• We're looking for artists. Direct message Dr. Watson for more info!

Game Ranked Dune Mafia - town victory

Status
Not open for further replies.
Reader mode
Ultra said:
I get your point but I don't really put as much stock into it as you do. I mean his capacity to be aggressively wrong is a large part of why I'm not scum reading him, so the premise that he is never wrong about sparkles as town, while sound, is not something I care about over my own considerations.

I mean sparkles has absolutely nothing going for her, complete ass
Click to expand...
Well, yeah I guess, I can't really help that because it means were coming from completely different perspectives. Fwiw, I don't have any defence of Sparkles via her play, so I don't completely hold it against you for pushing it.
 
Aurelian said:
I'm scum for claiming when you've taken a eunuch style position of giving no real input between Ultra and Poyser, sniping from the sidelines, and then getting the audacity to call me scum when I'm the lead wagon? Get your head out of your ass.
Click to expand...
this is a bad get back attempt fang, too many inaccuracies
 
Ratchet said:
I'm feeling Ekko. Don't like his defence if Aurelian at all because all he's done is try to marry his play to other slots (why him and not them). Beyond that, I want claims from the low posters and PoE. If Aurelian flips Town then I don't know, I'd have to re-read and see. Would probably defer.
Click to expand...
its more of me having concern about ur play than defending aurelian, i dont know how u took it as such. i legit think fang is playing better than u which is pretty telling
 
Ultra said:
I'm asking you to answer a question like a normal human being and offer a plausible explanation for what would be kind of offensively transparent. Seems like a dumb assumption from you, and instead of defending it, you're posturing about it.

Tempest is basically doing the same thing but he's better than you so I'm just kinda chalking him up as scum, but I'd like to see you try a bit harder than this
Click to expand...
Yawn
 
Ratchet said:
So, the thing with Sparkles is that I have not yet seen Poyser read her wrong. So his read has a lot of value to me. And I think, as town or scum, he has an obligation to read her right. So my position woukd be that for Sparkles to be scum here, Poyser's chances of being scum go up drastically. And I guess this is a problem I have with you, because you aren't really treating Poyser like you think he's likely scum. So I have to ask, you think he would be confidently wrong on Sparkles as town?
Click to expand...
yes hes not infallible

also cud easily see posyer as scum
 
EkkoLoJinx said:
its more of me having concern about ur play than defending aurelian, i dont know how u took it as such. i legit think fang is playing better than u which is pretty telling
Click to expand...
Yeah I don't buy this one bit. Early game you had me as obvious town, now I know you've been walking that read back but at the very least, it means you've seen things from my slot that you think are townie. Now you act like I've played shit based on... I'm not sure actually, you've even called me frozen when I have over 100 posts in the thread. It's just complete dreck.
 
EkkoLoJinx said:
yes hes not infallible

also cud easily see posyer as scum
Click to expand...
You can't just dismiss it as "he can be wrong". Maybe so, but until I see it I will trust his read. And I've outlined the considerations that come with not trusting his motivations. You gonna address that any time soon, or just snipe?
 
Ratchet said:
Town Aurelian would tell me that he would never claim for me.
Click to expand...
scum aurelian never claimed for u either iirc, think ur overselling this point tbh. its closer to NAI id say, probably a mood reliant than alignment reliant thing

feel like aurelian has claimed easily as town before too, sometimes he just drops it needlessly too

think the way he defended himself was okay-ish, like he called you out from being more self-serving which i agree with
 
Reader mode
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top