• We're looking for artists. Direct message Dr. Watson for more info!

Game Ranked Hades Mafia - Game Thread

Dofla is claiming Orpheus and Vanilla town.
Also I don't think Watson would claim something like this as scum.
 
At some point yall need to stop treating Orca like the class Gerbil and hold him accountable for his positions, he has 0 progression on Poyser since reading him at start of the game. If T-Pein posted this crap he'd probably be in the dirt.
 
They're so nice >.>

That's so rude!
This feels like a pocketing attempt. Given his enthusiasm overall in the beginning I do read him sincere tonally.
Town
Nibel

Xadlin
Magic
Lord Melkor
Hans
Dr. Watson
Polar Bear
Alco
Dofia
Ekkko
Scum
He's started his lists (NAI) early here, I see.
Why vote Nibel over me here? I'm very clearly trying harder.
-1 for lousy reasoning
The Orca had a townie vote. I think that Hans has hard town told by this point. I am very easily pocketable so >.<
I do agree with his take on Orca & Hans. Why he noted he's easily pocketable doesn't compute. Need further elaboration to pick his brains. Luka, if you strongly town read both of them, are you saying you're worried they're pocketing you somehow due to it?
They’re town and you guys are scum!
I can go into more depth later, sorry! Kind of hate explaining on my phone.
You need to expand more often - alot of these posts give nothing to work off of for most of us.
Nope! I forget why they were evil, so I need to go into my pc to iso! Nothing about paragraphs.
Did you?
T is a coinflip, fwiw. Many players regardless of alignment do open with this sort of thing, so this is quite a weak observation to me.
I can explain my list very well? I would just very prefer not to.
What's the reason for this? Why the reluctancy?
I don't love the question list. Doesn't feel like its contrubting much, but I wont call it inherintly wolfie. Going into the null section to be honest >.<

I think that this might be a possible distancing attempt with them. Nothing definitive.
Scattering reads all over the place is going to be a drag to sort through later on, my guy. You have definitive reads (or so it seems), what is it about certain players that make you struggle with reading them?
What motives, what characteristics, what types of profiles match with scum and town? You haven't delved into this very much if at all - specifically why you even read me as Town to begin with.
Tracks.


More of this. Town points given.
1. No
2. ?
3. Elaborate
4. Elaborate
5. Context since I'm skimming most of the thread
Town
Nibel
Hans
Dr. Watson
Xadlin

Ratchet
Aurelia

Magic
Ultra

Voyer
The Orca
Polar Bear
Game

Lord Melkor
T-Pein

Dofia
Ekko

Alco
Scum

This is likely aligned! Feels confident, smug, outfacing. Not hiding anything, in that they genuinly always think they caught a scum.
Observational
So your ISOs feel like they've progressed naturally - when you're scum, you tend to work yourself into a frenzy and wait endgame to establish them (imo.)

I think your slot is town, but you need to put in more work.

Phone posting sucked for me originally, but you have to suck it up or you're going to quickly go into the null pile.

I do like your ISO and how early on you did it, but I'm not comfortable discounting you switching up your play as potential wolf here.

Tl;DR
The potential natural flow as Town!Luka vs wolfing

+ Your enthusiasm strikes me as sincere, possibly due to not rolling wolf
+ Your ISOs and read lists aren't given via pressure, you're keeping track of the thread and player behavior and what's alignment indicative or not
- Your play as wolf might be reverse psychology
- You're pocketing me assuming due to my read on you I won't rescind it

No offense, I don't know if you have the ability to do this type of thing as wolf, but we shall see

Strong town unless it needs to be re-evaluated and you ring alarm bells
 
I wouldn't say it flips my read, but I do think there is something to be said for it - if a scum team is struggling for claims someone claiming easily in that team is jarring.

I didn't like this because it seemed like a needless elaboration from you based on gamestate reasoning. There's a lot of ways this can be easily explained, including Dofla having a role sheet that is mostly passive, or him just taking the safe route of a vanilla town without much strategic forethought.

What's more relevant is if this is something you can see Dofla doing, drawing a relation to whatever Ekko/Watson is doing is meh especially before they've flipped
 
Not sure what to make of the claim from retro but tweet summed it up pretty well. She’s on borrowed time either way s
 
Orca, your read on Ultra is prolapsed ass

Are you sure you're just not spite voting and mischaracterizing because you want him to be scum? Or are you implying you simply don't trust him day 1?

He's playing his town game to a T and taking a leadership position which is fairly easy to spot from the getgo

Can you explain