• We're looking for artists. Direct message Dr. Watson for more info!

Game Ranked Darkest Dungeon Mafia - Game Thread Day 6

Status
Not open for further replies.
Exactly the same as when I gung ho called out who she was seeding there with Kurumi/Tweet/CP. If not Kurumi then I guess one of you/X could qualify, but not the first place I'd look since this is her suspect pile.
I'm not really attached to the idea that she would include a scum mate in there to be honest.
 
What the fuck are you talking about

How does it tell us nothing

Literally told us he's town you muppet
circling back to this, it doesnt really tell us tpein is town either as he can still be BP godfather or serial

aka outing his info like that was stupid asfk and its not a smoking gun toward tpein being anything. the game before and after his info is exactly the same
 
my contention is he should of held his claim for another cycle, whereby if he is a vig he can have another shot instead of out it

as BPD is usually someone that doesn't claim either it comes very show off-y. "hey guys here is a box of nothing on a plate!! look at me doing something... but dont fish for more!!!"
 
oh didnt really read this but im going to lose my role ig
the curse said i feel anger and bloodlust so i suggest no one visit me unless u can somehow heal me, thanks
angry react all the posts to show ur anger
 
my contention is he should of held his claim for another cycle, whereby if he is a vig he can have another shot instead of out it

as BPD is usually someone that doesn't claim either it comes very show off-y. "hey guys here is a box of nothing on a plate!! look at me doing something... but dont fish for more!!!"
Poorly thought out Ekko - though I do agree that it was silly. Only part I agree with is that it's out of character for him to claim anything wilfully.
 
circling back to this, it doesnt really tell us tpein is town either as he can still be BP godfather or serial

aka outing his info like that was stupid asfk and its not a smoking gun toward tpein being anything. the game before and after his info is exactly the same
Yes but he literally said that, so when you say it isn't telling us anything you're just talking shite
 
1. i wasnt making an accusation
2. my posts around psychic has nothing to do with ur "info" right here, nor my response to it. why r u even bringing it lol
3. im also not trying to bite at you, more like trying to understand what are YOU doing outing yourself then susing us for asking for more info. you've already voluntarily outed yourself, we didn't fish for it. All i'm telling you is what you are saying doesnt help anything. tpein can be BP, or godfather, or any town role given whickers role
1. This is dishonest. Last day, as soon as I cased Psychic, you immediately went to discredit me by calling my case an over sell, then said nothing more about it, except for a post later on where you tried to shade me by repeating I was over selling. Your first response to my info this day was to try and frame it in a negative way. You say you're not making an accusation, but you are acting shady towards me and trying to twist the narrative around me to make me look bad. You're doing all this without giving me a read and also saying there's no accusation.

2. This is another attempt to discredit and misdirect. I'm talking about you being wolf, not my info, so your play around Psychic's slot is definitely something I'm going to bring up. You've played just as many games with Psychic as any of us here and are normally someone that has a read or something to say about her. However, you neither pushed nor defended Psychic, and just let that slot get dummied, which I would say is very unlike you. I'm not sure why you'd sit on the fence so much around her slot last day and be nothing but a witness to the events that unfolded.

3. It does not feel like you are trying to understand what I'm doing at all. Referring to point one, instead of trying to understand my case against Psychic, you called me out for over selling. When I revealed my info today, your first response was 'sounds like you're sure you weren't role blocked'. That's not a question asked to try and understand someone (in fact you really haven't asked me any questions at all). Your subsequent responses to me this day further show you're not really trying to understand my motivations at all, and sound more accusatory than inquisitive.
 
yes i agree. but that doesn't mean it was used though. sound logic and reasoning - doesn't always equate to the solution of a problem.
Considering Whicker's D1 play and emotions, I'd say it's very likely he used his role last night. I don't think that will really help solve anything, but I'm going to guess he did use it.
 
1. This is dishonest. Last day, as soon as I cased Psychic, you immediately went to discredit me by calling my case an over sell, then said nothing more about it, except for a post later on where you tried to shade me by repeating I was over selling. Your first response to my info this day was to try and frame it in a negative way. You say you're not making an accusation, but you are acting shady towards me and trying to twist the narrative around me to make me look bad. You're doing all this without giving me a read and also saying there's no accusation.

Did Ekko actually accuse you of overselling

Because right now he's hard casing someone with a single post

:lul
 
1. This is dishonest. Last day, as soon as I cased Psychic, you immediately went to discredit me by calling my case an over sell, then said nothing more about it, except for a post later on where you tried to shade me by repeating I was over selling. Your first response to my info this day was to try and frame it in a negative way. You say you're not making an accusation, but you are acting shady towards me and trying to twist the narrative around me to make me look bad. You're doing all this without giving me a read and also saying there's no accusation.

