• We're looking for artists. Direct message Dr. Watson for more info!

Game Ranked Medieval Fantasy Mafia - Game Thread

Status
Not open for further replies.
Reader mode
Magic said:
ya but when i was scum with him he immediately fought back against the lethal lynch that was happening to basically throw himself into the fray for no apparent reason. he got called out for wanting to defend lethal/a day 1 lynch when he usually doesn't care about the direction day is going.
Click to expand...
thats true in the sense that i wouldnt expect him to actively defend people, but nor would i expect him to just jump on either. id expect some variation of calling us cringe for going for lethal again, or cringe for thinking naomi is scum for repping out etc and making comments about others he thinks are scummy
 
Magic said:
ya but when i was scum with him he immediately fought back against the lethal lynch that was happening to basically throw himself into the fray for no apparent reason. he got called out for wanting to defend lethal/a day 1 lynch when he usually doesn't care about the direction day is going.
Click to expand...

Yeah because he wanted to undermine poyser specifically, he didn’t think for a second poyser would actually switch over to him - that’s what I’m saying, he couldn’t resist the chance to run poysers face in how wrong he was

Probably the worst piece of scum play I’ve ever seen tbh
 
I think we should melkor today, it would give alot of info.


Change vote lynch LM

If he flips town. I'm sorry LM but you were scummy.

If he flips Mafia, we vig Whisker for defending him.
 
Magic said:
I mean unless you guys think he's scummy or scum I don't see the point of this discussion as I won't be moving my town lean on him.
Click to expand...
I do have him in my scum leans yes
Even more so due to the fact hes done literally nothing else since. Im just aware that its tpein therefore cant be nailed on. But I'd lynch, one hundred
 
RDK said:
no- i think vinegar is town and they scum read ultra who i also scum read
Click to expand...

Lazy, you didn't even try with this one. RDK can go.

Magic said:
mango you want to go after LM with me?

i dont actually care about the ultra push, just wanted to see if rdk would jump on. someone else bit too so that's fun. i gotta go check to see who it was but those two are not going to be teamed.
Click to expand...

This explanation also makes no sense, though. RDK was prompted to do *something* and then brought up the proposition on his own initiative. What did you actually accomplish with this?
 
Ultra said:
Lazy, you didn't even try with this one. RDK can go.



This explanation also makes no sense, though. RDK was prompted to do *something* and then brought up the proposition on his own initiative. What did you actually accomplish with this?
Click to expand...
Knowing im being lazy implies knowing I'm town btw

Ultra can go
 
Poyser said:
Just wanted to have a gander at BPDs game that I've seen him as scum, and the last game we played together as town. As scum he's so fucking blase and chill and if you compare it to the town game its a stark contrast, even just the way he starts the games and gets stuck into the thick of things. Take a look yourselves. Dont have to reads loads, maybe just the first 2-3 pages of his ISO and you can skim to get a feel

Eastenders (he was town) - https://onelastforum.com/search/161721/?page=2
Wrestling wars (he was scum) - https://onelastforum.com/search/161722/?page=8

Compare both to his posts in this game. Which vibes he givin?
Click to expand...

Also, I want to say your links are broken here but my meta on BPD is that he's noticeably different between alignments, I think what your characterization here is missing is that he does a lot of fairly performative reads as scum and basically so far he's tunneled the fuck out of Melkor
 
Ultra said:
Lazy, you didn't even try with this one. RDK can go.



This explanation also makes no sense, though. RDK was prompted to do *something* and then brought up the proposition on his own initiative. What did you actually accomplish with this?
Click to expand...
he brought up the proposition without actually voting you. i wanted to see if he actually would engage. i didn't get a lot, but again whoever the third vote was likely is never aligned with you if you're scum or if they're scum you're likely town.

so i got something.
 
Ultra said:
Also I feel like Psychic is kind of out of range but has been kicked around quite a bit, can someone suspecting her toss me some cliffnotes?
Click to expand...
I thought her progression towards voting LM the first time was unnatural. Missed the last couple of hours though, so I should probably check in to see what she's done since!
 
Magic said:
he brought up the proposition without actually voting you. i wanted to see if he actually would engage. i didn't get a lot, but again whoever the third vote was likely is never aligned with you if you're scum or if they're scum you're likely town.

so i got something.
Click to expand...

Again, you weren't the one who brought it up - he did. You were testing to see if he did what he said he was going to do two seconds prior - what exactly did you glean from that?
 
@Psychic You seem really invested in defending yourself here - where does that come from? I've never seen you like this at all before actually, first you kept asking about being town read and then your response to Mango was pretty emotionally-charged.
 
Poyser said:
Flower
Hime
Whicker
Aurelian

Psychic
Melkor
Gram
Lethal

Null-ish

Ratchet
Ultra

Scummy

BPD
RDK
Tpein

This is probably about where I’m at currently. I don’t like really anything that ratchet has been doing but from conversing I do at the very least get a sense that he believes what he is saying which is a good sign.

With haza I think he’s mostly stuck to real easy stuff so far. His only town reads are fang and flower. Flower is consensus and fang is not somebody he can ignore due to their history so he’d pretty much have to give him a read. The only person he is pushing is lethal, and he seemed to work backwards to where he voted lethal alongside the other guys, and then began sussing lethal independently afterwards. Didn’t seem natural

Touched on Tpein and BPD already but I think I wanna lynch BPD. He’s just night and day compared to what I’m used to seeing from him as town. I get that he might have tempered his energy recently but even so I’d expect him to be scum hunting and pressing people, he’s almost solely focused on defence and how he looks, and whilst he is voting melkor and calling him scum, he hasn’t made any effort to explain why, convince others or either typically harass him which in my experience he ALWAYS does when he has a strong scum read. Like he’s saying he’s almost 100 on Melkor being scum but I couldn’t tell you why and he barely seems interested in interacting with him.

Play wise, I’d say he matches what I saw from him in wrestling wars far greater than he matches any game I’ve ever seen him play as town.

vote BPD
Click to expand...

why do you have melkor as a town lean?
 
Reader mode
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top