPD

 

[Arne Slot]

Are you up to speed? He shot Xadlin and we assume Hans roleblocked BPD

Yeah I'd like clarification from Hans on the roleblock

 

[Arne Slot]

You don’t have to lynch them tho

You’re just voting to apply heat / you then respond to what happens after that

As for the other thing, I see

Well I trust you to reread my posts this phase and talk town out of lynching me

I gotta do some work rn bbl

 

[Natalija]

I have no opinion on ODD

Really? Is this still the case?

 

[Grammaton]

Well this is a pickle

@Ratchet sorry to be a pest, coukd we get another count please?

 

[EkkoLoJinx]

Yeah I'd like clarification from Hans on the roleblock

wud this make a difference for u? tweet's answer will always be something along the lines of "i scum read BPD so i blocked/jailed him" regardless of tweet's alignment. where do u move from there?

also thoughts on the tracker claim and usage?

 

[Magic]

Wait tweet claimed roleblocker?

 

[Grammaton]

Part of me is rooting for the timeline where CP is scum here, as this would be an ingenious bit of play

 

[EkkoLoJinx]

Think we can let Xadlin self resolve here since Mafia and SK both will want him dead

unvote

u dont think hes roletracker?

im struggling to follow ur thought process

so u didnt suspect him of being mafia enough to disregard such an NAI claim?

 

[Grammaton]

u dont think hes roletracker?

im struggling to follow ur thought process

so u didnt suspect him of being mafia enough to disregard such an NAI claim?

Gonna ask you to trust me here - bark up another tree at least until he’s back

 

[Natalija]

3 - Magic
4 - CraigPelton
5 - TSworder
6 - Black Pegged Dragon
7 - Ekkologix
8 - T-Pein™
9 - Psychic
10 - Xadlin
11 - Grammaton
14 - Hans Tweetenberg
15 - Natalija
16 - Odd
17 - Lethal

I'm about here rn. Not sure T-Pein/Nat or Lethal/Xadlin would be aligned so this isn't really my final answer scum team of 4 or anything

I assume a 12/4/1 split with 17 players and 2 non-townie night kills

Town read I'm least sure on is probably Tweet. Maybe Ekko if T-Pein is town.

Magic
CraigPelton
TSworder
Black Pegged Dragon
Ekkologix
T-Pein™
Psychic
Xadlin
Grammaton
Hans Tweetenberg
Natalija
Odd
Lethal
==============
Evans
Lord Melkor
Aurelian

It seems you two are almost at the same headspace. Do you believe the tracker claim?

 

[Magic]

Well this is unfortunate as all hell

Let's just say I'm the reason your shot failed

Are you roleblocker or jailkeeper?

 

[EkkoLoJinx]

Well I trust you to reread my posts this phase and talk town out of lynching me

I gotta do some work rn bbl

the reigning town MVP needs players who mislynched day 1 to bail him out in day 2. u cant make this up

look how far u have fallen

sad.jpg

 

[EkkoLoJinx]

Gonna ask you to trust me here - bark up another tree at least until he’s back

im running out of trees to bark at up until i see his flip

cp flipping town likely loses the game tho. i wud drastically feel much lower about towns chances of victory