• We are currently rolling out incremental alterations to the forum. Don't freak! You aren't going crazy.

Game Ranked OLF Members Mafia

Status
Not open for further replies.

Lord Melkor

Exceptional
Alright I dug up one post for the xad case

That said, when did you start being less certain of your scum read on him mel?

I would expect scum to act with more self preservation, especially that there should be more than 1 so it is not like Xadlin is on his own.

He is still a scum lean at this stage though, POE is gettting smaller and smaller.
 

Dr. Watson

‣ ↻
Administrator
Speaking of confident, I also sometimes withhold Poses (regardless of my level of certainty surrounding slots I scumread) because I'm waiting for this very scenario to happen

By leaving it open and showing some vulnerability in my reads, it translates as "she must be easily pocketable and nervous over fucking the game over, let's increase the paranoia over remaining townread slots tenfold"

Best case scenario?
You're wolf and Mel is also a wolf and the "what if" mechanics behind a potential wolf Mel is correct

Worst case scenario?
You're town, Ratchet is actually wolf the entire time and Hime did get it right and I overlooked and miscleared his own slot because he decided to operate on my level and pave room for error by lynching Evans in order to gain further credibility

The likelihood of the latter? Slim to none, Ratchet isn't as patient as that and patience is required to pull off pulling that amount of strings just so he wouldn't be suspected all in order to avoid suspicion from previous slots
This isn't a 5D world I live in, the day that happens I'll give my first born to the scum player who found the idea of toying with people's reads doing these elaborate tricks even if they're in a really good position to end the game early a player I may have to low-key wonder is a sociopath or WAD's child he doesn't know about
 

Dr. Watson

‣ ↻
Administrator
I would expect scum to act with more self preservation, especially that there should be more than 1 so it is not like Xadlin is on his own.

He is still a scum lean at this stage though, POE is gettting smaller and smaller.
Fair enough

I don't think he thinks ahead (which I think Ratchet is giving him too much credit with)
Think the dude just vibes and does what he wants to as either alignment
He doesn't strike me as one who would also worry himself over mechanics, either
And the arguments based mostly on the conventional, logical conclusion toward him don't really necessarily apply - so him voting and not helping himself is mostly because he just straight up lacks self-preversation

If he's, like, essentially working solo he's going to give off this same thing as scum, too
I am sure his mates have felt similarly to how town feels playing with him because no one can get a good grasp on the dude

Vote lynch Xadlin
 

Dr. Watson

‣ ↻
Administrator
Imagine being in a scum team with Xad

"Hey Xad can you come back in 5 hours we need your action"
"hey did i miss anything"
"I said 5 hours, not 15."
 

Lord Melkor

Exceptional
Vote: Xadlin
Fair enough

I don't think he thinks ahead (which I think Ratchet is giving him too much credit with)
Think the dude just vibes and does what he wants to as either alignment
He doesn't strike me as one who would also worry himself over mechanics, either
And the arguments based mostly on the conventional, logical conclusion toward him don't really necessarily apply - so him voting and not helping himself is mostly because he just straight up lacks self-preversation

If he's, like, essentially working solo he's going to give off this same thing as scum, too
I am sure his mates have felt similarly to how town feels playing with him because no one can get a good grasp on the dude

Vote lynch Xadlin

Okay if you and Ratchet want it i can go with it.

vote lynch Xadlin
 

Dr. Watson

‣ ↻
Administrator
I used the same logic with hime, tbqh

Could just be there's such a limited pool of players and scum is running out of ways to cause chaos

Or, alternatively, the census fudged the numbers
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top