• We are currently rolling out incremental alterations to the forum. Don't freak! You aren't going crazy.

Game Ranked Tower of God Mafia Thread

Status
Not open for further replies.
Reader mode
Ultra

Ultra

THE BEAR
Moderator
Mafia Beast
Grammaton said:
Nah, I’ve neither the time nor inclination. You should probably read it tho
Click to expand...

I've read it, in short I disagree, I think Magic was kind of missing the forest for the trees with his point on Melkor and there isn't really a contradiction between "I think this player should operate this way because I have a meta read on them" and "I think Melkor is scummy because he acted opposite of (meta read)"

Particularly because when you have two players with comparable scum ranges you can draw generalizations and equivalence between the two, as long as their ceilings aren't too high. And I think you can make an argument that Magic is correct there, it didn't really feel compelling enough for him to walk away with the read on Ratchet that he did
 
Ratchet

Ratchet

Moderator
Moderator
Test
Kamen Rider, which is under the same umbrella as Super Sentai which Power Rangers comes from. All the terrible ones too, naturally.
 
Aurelian

Aurelian

Titan
Administrator
Decepticon
Grammaton said:
Why must there always be at least one player acting like an insufferable pleb in these games
Click to expand...
1682651908500432.png
 
Grammaton

Grammaton

Consigliere
Moderator
Ultra said:
I've read it, in short I disagree, I think Magic was kind of missing the forest for the trees with his point on Melkor and there isn't really a contradiction between "I think this player should operate this way because I have a meta read on them" and "I think Melkor is scummy because he acted opposite of (meta read)"

Particularly because when you have two players with comparable scum ranges you can draw generalizations and equivalence between the two, as long as their ceilings aren't too high. And I think you can make an argument that Magic is correct there, it didn't really feel compelling enough for him to walk away with the read on Ratchet that he did
Click to expand...

Which was what, exactly? I don’t remember any real conclusion being drawn, but then there wouldn’t need to be, this was more about, in ratchets own words, him attacking magic, not the other way around?
 
Ultra

Ultra

THE BEAR
Moderator
Mafia Beast
Grammaton said:
Which was what, exactly? I don’t remember any real conclusion being drawn, but then there wouldn’t need to be, this was more about, in ratchets own words, him attacking magic, not the other way around?
Click to expand...

He implied Ratchet was scummy and wasn't pursuing it because Day 1 hallpass and all
 
Magic

Magic

Resplendent
Ultra said:
I've read it, in short I disagree, I think Magic was kind of missing the forest for the trees with his point on Melkor and there isn't really a contradiction between "I think this player should operate this way because I have a meta read on them" and "I think Melkor is scummy because he acted opposite of (meta read)"

Particularly because when you have two players with comparable scum ranges you can draw generalizations and equivalence between the two, as long as their ceilings aren't too high. And I think you can make an argument that Magic is correct there, it didn't really feel compelling enough for him to walk away with the read on Ratchet that he did
Click to expand...
melkor is nothing like mango in terms of meta. even as town melkor often finds himself suspected and told he's saying suspicious shit. quite literally throughout your entire game. mango, meanwhile, seems obviously town at times including this and last game. dont think there's any generalizations you can draw from that.

also you keep referring to some read on ratchet that i never gave or said..
 
Magic

Magic

Resplendent
Ultra said:
He implied Ratchet was scummy and wasn't pursuing it because Day 1 hallpass and all
Click to expand...
i dont give people day 1 hallpasses. i just need to be sure they're scum.

for reference, as our dear flower will tell you, ive legit never been wrong on olf in who i think should be lynched day 1(with the closest being your game with gad however i still wanted reloaded over lethal which is what i stated). if i was giving hall passes to good players to go after town instead that's one thing, i just prefer sure things.
 
Magic

Magic

Resplendent
unvote

i still think he should claim but i dont think aurelian is scum here. last time he trolled like this was avatar, where he was again goading people to vote for him. he has some level of pride in his scum play where he wouldn't pull this shit as scum.
 
Reader mode
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top