What do you think of Luka being Indie? Don't really think this stands up anyway - if you think that regarding Magic then what do you take from Magic's posts so far? He hasn't given a single town read, and his only real interaction with me is saying I'm doing too much and asking me about whether I think there is an execution mechanic. It's not exactly setting the world alight to me, so I'd love to hear what your issues are with my conclusion there. Being generous with town reads is a given - most of you can't play town very well so I have to stretch and ask myself if it makes sense for you to do as scum. If I feel like the answer is no then you get a town read. It gives me something to work with.
Performative isn't really a good enough description. I've outlined what I'm looking for from him and why I think I haven't seen it, there is an element where my vote is made not to lynch but to gauge his reaction, which you could argue is performative as it presents conviction of a read that isn't there, but I've been pretty transparent about this. My attempt to prod you for thoughts is just that - you are not above giving something to the game, I voted you because I haven't liked how much of a backseat you had taken so far and your response to this is to take every facet of my play an interpret it in the most uncharitable way you possibly can. I am not impressed.