• We're looking for artists. Direct message Dr. Watson for more info!

Game Official Ranked Xmas Mafia 2024 - Where Worlds Collide

Reader mode
Ratchet said:
I mean she can, but that typically wouldn't be the only or even the primary motivation for a kill. And if it is, it would imply that she's leading the scum team - a sentiment which is not congruent with your reads (as it would mean most if not all of the scum team are newer/less confident scum, to defer to Flower). Lappland's point is this - with the idea being that Scum Flower wouldn't both post restrict you and kill Craig to set you up, so you pushing that looks like you're pushing a poor angle. Which I think is a congruent pattern of thought.

Also, I think the idea that Flower would post restrict you, of all players, to shut you up is a bit weak. She knows that you're quite tenacious when you're in a tunnel, and I don't really think she'd be able to have the expectation that post restricting you would just shut you up. I do think the usage is very questionable though, so I wouldn't say it's entirely out of pocket. Just not something I think she would be thinking.
Click to expand...
not entirely true
regarding the sentiment
i have on the scum

team. see melkor did
not do much anti spew which
lead me to believe

his team could be all
inactives or didn't care
to shut him up, yay!
 
Ratchet said:
I mean, are you going to expand on this so-called "equity"? It also doesn't really address the issue that I raise - this shouldn't really need to be pointed out to you for you to come to these conclusions.
Click to expand...
sorry man it takes
me like fifty minutes to
write one post and make

sure i am not uh
missing any syllabi.
anti town usage
 
Lappland said:
I don't think they would show in thread, but I would assume the initial people who switched off watson are townier than not. The later people have more bus equity
Click to expand...

I mean, I would go tottaly "wtf are you oing, watson is outed scum, you, you and you are going next after watson flips scum" :O
 
Chuck said:
I mean, I would go tottaly "wtf are you oing, watson is outed scum, you, you and you are going next after watson flips scum" :O
Click to expand...
Which fucks you over the moment watson flips not scum and melkor is vigged


Don't do things that fuck over your position long term unless its endgame where you can hail mary it
 
Lappland said:
Which fucks you over the moment watson flips not scum and melkor is vigged


Don't do things that fuck over your position long term unless its endgame where you can hail mary it
Click to expand...

yeah, but atm i'd worry about my favoured outcome of D1 going to hell, welp, i don't play ranked mafia
 
while i think poyser's
reads may likely have a wolf
in them, remember

he was not uh, the
mafia kill most likely.
might have serial

in his top sus reads.
bro finishing these haiku
is so giga cringe
 
Ultra said:
Also not terribly uncommon for players uninitiated here to get tripped up with flavor associations. Most people are used to shit hosting. Wouldn't use it as a reliable indicator someone is pushing papers unless they should know better. Think Lap is just tunneled town fwiw

Also we don't really do multiball around here just for the record, like ever. I would eat my left nut if this was a multiball game
Click to expand...
Aren't multiball games usually role madness games anyway?
 
can we like stop uh
being cringe and get more votes
on X please. we are

kind of wasting time
time over here. if he does
not claim we just cap
 
EkkoLoJinx said:
while i think poyser's
reads may likely have a wolf
in them, remember

he was not uh, the
mafia kill most likely.
might have serial

in his top sus reads.
bro finishing these haiku
is so giga cringe
Click to expand...
I have no reason to believe there is a killing neutral in this game. So I will work under the assumption that the only neutral party here is Watson if they are not scum.

I've played many games and I've found that scum try to discredit the legacy of a town leader by crediting it to a neutral or an uncliamed vig. In this case, i don't see why it is unlikely that Poyser was killed by scum, they are responsible for Melkor and was leading town on day 1, certainly that is a threat most scum parties would want to get rid of in most scenarios.

If you believe otherwise, then you gotta ask, why would scum prefer to kill RDK or Arnej instead of Poyser here? Why them instead of loud voices such as Ultra, Flower, Ekko and Professor? The more you read into those kills, the less sense it makes for Poyser's kill not to come from scum.
 
Chuck said:
is it case agains lap? because as far as i can see they're the only person on both lists
Click to expand...
he's hoping we will
bite and push poyser's scum reads
when poyser is more

likely not gonna
be the mafia kill and
sparkle feels likely

to be more town than
X. basically, he is
subtly pushing us

to go for sparkle
over X here, and thinks we
won't notice wow yay!
 
Reader mode
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top