2. This is another attempt to discredit and misdirect. I'm talking about you being wolf, not my info, so your play around Psychic's slot is definitely something I'm going to bring up. You've played just as many games with Psychic as any of us here and are normally someone that has a read or something to say about her. However, you neither pushed nor defended Psychic, and just let that slot get dummied, which I would say is very unlike you. I'm not sure why you'd sit on the fence so much around her slot last day and be nothing but a witness to the events that unfolded.

3. It does not feel like you are trying to understand what I'm doing at all. Referring to point one, instead of trying to understand my case against Psychic, you called me out for over selling. When I revealed my info today, your first response was 'sounds like you're sure you weren't role blocked'. That's not a question asked to try and understand someone (in fact you really haven't asked me any questions at all). Your subsequent responses to me this day further show you're not really trying to understand my motivations at all, and sound more accusatory than inquisitive.
i sat on the fence around psychic cuz i didn't read the game outside of first few pages, i can't really give you another answer

i thought you were overselling / replying with like 6 paragraphs to something that needed much less. or maybe like overcasing / feeling the need to output as much as you can. i felt like given how early the game was that response was too forced

and my comment about "sound you are sure you arent blocked or tpein isnt protected" is actually to try and clarify how much of a smoking gun you got. if you are confident that you arent blocked or tpein isnt protected, then yes he can be godfather or BP like you said (weird you didn't speculate serial), but if you are not sure about being blocked or about tpein not being protected, then your kill could have simply being stopped by whicker, aka you basically have nothing

if you outed this claim as a reaction test to tpein im gna call it right now - perfomrative. you aren't going to get anything from tpein with a half backed claim like that when he can easily defer to whicker saving him
 
X this feels a bit of an oversell and just overly making her scummy and ignoring that some of the stuff said here she does as town too. if psychic turns out town this needs to be looked at


Sesame Street Television GIF
 
X this feels a bit of an oversell and just overly making her scummy and ignoring that some of the stuff said here she does as town too. if psychic turns out town this needs to be looked at
@Ultra this is about two hundred posts after he called me town as well. He was also asking me to vote with him on Joygirl as well early game. So for him to call me out on over selling on Psychic, after he asked me to vote with him and town read me earlier, is pingy. Makes me thibk he didn't like I was chasing Psychic.
 
Why would mafia choose to kill Whicker out of all people when there are more active and experienced players they could go for? And yeah, I would totally kill him after me jokevoting him for calling me Dolores, would not make me look suspicious at all :pepesip
Pretty sure he used his ability, had I gotten this role it would be a no-brainer for me to use it right at first night, especially as there were rounds with 4 townies dying in a single night.

It´s more interesting who would use that curse stuff on hime.
 
i sat on the fence around psychic cuz i didn't read the game outside of first few pages, i can't really give you another answer
Are you going to fix this then? Because the current method isn't doing great to be honest, I'm having to reach to come to a town read.
 
You're first two posts here just say hmmmm and don't really give us any insight or hint at what you're thinking.

Third post you call out Joygirl and accuse her of self preservation after she voted you; basically you're sussing her because she OMGUS you. You saying you don't like her reaction is already a point made in thread. It also feels like you may be trying to link Ratchet her off pre flipping Kurumi as wolf.

Fourth post is to me. You say Melkor is hard to read but you also this game said people saying Melkor is scummy are scummy. Regardless of what you said or meant, I felt like that comment was you trying to get some sort of read or shade off people reading Melkor wolf despite you saying you yourself couldn't read Melkor. I found it hard to follow your thought process there.

Fifth post is pointless self meta talk.

Sixth post is you defending your activity. This is one of the reasons I decided to follow a vote on you. Wolf Psychic definitely likes to lurk and had enough time to like and react posts, so I don't give you any benefit of the doubt for not being around. Your desire to defend your activity is also something wolf Psychic does. This is similar to how you played in Dresden Files.

Seventh post is kind if useless comment on TSA.

Eighth post is to me. One reason I already explained. Another reason is I haven't really followed any of your thinking or catchup and to me it feels more mailed in than authentic.
this is the post i called oversell. i suppose it looks better after her flip and im in no position to sus people for putting in effort. i personally felt like a smaller response would suffice and this back then came off to me like forced contribution
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top