• We are currently rolling out incremental alterations to the forum. Don't freak! You aren't going crazy.

Game Ranked Negima Mafia

Status
Not open for further replies.

Tempest

Leprous Monarch
I'd look at aurelian, tweet, and then maybe someone like whickeror sigismund for scum. Think I'm all right with everyone else for now
 

Dr. Watson

‣ ↻
Administrator
If I was vig no way I'd shoot tonight as well. Pretty sure there's a vig or equivalent on 95% of the games and he hasn't been counterclaimed so I'm happy to trust unless major twists happen.
The latter would make it far more interesting

Now, what is this reaction from Big Man
 

RDK

Marvelous
Any reason aurelian isn't in people's scum poe? Seems like he completely avoided mentioning lethal despite saying he was around all d1? He voted kurumi immediately after lethals claim
Who said Aurelian isn't in POE? Don't think I've seen anyone with a solid town read on him?
 

Sky

So unreliable.
Pronouns
She/Her
Any reason aurelian isn't in people's scum poe? Seems like he completely avoided mentioning lethal despite saying he was around all d1? He voted kurumi immediately after lethals claim
Seems incriminating but that could also be because Lethal did literally nothing until right before EoD
 

Dr. Watson

‣ ↻
Administrator
Hey all I'm sorry but I overestimated the small amount of time I'm gonna have for this game. I want to play, but I'm only going to have a couple hours each night to read and post. I can be on throughout the day sparingly to respond to pings/questions, but I won't be caught up at all while doing so.

Just gonna go down the player list and go through their ISOs.
Craig - Seems mostly afk today. I don't think I can call any of his posts alignment indicative tbh.
Oneiros - I liked his entrance. My immediate reaction to #859 isn't great as I feel like it would add to some of the chaos he alludes to in #837, and it just seems a little out of place from the tone of the rest of his posts. A couple of his posts (816, 868 for example) seem to want to play as the "voice of reason" which I find a bit on the scummy side. He has some good posts as well (488, 891). Slight town lean here.
Fuji - This slot has been focusing on me, which in general I think suspecting my slot at this point is decently townie given what I've done. I'm a little weirded out by how exclusive it seems to be, but their thought process on their townreads seems genuine. Town lean
RDK - Jumped on a lynch for claimed watcher and has done nothing else. I could vote here.
Tweet - Hasn't really done anything yet. Null.
Aurelian - I thought his fight with Retro was TvT when it occured due to how it seemed to come from feelings from outside the game. Since then though, I feel like he's kind of slipped into the background and makes only safe comments. Scum lean here.
Kurumi - Claimed watcher isn't gonna get my vote for the day.
Gramma - IC
Sky - I'm not sure what to think here. I feel like she's just sus'ing every little thing she finds weird (she jumped on Psychic for the Bears, jumped on Orca for reaction test, jumped on Lethal for his entrance, jumped on Craig, jumped on me, etc) which my immediate reaction is she's wanting to prod those slots for more info. Looking through a second time, though, she doesn't really give many town reads, which my immediate reaction to that is scum who wants to test the waters on each thing for a mislynch. GTH read town lean since this could just be a playstyle difference more than anything else.
Retro - As I said I liked her interaction with Aurelian early as TvT. I think #524 seems pretty fake in terms of trying to solve. There's a lot of empty noise in her ISO and I don't see much solving. I think self-depricating posts are towny in general, but she seems to use this as cover a lot for her actions. This could be scum.
hime - Gonna say I don't like much of what she's had to say so far. I really hate #531 and in general the defense of herself for the T-Pein thing. Otherwise she's just given pretty low-hanging reads such as Psychic town. Also she's kind of set herself up to hide behind the IC vote in #582. I'd vote here today too.
T-Pein - I like his posting in general. Relaxed and carefree. Doesn't care what anyone thinks of him. I think his reaction to the Kurumi claim was very towny. I wouldn't say he's lock-town but he seems pretty town.
Big Man - 1 post. Null
Sigismund - 6 posts. Null
Polar Bear - I've really liked his recent posting, especially his reaction to Kurumi. #791, #831, #835 are all good towny posts from him. On top of this I've felt he was decently town the first half of the day. Pretty solid town read here.
Orca - His early game reaction tests made him one of my earliest town reads. I've been less impressed with the second half of his D1, where he's sat back and asked more general questions than making more proactive strides towards solving. I wouldn't vote here today, but I'm keeping my eye on this slot.
Lethal - His entrance isn't what I'd expect from him, but I know he has reason to be a bit... friendlier after last game. Null.
Balsamic - The first half of the day was more or less null from her, but I like what I've seen recently. I like their reads on both Orca and Polar. I think #681 is towny. Town lean
Psychic - I can agree #532 is more in line with what I expected from town!Psychic. I'm not entirely convinced she didn't do it because she was called out, but she can be in the town category for today.
Good catch
 

Dr. Watson

‣ ↻
Administrator
Slight waffling

Why didn't you expand on your thoughts when it came to Aurelian, Whicker
You explicitly say you think this was a TvT interaction, so what's changed
 

Tempest

Leprous Monarch
I'd push aurelian over whicker tho I feel like arguing with retro is easy content where whicker at least compiled a lot of thoughts on a lot of different players
 

Sky

So unreliable.
Pronouns
She/Her
I'd push aurelian over whicker tho I feel like arguing with retro is easy content where whicker at least compiled a lot of thoughts on a lot of different players
Aurelian as scum would make Retro town for me which seems a good shout
 

Whicker

Preeminent
Slight waffling

Why didn't you expand on your thoughts when it came to Aurelian, Whicker
You explicitly say you think this was a TvT interaction, so what's changed
The reasons I thought it was TvT was because it dragged on for longer than I thought it would if scum were involved, and I thought it felt more personal than game.
But looking through that seems the only real thing he’s done this game, which I’ve seen town!Fang just be significantly more proactive.
The interaction with you is the reason I have him as lean scum rather than “I think he’s scum” because I do think it’s a reason to townread him, but I’d need more to say he’s trying to solve
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top