• We're looking for artists. Direct message Dr. Watson for more info!

Ranked Baki Mafia

Status
Not open for further replies.
I don't blame Fang as much fwiw. Was a rough spot for him.

I think lying about an action is very tricky territory as town and deserves critique if, as he did here, completely botched it, as once you're caught in a lie there's no way out, regardless of the fact that he was cornered it's not something he should have done.
 
I think lying about an action is very tricky territory as town and deserves critique if, as he did here, completely botched it, as once you're caught in a lie there's no way out, regardless of the fact that he was cornered it's not something he should have done.
I mean, he was already in a rough spot even without that. From his pov Nibel was confirmed scum. The only issue was he acted like the item made him sure and not the fact that he literally didn't have a killing ability, so a Town Nibel would have never gotten that result.

Also from his pov the game was solved. Scum Gram and scum Flower don't derail from a Town Fang wagon onto a scum Magic wagon. And solving with that in mind isn't hard from a Town Fang pov.


But well, he was pissed and shit happens. So whatever.
 
I mean, he was already in a rough spot even without that. From his pov Nibel was confirmed scum. The only issue was he acted like the item made him sure and not the fact that he literally didn't have a killing ability, so a Town Nibel would have never gotten that result.

Also from his pov the game was solved. Scum Gram and scum Flower don't derail from a Town Fang wagon onto a scum Magic wagon. And solving with that in mind isn't hard from a Town Fang pov.


But well, he was pissed and shit happens. So whatever.

He made up a lie which everyone instantly caught onto and that solidified him as never getting out of this game without being lynched. Hard to really justify that.
 
I think lying about an action is very tricky territory as town and deserves critique if, as he did here, completely botched it, as once you're caught in a lie there's no way out, regardless of the fact that he was cornered it's not something he should have done.
I deserve flack for voting him at the end there but I couldn't pair him with anyone left except possibly Bachi? Xeno V Aurel felt real. His appeal to Gad felt real. His push on Nibel felt real. It was just like.. "God damn this dude is gonna die anyway so I need to find a reason he might be scum."

That was bad of me lol
 
He made up a lie which everyone instantly caught onto and that solidified him as never getting out of this game without being lynched. Hard to really justify that.
I don't think he was in a winnable position regardless. Scum faked info on him when he already looked like a prime suspect and the accuser was barely sussed.
 
I deserve flack for voting him at the end there but I couldn't pair him with anyone left except possibly Bachi? Xeno V Aurel felt real. His appeal to Gad felt real. His push on Nibel felt real. It was just like.. "God damn this dude is gonna die anyway so I need to find a reason he might be scum."

That was bad of me lol

Eh there was nothing wrong with voting for him under those circumstances. Before whatever bullshit he made up, his play was, from a meta standpoint, very much town and so even though he was positionally horrid (think at one point he had the entire scum team in the top of his list), what he did was basically a throw
 
I don't think he was in a winnable position regardless. Scum faked info on him when he already looked like a prime suspect and the accuser was barely sussed.

Fair, but that wouldn't be on him if the game had proceeded and he tried his best. It is now definitively on him lol
 
He made up a lie which everyone instantly caught onto and that solidified him as never getting out of this game without being lynched. Hard to really justify that.
And I'm not justifying that. The outcome would have just been the same. It's like comparing standing in heavy rain with a broken umbrella to standing in heavy rain with no umbrella. The rain gets you in any case.

So yeah, I'm not gonna bash him for it.
 
And that was pretty much my game since I subbed. I had room for a single mislynch to work with. From my pov it wasn't exactly winnable anyway.
 
Abolish yall stupid variant Indies.

Yall love over-indulging in Indies with unique win conditions or ways out of the game.
no abolish them all, cast them to fire

we can have 2 ranked subsections

the normal, mid tier, meh/10 ranked games section

and the gigachad, hard mode, all-stars, champs ranked game section - with only town and mafia
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top